Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Why Must The Fun Stop With The Turner

Posts

Why Must The Fun Stop With The Turner

#1

Why Must The Fun Stop With The Turner

charlie belden

>Let's admit it, underneath the aesthetics and proportions, tools and techniques, turning is fun - and at times exciting. For me, at its best, turning is play. Why should the fun and excitement end when we're done with a piece?

You've been to a gallery or museum where turned pieces are on display. If you're lucky, you've also been to a Childrens Discovery Museum or Exploratorium. In the former, the atmosphere is typically like that of a library or church (or synagogue or mosque or temple). People talk in hushed tones and observe - but only with their eyes. (OK - se "openings" can get pretty roudy and loud and maybe even playful - but then it's back to ADULT mode)

Now think of a kid's "museum". Kids are bopping around, poking and turning and lifting and cranking and climbing - into, on and around things - often chattering up a storm, smiling, sometimes quizzically, and often laughing. The "exhibits", if they're done well, engage them - all of them - sight, sound, touch, sometimes even smell - AND - their brains.

Why do we, as "adults" get stuck with the staid (sp?), the stodgy (sp?), the still and static. Why do we overlook kids - or the kid in all of us? Why don't WE get "exhbits" WE can play with and explore?

I think part of it is that WE, as turners, don't make enough things you can actually pick up and play with.

What if the "function" of Form Follows Function is PLAY?

What would the design criteria be for a piece for a Childrens Discovery Museum? Sure- durability would be important, as would safety (no sharp edges, no pointy stuff) - but what about the "engaging" criteria?

Could exhibits be designed to constrain potentially harmful things while still allowing for exploration and experiencing more than just the visual appearance of the pieces? A padded floor plex enclosure with holes to reach into, but not be able to remove the piece inside, would allow handling. Or maybe the piece is fixed to its stand - but has holes in it for fingers to explore the inside - which could have interesting textures - or even fur - and maybe small objects inside as well - too large to be removed yet still explorable.

Linus Pauling had an interesting deduction exercise for his students. He'd put a polyhedrom inside a small cardboard box and seal the box. The students' job was to manipulate the box and listen and feel what happened when they did. From that information they were to deduce the shape of the object in the box. A ball will behave one way, a cylinder another, a cone another, a pyramid another and a cube yet another way. Putting them in a cylindrical tube might add an additional challenge.

A sherical box, with a small ball inside - holes of different sizes in the sides of the box - only ONE large enough for the ball inside. Texture the outside to add more sensory stimulation.

As a bonus - the blind would get to play as well. Why have we overlooked THEM! And what about folks with palsy. Wouldn't it be great to have their "disorder" work FOR them - moving and shaking a piece - changing the balance - and generating sound?

What would a piece be like if it could only be manipulated by your feet?

Just playing with ideas and questions they generate.

Care to play?

Re: Why Must The Fun Stop With The Turner

#2

Re: Why Must The Fun Stop With The Turner

Jim Rutten

>I have often wondered if there was anything I could turn that would help patients at my wife's work with physical rehab.

Re: Why Must The Fun Stop With The Turner

#3

Steven Antonucci

How is the better question...

Steve antonucci

>I think that the challenge isn't "why" should the fun stop, but more "how" do you make turnings interactive? Too thin, and they will break. Too heavy, and you can't interact...

When I was at the Woodturning Center and looking at Schreiber's work, there was almost a sense of fear to interact with it. Turnings are very difficult to interact with because of the nature of the material. Wood dents and dings or cracks if dropped.

Unless you decide that fun is fleeting and long term viability isn't a concern, I don't know how to get around this. Just today, I found a magic wand I turned a few years back snapped in two pieces in the yard. Seems that the boys like to use them like swords when they think nobody is looking...

Steve

Re: Why Must The Fun Stop With The Turner

#4

Re: Why Must The Fun Stop With The Turner

charlie belden

>Jim Rutten asked:

I have often wondered if there was anything I could turn that would help patients at my wife's work with physical rehab.

======================

Pop lid box - grip, eye hand coordination - and maybe a surprise inside as motivation? Have pattern or maybe just the grain for alignment - again working on eye-hand coordination - but using a twisting motion - working the grip and fine motor skills.

Finials with different sized tenons - and a nicely figured maple board with corresponding sized holes. Works on visually gauging size of tenon and size of hole, eye hand coordination for fitting - or test fitting - the finials to the holes - and if you do it right - visually stimulating finials.

Flat top and bottom turnings of various sizes and shapes - to stack and unstack - with one hand or two. Add textures and colors and designs to include visual stimulation - and boredom delay.

Re: Why Must The Fun Stop With The Turner

#5

Re: How is the better question...

charlie belden

>Steve:

I think one of the things that would make interaction possible is to make things that are interesting to play with - but not delicate, or two heavy - or two precious - to the turner.

A bowl with an overhanging rim - and some texturing on the inside would make some interesting noises if you could move the bowl and have a ball roll around inside - over the texture. Doesn't have to be out of an exotic wood, or have "turner thin walls", or a whole lot of refined details turned in it. It's not to LOOK AT but to PLAY WITH.

Schreiber's "tops" and "plates" don't HAVE to be so delicate and refined for them to work - as things to play with - and maybe discover something.

Maybe by elevating the quality of our turnings - we've put them out of actual reach - to use, or play with. Perhaps we've increased our expectation of what a turning is to do beyond what is needed for them to work - more fully.

Somewhere between a pedestal and a toy box, there's room for these pieces people, of all ages can interact with and enjoy.

And if a piece gets dinged or in someway damaged to the point that it can't be played with - have another on hand to replace it.

Just as an example. I turned maybe a dozen little spinning tops and took them to an elementary school and showed them to kids while waiting for the neighbors kid to show up for her ride home. I just sat down on the walkway and started spinning these little tops. Kids watched and when invited to play - did. They were surprised at how much fun they were to play with - and they didn't need batteries. In no time kids were showing other kids how to spin them and one kid figured out how to make them spin - point up - and got busy teaching other kids how to do it.

When "my" kid finally showed up all the tops were in use - with their new owners. And one of the kids was showing a teacher how to spin a top "upside down".

The Lone Ranger left silver bullets behind and departed with a Hi Ho Silver - Away! I left spinning tops behind - with a Have Fun With It! And I don't have a mask- or a horse - to deal with.

It can be done - but it requires that you value the turning in terms of what it can do rather than the time, effort and thought that went into it.

Re: Why Must The Fun Stop With The Turner

#6

Re: How is the better question...

Pete in Holland, MI

>We had a man speak at our woodworker's guild meeting several months back on children's toys. He designed and built them for several years.

One of the traits of a good toy, is that a child will want to pick it up and play with it. It's purpose has to be plainly evident. The right sizes, shapes, colors all come into play. He had several examples of toys that were all similar in concept (a dump truck, I think). Some were more appealing to young kids, others to older adults. Gotta know your market.

Re: Why Must The Fun Stop With The Turner

#7

Re: Why Must The Fun Stop With The Turner

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Charlie, I was a participant in an exhibit that was geared toward the sight impaired. Every person who participated knew that these pieces would be touched and handled. It was quite fun to make something that you knew the intended purpose was to touch. It was the first time I incorporated brass BB's into my work. There should be more exhibits like this one. Touching and experiencing a piece of turned wood is often as wonderful as just looking and whispering at it.

Jen