Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Working big vs. working small

Posts

Working big vs. working small

#1

Steven Antonucci

Working big vs. working small

Steve antonucci

>One of the weird things that I've noticed over time is as follows: working big vs working small generall take the same amount of time.

With big wood, most people use bigger tools. They have bigger lathes. The wood is securely fastened and can be cut very aggressively.

Small wood, and you need to work with smaller tools, but you also need to pay a lot more attention to details. Mistakes show a lot better on smaller objects. They're handled more often and you can feel a rough spot or a missed curve that you might not het on a big bowl.

Which do you prefer? throwing lots of shavings over your shoulder or refining small details? What "turns" you on?

Steve

Re: Working big vs. working small

#2

Re: Working big vs. working small

john lucas

>Working big also requires a lot more sanding, a lot more time finishing and lot bigger mess to clean up. So even though the turning might go faster, and I'm not sure it does, there is a lot more to making a big piece.

I've also heard from people who sell big that the market is somewhat limited because people don't have the room on their shelves for big work. I design pieces based on what the piece needs. If it has to be large to work then I make it big. If it needs to be small, well you know I can make small.

Re: Working big vs. working small

#3

Brad Vietje

Re: Working big vs. working small

Brad Vietje

>Steve,

If I had to pick one answer, I like rough turning big pieces of green wood. Its a whole lot of fun keeping 20' of Maple linguine in the air, and pretty impressive for newbies to see. If I've had a stressful day, its fun to just spin a wet Poplar log between centers and make the shavings fly!

BUT, I also like making really fine spindles, ornaments, and finely detailed tops and such. Just seems there are a lot more days for green turning than those when I'm in the mood for fine detail work!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Working big vs. working small

#4

It's All Good

Texian

>

Re: Working big vs. working small

#5

Big is more fun

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>As Brad said,

Flying ribbons of wet wood are fun, I love that and as John says, sanding big is a PITA.

I enjoy small stuff too, but if I have the time and the wood, big is my natural inclination.

Jorge

Re: Working big vs. working small

#6

Re: Working big vs. working small

GalenV in Iowa

>Steve:

You said: "Mistakes show a lot better on smaller objects'

Guess I need to get rid of my little Jet 1220 and get the BIGGEST lathe made so I can turn BIG pieces, then I can hide the mistakes I make better. Good justifcation for a new bigger lathe!

Here I thought it was just my lack of experience and did not know I could fool someone into thinking I am a better turner if my pieces are larger.

:>)

Galen

Re: Working big vs. working small

#7

Both

Fog Tanner

>I do some large pieces in the 22"-23" range. But I also core these so I start with a 3" bowl in the center, so that covers small to large. Each has its own challenge and reward, a journey unto itself.

I also enjoy making boxes with suction fit lids. I find these more demanding than a large bowl when looking for the correct fit. Turning them thin offers another challenge. I look at these as a welcome change to bowls.

Right now, my greatest satisfaction comes from eccentric work. It is a bit differnt from bowls and boxes. A new usage and limits of tools, along with those of the person on the other end of the handle. A simple eccentric bowl becomes a greater challenge than a nice box. And turning them thin provides new excitement.

Endgrain, facegrain, or eccentric - each provides its own pleasure. I am presented with the opporunity to make something from a piece of wood, and I owe it to the wood to do the best that I can and enjoy the journey. The wood is given a second life and I am given a new adventure, I would call it an even trade.

Fog

Re: Working big vs. working small

#8

Re: Working big vs. working small

charlie belden

>BIG is a relative term - to someone on a JET mini/midi - with a 10" diam. max limit - 10" is BIG. To a Stubby 750 or VB or big OneWay, 10" diameter may be small.

In the JET mini context, which is the only context I have, turning really small is quite challenging, a very small misstep -probably not noticed on a BIG turning - can mean disaster - actually a mini-disaster. No blood, no concussion, no broken rib - or arm - but the piece is destroyed. And sneaking up on a pop-fit is seldom part of the turning BIG experience.

I'm sure there are great experiences turning BIGI'm not aware of, nor can appreciate. But I am thinking about doing some turning on a little "micro" UniMat. The idea of using a Dust Buster as my dust collection system is intriqueing.

Since I'm interested in actual movement in a finished piece - small is a lot easier than BIG (though the idea of putting a Roomba under or in a piece would open up some interesting possibilities).

In the end, it's a personal thing - and to each his/her own. There's plenty of room in wood turning for everyone.

Re: Working big vs. working small

#9

Re: Working big vs. working small

Carole Valentine

>I turn fair number of minis (2 1/2" and under). To me, it is more difficult to carve (and especially to sand) small pieces and any defects really leap out at me. Also, the smaller the piece, the harder it is to showcase spectacular grain. On the plus side, hollowing small pieces is not nearly as hard on my elbows and hands and they don't move as much during the process as the larger ones.

Re: Working big vs. working small

#10

Wood movement is very different

john lucas

>Thanks for bringing that up Carole. Smaller items are usually turned thinner which reduces the chances of checking also.

Re: Working big vs. working small

#11

Re: Working big vs. working small

Philip Morris

>I have found that I am tending toward smaller turnings.

In addition to all the reasons mentioned herein, I find that since being diagnosed and treated for heart failure, harvesting 30" logs is not the fun it once was.

Still appreciate turning the smaller pieces on a larger more stable lathe, though.

Re: Working big vs. working small

#12

Re: Working big vs. working small

Don Orr

>I find myself working on smaller projects more and more. I can only go so big with my lathe anyway (Jet1642). I think working small is more of a challenge for me-details, proportion, form all become more important to get "right". Tool control becomes essential. A heavy, stable lathe with electronic VS and reverse really help. Big is fun though.

Re: Working big vs. working small

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: Working big vs. working small

Mike Stafford

>My initial reason for turning was to learn to turn boxes; so small has always been a part of my repertoire (if I have one). Later I became interested in turning small semi-enclosed forms i.e. orts bowls.

Now I am going to venture into larger turnings, larger in diameter but not necessarily in depth as I hope to turn platters and wall hangings. I have been accumulating large thick boards and blanks just for this purpose so I hope to branch out a bit.

My first love will always be boxes but I must say I enjoy swinging the occasional platter. A stable lathe is required for both in my opinion.

Re: Working big vs. working small

#14

Re: Working big vs. working small

Jeff Willaford

>With a Jet mini 1014 and a workspace of about 10'x3' I enjoy every little piece of wood I turn. Bowl, spindle or hf... it's all a learning curve for me and I like it all.