Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Club Lathe - Which One

Posts

Club Lathe - Which One

#1

Club Lathe - Which One

E.T.

>Hello Woodturners, Our club needs to have it's own lathe for meeting demos and workshops.

It should be:

1. semi - porttable, easily moved by two people even if it has to be partially dissassembled,

2. run on 110 volts,

3. multi speed pulleys means no hassle problems with elenctronic controllers that act up or pack it in prematurely,

4. 1 1/4 inch spindle preferred but 1" would be OK,

What would you suggest?

What lathe(s) does your club have?

ET

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#2

JL

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

JL

>Why not the new Delta "midi" lathe? That certainly is a nice, powerful, portable lathe. It isn't a pulley machine though - it is an electronic variable speed.

Another thought - how about a Jet 1442? It weighs in at ~350 lbs with the legs. It is reasonable powerful nice size lathe. It could be moved. It is a pulley lathe. I've seen two people move a 1642 around (without the headstock), so that could be considered.

General has their "maxi" lathe (25-200 M1) - which fits your specs - except for the electronic variable speed.

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#3

Steven Antonucci

Nova?

Steve antonucci

>Not sure about your budget or size requirements, but I suspect that two folks could carry a Nova if you broke it down? None of the parts are so heavy that you'd need two people.

My clubs has a Oneway 1224 and a bunch of Oneways. The first club moves they lathe frequently, but not for long distance. the second club's lathe do not move.

Steve

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#4

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

Russ Fairfield

>A lot of clubs have the Nova lathes, both the old 3000, and the new one. They are good 16" machines and they are relatively portable.

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#5

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

Greg Haugen

>Our club is having similar conversations. Here are a few points that we're taking into account.

Demonstrations-can the lathe handle "any" demonstration option; is it big enough to core bowls or for a captured hollowing system? Yes, even mini lathes "can" do these jobs but put yourself in the shoes of the demonstrator.

Voltage-110 is available, 220 would be an additional cost to set up.

Portability-We have "storage" at our location so casters would be fine since it could be rolled out and back in.

Service- No sense in spending money on a lathe through a catalog if no one locally can service it.

We're still in the process of researching things out but the Jet 1642 and Novas have come up in the 110V range and the Large Rikon and Powermatic in the 220V range.

My personal lathe is currently the Jet 1642 on which I do core bowl regularly and a friend of mine is a Jamieson fanatic and I don't think it ever leaves the lathe. It's hard to dispute its versatility. To be fair the only "con" is the banjo and the height issue with some rests.

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#6

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

Ralph

>Another point to consider is the Horse Power of the lathe, a 3/4 or 1 HP lathe is less able to be used for heavy projects then a 1-1/2 HP lathe. So the smaller lathe(s) would limit what Demonstrators could do.

Another reason for something like the Nova.

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#7

Re: Club Lathe - Which One *LINK*

Fred Holder

>The Northwest Washington Woodturners, which I've belonged to since its beginning in February 1996, have tried several different lathes and have finally settled on the Nova DVR XP. They find it easier to move than the Jet of the same size that they had before the Nova. The Nova is mounted on a set of rollers that can be flipped out of the way when being used, or flipped under the lathe when ready to move.

I personally have had a Nova DVR for eight years, or shortly after they became available in the US. It has handled any thing that I have wished to turn. It handles coring nicely and with the extra bed section I purchased it handles the Jamieson Hollowing system easily. I don't think I've ever seen a club demonstration that the Nova DVR can't handle.

If your club doesn't want to spend that much money, the Nova 16-24/42 would be a good buy. It has step pulleys to change the speed and is actually an updated Nova 3000, which I also owned for several years before the Nova DVR became available.


More Woodturning Website

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#8

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

Scott in Socal

>I'd say the Nova 1624-44 fits the bill perfectly. 1 1/4" spindle, 1.5hp, 16" swing with outboard, step pulleys that you could later upgrade to EVS by replacing the motor, 251 lbs assembled.

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#9

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

John Jordan

>I demonstrate for a lot of clubs, and the Jet 1642 would be my choice every time. It will accommodate just about anything that will come up in a demo. A very good value for the club's money.

John

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#10

Re: Nova?

Jim Sebring

>My club has a Nova DVR XP with the sheet metal legs on casters. It works well for all of our demonstrators. We also have eight Jet 1014vs machines that are used for group activities and classes.

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#11

Fred.. Why the link?

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>It was my understanding that it was a no no here.

But I have been wrong before. :)

Dave

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#12

Can't believe you didn't say Stubby :)

john lucas

>

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#13

Rob Wallace

Re: Can't believe you didn't say Stubby :)

Rob Wallace

>John L.

Condition #1 was being "semi-portable".... doubt that a Stubby would even make it past "semi-"....

I agree with the Jet 1642 recommendation. The Nova is a good lathe to be sure, but I've never been a fan of swiveling headstocks, and the sliding head of the Jet 1642 (and Mustard monster) is a BIG plus in my book.

Rob Wallace

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#14

Thank You - Everyone

E. Tabachek

>Thank you for taking time to reply. I appreciate your effort and advise. I looked at the 1624-44 specs on the Teknatool web site and that lathe looks like it would suit our club quite well. Now, I just have to get the club executive on board.

ET

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#15

Re: Can't believe you didn't say Stubby :)

john lucas

>I agree also. Our club has a 1642 and of course I turn on the mustard monster which works the same. I've owned a Nova and the new one is a lot better than my old one in a lot of ways but I still like the Jet better.

All you need is a good engine hoist and your Stubby would be portable. :)

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#16

Re: Can't believe you didn't say Stubby :)

Rick Allen

>One of the many selling points of the Stuby is that the lathe comes apart so that two men can move the lathe.

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#17

Steven Antonucci

If you own a Semi, the stubby is portable :-)

Steve antonucci

>if it has a liftgate...

Re: Club Lathe - Which One

#18

Mike Stafford

I unloaded and assembled my Stubby by myself...

Mike Stafford

>One of the selling points for me was that I could move the Stubby in a disassembled form by myself. The heaviest piece is around 160 pounds so you can move it onto the stand and build the rest of the lathe on top of it. Of course there are several heavy pieces and by the end of the process you will need a cold glass of tea....