Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

a great day and review of 2 tools, long

Posts

a great day and review of 2 tools, long

#1

a great day and review of 2 tools, long

MFoster

>I had a great day yesterday. I participated in the VT open studio weekend and had my doors open to the public. I didn't have many sales, but did have a number of woodturners and woodworkers stop in to chat. One of the wood turners, Ralph Tursini, was a demonstrator at Pinkerton on Sat. who lives in the Burlington area and decided to stop in on his way to a short visit with Johannes Michelson who lives west of me and was also a demonstrator at Pinkerton. (I really hated having to miss being at the symposium). We had a really nice chat and Ralph seemed like a great guy. One of the other turners who stopped in had taken lessons with Johannes and wound up buying a Mustard lathe from him. Talk seems to be spreading about getting a local turners club together for the Southern VT area. That would be nice as other clubs around are just too far away.

I actually had some time to turn yesterday as well. Most of my shop time lately has been eaten up by a project for the house. I built a wall of built-in book shelves and another wall with a built-in desk/computer station. It is a great addition, but I'm glad it's done. So I decided to try out a tool that I picked up while attending the Totally Turning/Showcase event. I watched Rolly Munro demo hollowing and surface decoration, and was so impressed with his hollower, I decided to buy one. What a sweet tool. I chucked up a block of wood and decided to really put it through it's paces. I used his tool for the whole piece, roughing, shaping the outside and hollowing. I did break down and picked up a gouge to fair the curve and put a nice surface on the outside. I don't usually turn real thin, but thought I would see what the Munro could do. The walls on this vase are between 1/16 and 1/8" and I did not use any other tool (hollower or scraper) to clean up the inside. The surface was really pretty nice straight from the Munro. I did have a few bumps deeper in the vessel that took a little more sanding than the rest, but I was impressed overall. I have several hollowers including a Jamieson rig, some Jordan hollowers and a Hunter. I also have had some Woodcut Proforme hollowers. I never really liked the Proforme tools. I found they clogged easily, and were really fussy to adjust and never really thought I could turn any better with them. The Munro is nothing like that. I literally took it out of the box and turned this vase with only a very minimal learning curve. I haven't needed to sharpen it yet, but that seems straight forward and if you want, you can use a Hunter carbide insert in it as well. I felt comfortable and had no problem reaching 7" over the tool rest to hollow this piece. I drilled my depth hole a little shallow, but the Munro did fine without it deepening the vessel and even removing that pesky nib with minimal fussing. It's fun to use this tool and nice to produce shavings instead of dust, even deep into a form. I give the Munro a big thumbs up.

After hollowing, I wanted to sand the piece and thought it was time to try out another tool that has been gathering dust in my shop. I bought one of the Sanding Glove's passive sanding tools (The Sanding Solution) over a year ago but never turned something I could use it on. This form was perfect. I didn't really want to try to get a drill, or drill with extensions into this form. This passive sander works great. You have to be a little more patient, as it is a passive sander, but if you let it work it does a great job. The handle is really nice and gives complete control. Sanding the inside of a flexing, warping vessel was a breeze. Another nice tool.

Both of these tools are a bit pricey, but really live up to their claims. I admit to being somewhat of a tool junkie, (like some others on this forum), but these are a couple of sweet tools that will definitely see some use in my shop. Not affiliated with either turner or tool maker, just a satisfied customer.

So now I have to figure out what to do with this vase. I have not been all that interested in piercing, but I think I see that in it's future. I have the tools needed and the walls are right for it, it's pretty bland and I don't care if I wreck it. May be fun to give it a go. Split leaf maple 7.25"h x 6"d.

Mike


img

Re: a great day and review of 2 tools, long

#2

Rob Wallace

Re: a great day and review of 2 tools, long

Rob Wallace

>Mike:

Thanks for the review. I also have both of these tools, and agree with your assessments. The leaning curve on the Munro hollower is pretty short and not too steep.....When I discussed clogging the tool with Rolly at a recent AAW Symposium, he said the key was to take a smaller cut and to have the tool adjusted carefully so that the cutter sees the tangent point of the cutting surface most of the time. I also added some lead shot to the handle to give a bit more heft and balance; I found that I got a more control with the handle somewhat heavier; give it a try.

One word of caution regarding the aluminum handle and knob supplied with the tool. Be careful about not over-tightening the knob - with the soft aluminum, you can easily strip-out the threads. I did this quite easily without applying much tightening force. I haven't re-drilled/re-tapped another hole yet (....anyone know the threading on the Munro handle knob?), but just be careful about this. It would have been nicer to have a steel handle for this part of the tool.

Good luck with the new toys! (I also am a confirmed tool junkie, who refuses any 12-step program to "cure" my condition.)

Rob Wallace