Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Heavy scraper...

Posts

Heavy scraper...

#1

Heavy scraper...

Marc Phillips

>I have one of those large heavy scrapers... 1 1/2" I think...

I remember using it once quite a while ago and loved the way it cleaned up the transition area of the bowl I was working on and made it very easy to get a nice curve there... Normally I do the whole bowl with a 1/2" bowl gouge with a fingernail grind.

Anyway, I was working on a Sweetgum green (sorta) bowl (11" X 4") yesterday and thought "that scraper would work great on this transition curve" and sharpened it up....

.... and all it wanted to do was catch... and catch... and catch... changed the tool rest height, tried changing the angle of attack... catch, catch, catch.... had the Oneway curved tool rest very close to the wood... more catches....

Went back the bowl gouge laid over on it's side and finished scraping/light cutting that area and finished the bowl...

So... what was up with that? The last time I used that heavy gouge I had beautiful ribbons coming off of it, almost no effort at all as it glided across the surface... now I can't get it to work at all. :mad:

Any help?


img

Re: Heavy scraper...

#2

It's the turning gremlins at work

Carole Valentine

>The next time you use it, they will have moved on to someone else's shop....probably mine! LOL

Looks like you didn't need it anyway. Nice piece.

Re: Heavy scraper...

#3

Re: Heavy scraper...

Bill Howatt

>Couple of thoughts:

The burr on a freshly sharpened scraper can be quite aggressive.

I also find that thin-walled or weak-walled bowls can have enough flex in them to cause the cutter to dig-in - similar mechanism as turnng an out-of-round bowl. A bowl-steady helps in this situation.

Bill

Re: Heavy scraper...

#4

Re: Heavy scraper...

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Was the bowl thin? My guess is the wood was vibrating.

Re: Heavy scraper...

#5

Re: Heavy scraper...

john lucas

>There are 3 things I can think of. Did you have the handle higher than the cutting edge, were you cutting on or slightly above center, and were you taking a light cut. If it's not one of those I would have to stand and watch what your doing.

Re: Heavy scraper...

#6

Re: Heavy scraper...

Dale Cook

>Hi Marc, I sometimes use a large heavy scraper to clean up on final cuts. I put a negative rake angle on it,where you grind down the top cutting edge so you are scrapping from below the top of the scraper.I flip the scraper over and grind an angle down about a 1/4 inch then flip it back to regular position and sharpen. It has to be sharpen quite often but it makes a great finishing cut,very fine shavings. It also take away almost all catches.You could try this on an older scarper or one you don't use much to see if you like it.

Re: Heavy scraper...

#7

Re: Heavy scraper...

David Belser

>You can use a very fine diamond hone and "remove" the bur by laying the hone flat on the top of the scraper after grinding. As stated previously in this thread, the bur on a scraper can be very aggressive right off of the grinder.

Re: Heavy scraper...

#8

Pic of scraper profile?

Adrien Coblentz

>

Re: Heavy scraper...

#9

Re: Heavy scraper...

robo hippy

>Hmmmm... I love scrapers, and have a couple that are 1 1/4 to 1 1/2 inch wide by 3/8 thick. Now for finish cuts on the inside of the bowl, and on the outside as well, I have the scraper at a 45 degree angle making a shear cut as opposed to flat on the tool rest making a scraping cut. I consider a scraping cut to be more for roughing as it will 'pull' at the fibers more and cause more tear out. It is also more agressive. Catches with it seem to come from two things. One is hanging too far off the tool rest, and you get overpowered by not having enough lever on your side of the tool rest to be able to counter. Also, if you are in the transition area, and the radius of the transition is smaller than the radius scraper (scraper big curve, bowl transition small curve), you will be getting a lot of wood on the tool all at once as you come into the transition, and can be overpowered by the lathe. You can change this by going from a scraping cut to a shear cut, or use a smaller scraper. With the scraper at a shear angle, you can actually do a pull cut on the inside, pulling from the bottom towards the rim. I know, this is backwards to how you are supposed to cut, but because you are at a shear angle, and taking such light cuts, it works.

It didn't sound like you were working the rim of the bowl and having catches. You can get them here. The rim is thin, and doesn't have much mass, so any pressure on it will make it start to vibrate. Usually this is accompained by some rather loud screeching and howling noises. You have noticed that this doesn't happen on the outside of the bowl, at least not before the center is removed. As the edge starts to vibrate, you go from cutting air to wood rather rapidly, and the oscilations of the bowl rim can suddenly put a lot of wood on the cutting edge of the tool, and you get an explosion. You can fix this, again by doing a very gentle shear cut, and use your hand on the outside of the bowl rim as a steady rest. Very light cuts are taken, any your hand pressure is the same as your tool pressure. On samller bowls, this isn't much of a problem, but on larger ones it is. On the larger ones, you have to do your finish cuts in stages. Cut to final thickness an inch or 2 at a time, and then do your finish shear cuts, then down another inch or 2, till you get to the bottom.

robo hippy

Re: Heavy scraper...

#10

Re: Heavy scraper...

Marc Phillips

>Yea... it was really getting thin at that point... ended up being only 3/16" thick after sanding... thanks...

Re: Heavy scraper...

#11

Re: Heavy scraper...

Marc Phillips

>"Did you have the handle higher than the cutting edge"

Yes... the handle was being held a little higher than the cutting edge..

"were you cutting on or slightly above center"

I was at or slightly lower than center....

"and were you taking a light cut"

Very, very light.... the bowl was really getting thin and I just wanted to barely smooth out a couple of tool marks...

"I would have to stand and watch what your doing"

One of these days John.... one of these days! ... first opportunity to have some hands on training and I am all over it like ugly on a monkey!

Re: Heavy scraper...

#12

Re: Heavy scraper...

Marc Phillips

>Like this? ... this is a new one on me....


img

Re: Heavy scraper...

#13

Re: Heavy scraper...

Marc Phillips

>Never thought of that... I will give it a try... thanks...

Re: Heavy scraper...

#14

Pic of scraper profile.... 

Marc Phillips

>


img

Re: Heavy scraper...

#15

Re: Heavy scraper... *LINK*

Bill Howatt

>That's the basic idea. It is called a negative rake.

Have a look at the link below.

Bill


Negative Rake Scraper

Re: Heavy scraper...

#16

Re: Heavy scraper...

Marc Phillips

>Thanks Bill... that link explained it well. I will try that with a tool I am not using... turn it into a negative rake scraper and then road test it....

Re: Heavy scraper...

#17

Re: Heavy scraper...

Dale Cook

>Yes, mine is a rounded edge scraper ground like your picture.It will take away most all catches and cuts very fine shavings.