Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

WHAT has happened ??

Posts

WHAT has happened ??

#1

WHAT has happened ??

Russ Fairfield

>The "Nattering Nabobs of Negativity" have won.

This forum used to be the best place on the Internet to discuss the technical issues of woodturning. What has happened that one of the the best known makers of hollow forms, and the first one to present a captured hollowing system to the woodturning community, feels it necessary to post the following message??

"I guess this is not the place to address all the technical issues like set-up, laser vibration, back rest position, home built issues but Id love to chat with any of you at Provo or Albuquerque about what I have done to solve these issues or any other subject you want to chat about."

Wood Central has indeed changed.

Re: WHAT has happened ??

#2

Re: WHAT has happened ??

Sean Troy

>Just a little spring fever going around, it'll pass .

Re: WHAT has happened ??

#3

Steven Antonucci

Do you really want to know?

Steve antonucci

>Lyle was wrong. He tried to explain what had happened that cause my vessel to break (after I had already explained it) and offer a solution that was completely irrelevant to the problem at hand.

I merely pointed out that he hadn't presented a solution to my problem nor had he diagnosed it correctly. I wasn't Lyle bashing any more than I took his post as Steve bashing... but a captured tool would not have prevented what I did and people need to know that there are no guaranteed ways or quick fixes to push your own limits and that mistakes happen when you are tired.

That's what I saw.

Steve

Re: WHAT has happened ??

#4

Re: Do you really want to know?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>That is the way I read it as well Steve,

Take care,

Jim

Re: WHAT has happened ??

#5

When folks react in anger ...

Ed Moore of SW VA

>they are probably over-reacting and will probably say something emotional or stupid or both.

1. Not every comment must be taken personally.

2. Life is not a reality show and one's personal feelings are probably not being sought ad nauseum.

3. Only the author of a comment truly knows his motives.

4. Differences of opinion are healthy - unless you are sky-diving. There may be a right and a wrong method in that case.

5. Look for humor, not for hurt. Lighten up.

These comments are intended as being a little thought-provoking on the general malaise that seems to have absorbed the thread that Lyle started. Basically, I am agreeing with Russ, who may or may not see it that way.

Have a Wonderful Mother's day!

Ed

Re: WHAT has happened ??

#6

Steven Antonucci

There's the issue:I didn't read reaction as angry?

Steve antonucci

>Merely a difference of opinion...

We don't always agree on "the best way" to do things, and that's healthy. However, some folks read disagreement as anger, and that's not. I have no motives in my posts other than:

1.) showing my work

2.) showing newcomers that mistakes still happen

3.) venting when they do

4.) educating why they did

I agree with Lyle that it was a great learning opportunity for folks to see those things, but I differ in opinion why it happened and what could have prevented it. I have no anger towards him or others with other opinions, and I hope that the same can be said for others towards folks that differed from his opinion.

Off to my MIL's for a day of laying around. When did I get so old that a day of turning made me sore the next day?

Steve

Re: WHAT has happened ??

#7

For Goodness Sake

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Steve you have spent at least four posts defending yourself; it is not all about you. Remember, the more time one spends defending their actions, the more attention they draw to the fact that they feel the need to defend.

Re: WHAT has happened ??

#8

Mike Stafford

Please everyone, just let it go. It's over.

Mike Stafford

>The horse is dead. Can we please just bury it.....

Like Barbara said, "Happy Mother's Day!"

Re: WHAT has happened ??

#9

Mike Stafford

Actually Ed said, "Happy Mother's Day!"

Mike Stafford

>

Re: WHAT has happened ??

#10

Russ, I Have to Disagree

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I still think Wood Central is the best Woodworking Forum. As anything else it is evolving. Ellis works so hard to keep this site available for us. He and Jim started it years ago so we could discuss all aspects of woodworking as well as innumerable off topic subjects.

Without a doubt Wood Central has the fewest rules and restrictions than any other public forum. I think at times we all who frequently post have stretched the limits. I have to wonder sometimes if Ellis bangs his head against a wall wondering why he keeps doing this.

Re: WHAT has happened ??

#11

Steve Kubien

WC is tops in my books.

Steve Kubien

>Russ, I have to respectfully disagree. It is the make up of such different turners with such different opinions and techniques that makes this place so awesome. I enjoy being able to access the minds of (let's take hollow form turners) Lyle and Wally... Two guys doing very different work in very different ways and each to an amazing high level of excellence. Add in people who are making their own tools from scratch (Steve A for one) and people who think so far outside the box that they can't even remember where they left the box (Mr. Lucas and Mr. Belden off the top of my balding head) and you have the make-up of a very fine community. Yeah, there are disagreements and tempers flare. That's because we are a family and I don't know any family where that doesn't happen.

Just my 2 cents and I think I owe you change.

Steve Kubien

-off to cook ocean perch with asparagus and bacon for my wife and mother of my children. Happy Mom's Day!!!!!

Re: WHAT has happened ??

#12

Steven Antonucci

Folks: I'm not defending myself :-)

Steve antonucci

>Barb-

It would be great to think I could say this in a meaningful way:

it's not me vs. Lyle

it's not hand held vs. captured

it's not good vs. evil

The sooner folks "get it" the faster this ends. The fact that some people will take Lyle's view of what happened as the gospel over mine when I was standing there when it happened (I saw it, caused it, and explained it) is just plain frustrating...

If Lyle blows something up in his shop, I'll be sure to explain how he could have avoided it by hand held hollowing...LOL

Happy Mother's Day

Steve

Re: WHAT has happened ??

#13

Best site ever.

john lucas

>I know we have squabbles some times. What family doesn't. In the end we will still be friends if we meet at a symposium. That's what it's all about. Ellis has made this an extended family for me and I really enjoy everyone.

Re: WHAT has happened ??

#14

Peter Lamb, in SC

Re: Best site ever.

Peter Lamb, in SC

>I very much agree with Barbra and John. Family disagreements can and should lead to greater relationships!!

Peter

Re: WHAT has happened ??

#15

Re:Ellis obviously does it for the BIG BUCKS!(;-D)

Jamie Donaldson

>