Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Boom.

Posts

Boom.

#1

Steven Antonucci

Boom.

Steve antonucci

>I knew I should had probably called it a night, but I thought I could power through it and finish. My biggest fear was that the wood would move if I left it overnight, and I wouldn't be able to finish hollowing it through the 5/8" I had cut. It was probably dry enough that I could have, but I decided to "go for it".

I had about 1/2" of depth to finish cutting and I was done. I had just blown out all of the chips and sharpened the cutter in my bar. Turned on the the lathe and started to feel for the bottom. That's when it happened.

Boom.

I still haven't found all of the pieces, and I suspect that I never will. I had obsessed over the exterior curve and finish cut it with a skew to minimize sanding. I had gotten a pretty consistent wall with about 1/2" left to cut in the bottom. Instead of finishing in the morning, I left with nothing.

Worst part is that the wood deserved to make it. It was too good to end up this way. Just the right amount of spalt with no punky spots. And curly too...

Steve


img

Re: Boom.

#2

Re: Boom.

mike Nelson

>Been there, done that! I feel for you, especially since it wasn't punky. Did you use a steady rest?

Re: Boom.

#3

my condolences

Thad

>

Re: Boom.

#4

Ellis Walentine

Sorry for your loss, Steve

Ellis Walentine

>I could be clever with talk about the occupational hazards, but that doesn't change the relationship you make with a piece once you begin to turn it. It's a heartbreak when it happens.

Ellis

Re: Boom.

#5

Re: Boom.

charlie belden

>With "AH Moments" comes the possibility of "AH #@*&^%@! Moments", the latter typically occuring very near the end of hours of of work with several AH Moments providing rewards and encouragement.

Like turning tools that come with a fixed, but unquantifiable or predictable, catches, it seems that each piece of wood comes with a specific number of AHs and AH @$%@#@^!!!!! moments - and some - with a built in BOOM! And the insidious part is - that the really nice/unusual pieces of wood always seem to have a built in potential BOOM. This may have been one of those pieces of wood.

BTW - many in our turning club swear that if they can't finish a piece for some reason, they pop the work in the freezer until they can get back to it. That's worked for me - sometimes - and other times- not so well. Might be worth a try though.

Sorry for your loss. I'd put money on you finding a similar, or better chunk of wood to have another go with.

Re: Boom.

#6

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Boom.

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>Now that really is something to kick yourself over, I had a similar thing happen about 2 years ago and I have a fellow feeling for you!

I sincerely hope that it will be a spur to try again.

Regards, Peter.

Re: Boom.

#7

Re: Boom.

Greg Haugen

>That's a heart-breaker! Been there, done that. Bummer! It was a gorgeous piece of wood and from the larger piece shown, looks like it was an excellent form as well.

Re: Boom.

#8

I hate it when it does that

mfoster

>

Re: Boom.

#9

Steven Antonucci

I don't think it would have helped.

Steve antonucci

>More so than anything, I needed to make another tool (which I will probably make this Saturday. I think a steady rest would hve probably cause more pieces in the wreckage as it struck the assembly. As it is, the three main pieces are all "pretty clean" (no dings or losses)

I'll glue it back together just for giggles...

Steve

Re: Boom.

#10

Steven Antonucci

That's exactly how I feel.

Steve antonucci

>I was going to start sanding it at 220 on the outside, just to get it down to one surface. There were some areas that were just perfect. To have spent 2 hours inside that little hole, measuring and cutting, to have touched the surface to feel for the curve, and then leave with nothing...

Sad.

S

Re: Boom.

#11

Steven Antonucci

I have no shortage of this wood....

Steve antonucci

>now finding a clean, straight grained piece of maple in my pile would be a feat!

There will be salvation for this piece as it rises from the wreckage!

S

Re: Boom.

#12

Steven Antonucci

I've lost more than one

Steve antonucci

>I doubt I can even count that high. Each one hurts like the first time.

S

Re: Boom.

#13

Steven Antonucci

I found "most" of it

Steve antonucci

>I will glue humpty dumpty back together again. I think I found 95% of it, with only a couple of small losses. For the cost of some glue, I can finish this and throw it on the shelf with the rest of the tragedies...

S

Re: Boom.

#14

Steven Antonucci

me too :-)

Steve antonucci

>

Re: Boom.

#15

Dick Hines

Re: Boom.

Dick Hines

>Steve, I wrap my hollow forms in blue tape when I am working on the inside. It may not keep them form blowing up but at least I can find all the pieces. I had a big piece of BLM burl that tok me 3 days to hollow. I had it all sanded and the first coat of finish on it. I bumped as I was walking by. Sounded like a pumpkin hitting the floor.

I think I had rather have one blow up on the lathe. That way I would not waste all the time sanding.

Re: Boom.

#16

Re: Boom.

Don Orr

>Sorry to see that Steve. Woulda been a nice one. Nice even wall though ;-))

Re: Boom.

#17

Re: Most of us have BTDT Steve! Doesn't ....

Jamie Donaldson

>...make you feel any better, but think of the good practice that piece of wood gave you! Looks like it was getting too thin at the base anyway, and that's the most difficult area to measure twice before cutting once. Old dry spalted wood like that is often so brittle that there is little tolerance for any errors.

Re: Boom.

#18

Steven Antonucci

Humpty Dumpty: There is always hope

Steve antonucci

>I may have overstated the severity of the situation. It seems that the wood gods have chosen to give me a second chance at life.

The piece had a few odd cracks running the length of it, and when the run-back on the nub at the bottom occurred, it must have just followed those cracks. This picture shows the four sections reassembled, and I'm guessing that I can carve the rim to some geometric that will disguise the problem all together. A little sanding will get rid of the surface glue.

Steve

P.S. I may try to find the "missing pieces"- NOT!


img

Re: Boom.

#19

Dick Hines

Re: Humpty Dumpty: There is always hope

Dick Hines

>And you thought all was lost.A little CA and you are back in business.

Re: Boom.

#20

Steve Kubien

I've heard rumours of this happening...

Steve Kubien

>...but I have never been able to replicate this event in my shop.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

Well, not in the past week of so!

Steve Kubien

Re: Boom.

#21

Re: Humpty Dumpty: There is always hope

RonZ

>That's what's known as an artistic oppertunity. Spalted wood has its faults.

The picture I use in top left corner of my site is from when I was just starting. It must have brok 4-5 times and I went through the bottom. I didn't give up and it survived.