Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

Posts

An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#1

An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

Carole Valentine

>Sick of the cheap rifflers I had been using that literally tore the wood fibers out, I finally decided to spring for some new ones. I ordered one Auriou ($70 for an 8" triangle/half round!) to try and, for the heck of it, a 3 piece 7" set of Gramercy rifflers for $47. Both are handcut - the Auriou is made in France and the Gramercy is made in Pakistan. The Auriou is a #12 grain and the Gramercys are #10 grain. While the teeth are offset on both, each has a different pattern.

The Auriou is is a markedley finer tool in balance and shape and cut, as it should be for the price. It cuts cleanly and smoothly and is very easy to control. I was pleasantly surprised though, that the Gramercy is a very decent set of rifflers for the price. However, with the Gramercy, there was no choice of size or grain and it is obviously a little coarser than the Auriou. The ends of the half-round/triangle tool are not as pointed so you can't quite get into as tight a space as you can with the Auriou. The one thing I did NOT like about the Gramercy is the fact that on the triangle tool, the straight V is on the concave side, not the convex side as it is on the Auriou. Why they did this, I will never know!

Bottom line: the Auriou is definitely top of the line and if you can afford them, by all means do it, but if you can't see your way past the price tag, and want something better than what is available in your local hardware store, take a look at the Gramercy set. I will probably order a couple more Aurious as the budget permits.


img

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#2

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

Greg Haugen

>Carole,

Thank you for the information, a very thorough and great review.

Thanks.

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#3

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Well done Carole,

I have a wide range of Aurious for my furniture work, they simply are wonderful to work with in allowing me to shape and refine wood details in my work.

Take care,

Jim

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#4

Rob Wallace

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

Rob Wallace

>My understanding is that the Auriou family in France went out of business, and that no more of their high quality files, rasps, or rifflers, etc. will be produced. Whatever is available in stock by suppliers now is all that is left....I saw an article on the closing of the Auriou's family manufacturing not too long ago...

One of the woodworking tool suppliers (Highland Woodworking, others???) now sells other "European" woodworking files and rasps that are "hand-stitched" by the Roczo family in Hungary. Seems these Hungarian tools also command a similarly high per unit price as did the French tools.

Carol, you may be using a 'dinosaur' with your Auriou riffler(s) because I think the line of French-made Auriou files, rasps, and rifflers is now extinct.

I'll have to have a look at the Gramercy tools....

Rob Wallace

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#5

JL

Thanks for sharing - but is it Auriou anymore? *LINK*

JL

>I do know that they folded their tent and are now back in business.


Forge De Saint Juery

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#6

Rob Wallace

Re: Thanks for sharing - but is it Auriou anymore?

Rob Wallace

>Thanks JL!

Always good to be updated - and especially with good news!

I'll have to link their web site to my Woodturning Links page...

Cheers,

Rob Wallace

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#7

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers *LINK*

Carole Valentine

>Rob, they are back in business. You can get their files and rasps at Tools for Working Wood (I think Joel still frequents WC)


Tools for Working Wood

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#8

New name *LINK*

Carole Valentine

>They are operating under a new name: Forge de Saint Juery


Forge de Saint Juery

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#9

Thanks Carol

john lucas

>I have 2 of them and like them a lot. I would also recommend the Cabinet makers rasps from Highland woodworking. Very useful for broad surfaces the they cut very well. They are about 1/3 to half the price of the Auriou.

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#10

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

John Jordan

>That's interesting, Carole. I don't know where you got them, but at Tools for Working Wood, the rifflers are, as you said, quite different in price, but the full size Gramercy rasps are just as costly as the Auriou rasps. I have a lot of the Auriou rasps and love them. I use rifflers frequently, but not for long periods-I depend on the full size rasps. You had me hopeful for a minute I could find some new rasps that would suit me.

I may try a set of the Gramercy rifflers, though. Thanks!

John

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#11

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

Carole Valentine

>John, I noticed that the full sized Gramercys were just as costly as the Aurious. I don't know why the set of Gramercy rifflers are so much less except that maybe others don't like the orientation of the trianglar one either. They are a good bang for the buck to work on small stuff, but I like the Aurious better - I like the finer grain, the balance, the octagonal "handle" section and the general shape.

BTW...I love my 3/8" hollowers! :)

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#12

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

John Jordan

>I made six sets and sold the rest at Southern States. I guess you got me thinking I'll tool up to make them. Glad you like them-they made a pretty little piece for sure. Maybe I sould raise the price. :)

John

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#13

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

Carole Valentine

>Go for it! ...now that I have mine. :)

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#14

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

Pascal Oudet

>Hello,

just to give you some more details. Michel Auriou is involved in the new Forge de St Juery business. The bad news is he couldn't keep all former employees, the good news is that some of them are now working for another French maker of hand stitched rasps. I'm currently working with them on new shapes for rotating rasps.

being able to have a fine teeth, or teeth just at the very end of a pointy tool is all where the expertise is.

Pascal

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: An amature's take: Auriou vs Gramercy rifflers

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Carole, I have a set of rifflers (brand unknown), each one has one section that is uncut, just smooth. For example, in a triangular section, two sides will cut, one will not. These are great for cutting only one side of a line. A set of rifflers is indespensible.