>Just as Reed said a box much larger than 3 1/2"-4" begins to give problems with seasonal stability i.e. it will start going slightly oval with changes in humidity. This causes lid fitting problems where you will experience a twist fit but the grain will no longer align. There are a few species where I have not had this problem. Shedua, bubinga and most of the rosewoods once good and dry do not seem to warp as much as some other woods. I have turned a few 4" boxes in walnut and to date they have remained round and the lids continue to fit properly.
The other consideration about size is that if the lid is tight fitting it can be hard to grasp and open for people with small hands. For me the rule is the larger the box the looser the lid.
>Interesting question with several parameters affecting stability as the size of the box increases
- wood species
- initial moisture conent
- seasonal moisture content changes
- grain orientation
I did a 4" diameter lidded box - with add on finial - from a piece of a 12" diameter logette of deodor cedar that had been out under the parent tree for four or five years. The grain is U shaped, close to, but not including the pith. The lid is a "pop fit" and though it's been well over a year since it was done, it still has a pop fit.
Did a 3 1/2" lidded box out of old (50+ year old porch post), very tight grained, quarter sawn pine that behaved the same way as the deodor cedar, as did a 3 /4" diameter rosewood box.
So it seems resinous woods that have had time to dry are fairly stabile.
On the other hand, I've had apricot and plum boxes that were only 2 1/2" in diameter, turned from wood that had been cut several years earlier, crack - no pith anywhere near the wood used for them, lock up tight - or split.
Black walnut (Juglanus nigra) has a radial shrinkage of 5% and tangential shrinkage of 7/8% so the T/R Ratio is 1.4. Not resinous, but it's been pretty stabile for boxes - at least for me - if turned dry.
My vote is to go for it - real soon. If it doesn't work out - there's always a dozen roses, or you can take her out for a nice dinner.