Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Here's where I am at so far...

Posts

Here's where I am at so far...

#1

Here's where I am at so far...

Marc Phillips

>... on the deep hollowing I had posted before...

Great advice ... thanks so much. I cut off the punky bottom and re-cut the tenon as large as my Supernova will go... and made sure there was a good shoulder on it and that it didn't bottom out in the chuck... and I was able to hollow the entire thing. I did lose a few inches with cutting off the bottom, but this vase is still deeper than I have tried hollowing before... boldly going where... uhh... this man has never gone before :)

Great practice! ... I (literally) used all of my hollowing tools once I got about 3/4 of the way in there... kept changing cutters, trying different angles of attack, different tool rest heights... learned a lot! ... good learning experience when you can see what the tool is doing.

It is cracking... as did almost everything I have made from this particular log...

I have applied CA to the cracks and am letting it dry as I type this....

Can it be saved ya think? (see other replies for more pics)


img

Re: Here's where I am at so far...

#2

Cracks....

Marc Phillips

>Here's the cracks...


img

Re: Here's where I am at so far...

#3

One more pic....

Marc Phillips

>..... just for scale....


img

Re: Here's where I am at so far...

#4

Re: Here's where I am at so far...

Norm Smith

>Mark, It looks fine. Fill the cracks with copper or brass powder, or something else. I like the metal powders for cracks like these.

Norm

Re: Here's where I am at so far...

#5

Steven Antonucci

Did you sand it?

Steve antonucci

>The cause of those types of crack is usually from heat build-up while sanding. If not, then it's likely that the overall surface has spun out all of the water and it's drying too quickly from the end grain.

I have rewet pieces in the past that I had this happen to. While it will keep them from cracking if done preventatively, I think a piece this size is likely to crack unless you take it down to 1/4" or less. Too much wood and too much diameter is a recipe for wood movement, and even if you set it off the lathe, I bet it will crack anyhow.

If you get it down to 1/4" or less, it will warp, but it will not crack.

Steve

Re: Here's where I am at so far...

#6

Dick Hines

Re: Here's where I am at so far...

Dick Hines

>Can it be saved. Maybe. When I get cracks in pieces I put mid. CA in the cracks and then sand. The dust will work down into the cracks. Depeneding on the wood the cracks will not show as bad. I do this to fill little pits also. The mid. CA will satin the wood like the thin.

Re: Here's where I am at so far...

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Here's where I am at so far...

Brad Vietje

>Marc,

A few random thoughts:

- Cross-grain tall vase shapes are more likely to snap at/near the base because the wood is stressed where it is pretty weak. Can be done, very gently, and with real sharp tools.

- In this orientation, over-tightening the chuck can crush the wood fibers and cause separation of growth rings in some woods. End-grain, or "spindle" orientation gives the tenon more strength, but introduces other issues, liken end grain hollowing and avoiding the pith...

- shaping the tenon is critical to keeping a piece (especially a tall one) in the jaws. Which Supernova jaws are you using? Their 2" standard-issue jaws are shaped like Vicmarc -- a cylinder, with a small 15-degree dovetail at the tips. If you shape the tenon just right, they hold pretty well. Some people like serrated jaws like the Oneway profile jaws or the Powergrip jaws for tall pieces.

- Avoiding cracks is usually done by using sound, un-checked wood to start with, keeping it moist, and working fast. The outside doesn't look sanded, but heat from sanding can cause end grain checking. It looks like that end grain may have been too near a cut surface and may have started cracking before you started turning it (?)

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT