Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Can't figure this out....

Posts

Can't figure this out....

#1

Can't figure this out....

Marc Phillips

>Hi all

I am trying to make a natural edged vase out of some spalted sweetgum.

I shaped the outside, and it is 11" deep, a little over 6" at the top and tapers to 4" at the bottom I formed a tenon, and turned it around to hollow it out....

.... and now I am stuck.

It wont stay in the chuck no matter how light a cut I take trying to hollow out the inside... and now the tenon has snapped off. I tried using the tailstock to support it until I got it hollowed out a little but could not figure out how to get in there with the tailstock in the way.

Can someone help me out?

Re: Can't figure this out....

#2

Re: A photo would help us help you.

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: Can't figure this out....

#3

Re: Can't figure this out....

Paul Zerjay

>11' is a lot of wood in regards to twisting and flexing. Try using a steady rest.

Re: Can't figure this out....

#4

Re: Can't figure this out....

Don Evans

>Are you sure the tenon was large enough in diameter? It sounds like it may have been at the smallest diameter the chuck and jaws would close down on.

Anyway, if it is 11" tall and the tenon broke before you could really get started good on hollowing, why don't you just put it between centers again and make another tenon, make this one big enough that the jaws can bite down on it good.

Was this green wood? It probably got smaller (tenon) as it started drying out.

What chuck and jaws are you using, do you know the upper and lower limits size on them? If not, learn that first and make the tenon in a size that falls in the middle of that range.

If it is natural edge, want equipment do you have for finishing the bottom?

Don

Re: Can't figure this out....

#5

Re: Can't figure this out....

Adrien Coblentz

>Alternatively, get bottom smooth, CA glue it to sacrificial wood that can be securely clamped in the chuck.

Re: Can't figure this out....

#6

Re: Can't figure this out....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>If you are able to turn the piece between centers to cut a new tenon, cut a shoulder for the chuck to seat itself against. That is always a must. Otherwise the piece can move and lever itself out of the chuck. Be sure that the tenon doesn't bottom out in the chuck. For hollowing an 11 inch piece you really need a steady rest. You might want to think about making it a shorter piece.

You may have better luck if you install a faceplate instead of using a chuck.

Good luck,

Wally

Re: Can't figure this out....

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Can't figure this out....

Keith Tompkins

>HI Mark, I'll bet you were turning it bowl-grain orientation. If so, the tenon will be extremely weak, easily snapped off. If you turn it end grain, it's near impossible to snap of the tenon. My guess.

Re: Can't figure this out....

#8

Re: Can't figure this out....

Marc Phillips

>I was wanting a natural edged vase.... but at least now I know can plan a different method of attaching in the future.... thanks.

How does a recess work with bowl orientation?

Re: Can't figure this out....

#9

Re: Can't figure this out....

Marc Phillips

>Thanks Wally....

"If you are able to turn the piece between centers to cut a new tenon, cut a shoulder for the chuck to seat itself against."

I had a shoulder... but I am now guessing the tenon was too small... the jaws of the SuperNova were nearly closed....

"Be sure that the tenon doesn't bottom out in the chuck."

I think you hit it.... I am pretty sure the tenon was bottomed out in the chuck...

Thanks again... I will give it another try tomorrow...

Re: Can't figure this out....

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Can't figure this out....

Keith Tompkins

>Mark, One method is to leave a large mass of wood at the base; for example, use a faceplate with screws to secure the piece. then turn the piece outside and inside together, progressing down the piece in increments. By the time you reach the base, the piece is finished, no need to hollow separately with all the stress on the tenon. I'm not partial to recesses.

Re: Can't figure this out....

#11

Re: Can't figure this out....

Roger

>As Keith said, if the blank is mounted with side grain in the chuck that could contribute to "shearing" off at the tennon. You mentioned that the wood was spalted. If the tennon, or even the screws of a faceplate are in soft or punky wood that could cause your problem. I had a 20" ash bowl shear off twice yesterday where the faceplate screws stopped. The wood where the faceplate was mounted was definately a little punky. On the third try of mounting the faceplate I was into more solid wood, and everything went good. Also if the wood is a little soft you can soak the soft area in CA glue to strengthen it up. Hope this helps. Good luck.

Roger

Re: Can't figure this out....

#12

Re: Can't figure this out....

Marc Phillips

>"Are you sure the tenon was large enough in diameter? It sounds like it may have been at the smallest diameter the chuck and jaws would close down on."

It was at the smaller end of the scale... the jaws were nearly closed...

"Anyway, if it is 11" tall and the tenon broke before you could really get started good on hollowing, why don't you just put it between centers again and make another tenon, make this one big enough that the jaws can bite down on it good."

I will ... and the tenon was bottomed out in the chuck too... so apparently a double whammy...

"Was this green wood? It probably got smaller (tenon) as it started drying out."

It is a green piece....

"What chuck and jaws are you using, do you know the upper and lower limits size on them? If not, learn that first and make the tenon in a size that falls in the middle of that range."

It's a Supernova.... and I am going to make some sort of a gauge so I can measure the tenon before I take it off the lathe... I can't tell how many times I have turned the tenon, taken the piece off only to discover that the tenon was too large or too small...

"If it is natural edge, want equipment do you have for finishing the bottom?"

I just use jam chucks for finishing the bottoms...

Thanks Don ....

Re: Can't figure this out....

#13

Thanks for the help..

Marc Phillips

>

Re: Can't figure this out....

#14

Re: Can't figure this out....

Barry Irby

>I think you have gotten good advice and figured this out. In my relatively limited experience with hollowing and suing a chuck I have observed a number of things. I also have a Nova Chuck.

If you are near the upper/larger limit for the chuck's grip range, only the "corners" of the jaws bite into the wood, sort of like Eye Teeth. If you are right at the lower/smaller limit most or all of the surface of the jaws grip, but if the piece is very slightly too small, the jaws will close before they grip and the piece will be loose. This can be deceptive. Also, if you piece dries and shrinks and you have to true the tenon, you could trim it down to the point it won't grip. If the lower limit on my chuck is 4" I like to be at about 4 3/8".

The shoulder that Wally mentioned is very important. The piece rides on the shoulder and the tenon keeps it snug to the shoulder.

Do not let it bottom in the chuck. This prevents the piece bottoming on the shoulder and really stresses the tenon.

With dovetail jaws match the angle of the dovetail to the angle of the jaws carefully. A mistake I have made is to cut the tenon too straight, so that the "teeth" bite into the wood right at the base of the shoulder. Better to have the angel slightly too steep than too straight. Better for the jaws to grip the part of the tenon that is deepest in the jaws first. Visualize the dovetail in the chuck as teeth. Don't cause the teeth to bite the tenon off. Once they start a crack or tear there, its over.

I have had very little success with a recess. A recess may work well on a platter where you can have a very large ring of good sound wood around the recess, perhaps a 1" or more, but if you are going to have less than an 1" of somewhat punky wood, you may be better off to just throw the piece around the shop yourself and not bother with the lathe.

Re: Can't figure this out....

#15

Re: Can't figure this out....

Don Evans

>Marc:

One thing I forgot to mention, when turning green wood and with the tenon in the middle of the diameter range it is also important with to continue to check the tightening on the jaws. At least every 15 minutes for first hour until you get a feel for how much if any changing is going on, especially with GREEN wood.

Also, if you leave it, cover it with plastic bag and tie up end with something to keep drying slow. Mandantory to check the tightening again when removing the bag before starting the lathe up.

I also soak the tenon in thin CA as someone mentioned but make sure glue is dry before putting in chuck, best to spritz it with instand drying agent made for CA.

Don

Re: Can't figure this out....

#16

Mike Peace

Wrong Jaws?

Mike Peace

>You did not say what size jaws you were using. The size of the blank you were turning is outside of the manufacturers recommended range for anything except the Power Grip jaws. You got some good advice here. When all else fails, read the manual. Good experience is probably better than any manual. But, if you do not have the experience, reading the manual is not always a disgrace to our gender, LOL!

Re: Can't figure this out....

#17

Re: Wrong Jaws?

Carole Valentine

>I agree about the jaws - Powergrip is called for here. And you really should make your tenon closer to the smaller setting of the jaws than the larger setting. As you open the Nova jaws, they are no longer "round" and contact the wood strongly just on the tips of each jaw instead of closely gripping the entire tenon. This puts stress on the wood...almost a splitting action.

Re: Can't figure this out....

#18

Dick Hines

Re: Can't figure this out....

Dick Hines

>If the wood is wet and you used the dove tail jaws on your chuck ant cranked the chuck down hard you can pinch the tenon off the bottom.

On tall pieces I use a face plate. If you have enough wood still on the bottom try going back between center and trueing up the bottom and put a face plate on.

Good luck.