Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Renaissance Wax substitute?

Posts

Renaissance Wax substitute?

#1

Renaissance Wax substitute?

charlie belden

>Living in earthquake country, it occured to me that finding something to temporarily affix some of my less stabile pieces to their display surfaces might be a wise and prudent thing to do. To that end I went to my favorite hardware store, a family run Ace Hardware down the road, looking for something that'd do the job.

What I found, was a plastic jar of "Crystalline Clear MUSEUM WAX - QUAKE HOLD" The description of this wax uses most of the same buzz words used in RW's description - micro-crystalline, acid neutral, won't discolor or stain. Comes in 2, 4, 7 and 12 ounce jars.

RW goes for about $3.70 an ounce ($25.95 for a 7 ounce jar) while this Quake Hold is about $9 for 4 ounces or about $2.25 an ounce. A 13 ounce jar is only $12 or 92 cents an ounce.

Haven't tried this stuff on wood, but it might be a much less expensive alternative to RW. Will report back with some anecdotal comparisons after I've done some samples on different woods.

Anyone already used Quake Hold?

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#2

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

David Walser

>Charlie,

I've heard some turners say (read what they wrote on forums such as this one) they use Museum Wax instead of Renaissance Wax because it was cheaper but just as good. I've not tried it myself, but only because I could not find any when I needed some more Renaissance Wax. Never thought to look in the local hardware store.

Try it and let us know how you like it.

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#3

Steve Kubien

Conservator's Wax

Steve Kubien

>You can get it at Lee Valley. 4oz for $11.50 Cdn. One of the ladies put me on to it (Ruth? Jennifer? Molly? C.R.S.)

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#4

Re: Conservator's Wax

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hi Steve,

I have been using it for 10 years, it's excellent..

Take care,

Jim

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#5

Tacky wax

john lucas

>Charlie I used Tacky wax from photography dealers. Mostly because I already had it. My show was in a restaurant with a train track right beside it. Even with the tacky wax and signs saying do not touch I found a couple of pieces had been pulled off and then replaced in a different orientation. People are so tacky.

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#6

Re: I believe you guys are talking about...

Jamie Donaldson

>...2 entirely different materials here. Renaissance is a finishing wax, and the quake hold type museum wax, as John pointed out, is a mounting wax for holding objects in place, such as during quakes. It's a fairly standard item in a photographers bag of tricks for holding items at odd angles or other uses while shooting pix.

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#7

museum wax

john lucas

>One of my artist friends just stopped in to pick up a disc I did for him and he says he uses Museum wax to anchor pieces during outdoor shows when it's supposed to be windy or if he's using a small pedestal in the front of the booth for a piece that could easily get knocked off.

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#9

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute? *LINK*

Don Evans

>Charlie:

The stuff you are talking about isn't in anyway good for a wax finish on anything. It is a gel and putty that you use to stick stuff but it can be removed.

I have used it for years on the bottom corners of pictures that hang on wall. I use the putty and a pinch rolled into a ball and put one on the rear of picture and push it and no more cocked pictures, they stay hanging straight.

Here is web site:

Don


Quake Hold

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#10

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

charlie belden

>This stuff is definitely not a gel. In hardness, it's closer to paraffin and nowhere near carnuba's hardness and much harder than bees wax. Unlike paraffin and carnuba, it doesn't chip when you try and scrape a curl, but curls like wood can - or cool bees wax.

If it has any smell at all, it's a really subtle one. One of the kids with a sensitive nose thinks she might be able to smell it - but isn't sure.

Rubbing T-shirt material on the surface, with a bit of pressure approaching white knuckle pressure, you CAN get some on it. And if you try and apply it to a piece on the lathe, with the lathe off, you have to rub pretty hard and briskly to warm it up enough to go on the wood. Even at low rpms, it takes a while to get it off the T-shirt rag and onto the wood. But crank up the speed to 1000 rpms or more and it goes on nicely and does produce a nice sheen.

Will take the jar to the turning club meeting next week and get some hands on, face to face feedback from some of the members who use RW quite a bit.

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#11

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

Don Evans

>I'm sure the problem here is that Quake Hold makes several different products. So there is a problem in discussing it.

If you take the link I gave and go to that site, look in bottom right corner you'll see several other links.

The one that says: Museum WAX is what you have I'm guessing.

The stuff that is for holding items to a shelf during an earthquake is the stuff I was talking about, I have two of the gels and two of the putties of it and it works great.

I've never tried the one you are referring too and didn't even know about it till just now. May order so of it and give it a try.

I've never used RW but instead use Arbortechs microcrystaline because they make several different versions of it in different shines. I've mostly stuck with their High Gloss and really like it as it requires only hand application and hand buffing. Its better than spending lots on Beal buffing systems, to me. Also no finger prints will show when using any of the microcrystalines second best part of them.

Don

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#12

Pic of this stuff

charlie belden

>The lid has the following text below "Museum Wax"

Used by Museum Professionals for anchoring artifacts, collectibles, glass and more from falling and breaking due to accidents and earthquakes.

It's made in the USA by Ready America Inc, Escondido, CA.

If you scrape a curl and roll it around between thumb and finger, it will soften up.


img

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#13

Re: Wax substitute? Why?

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>I use Renaissance wax and love it. It's not cheap but it goes a LONG way when not over applied. I'm all for saving a buck, but the question is: If turners can easily spend thousands on a lathe along with a large variety of needed support equipment and turning tools, then. . . Why the do we all find it so important to try and save a couple of bucks by replacing a fine quality, proven wax? Shouldn't the quest be to search for the ultimate, or Holy Grail of Wax instead of merely a cheaper version? Or am I missing something here?

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#14

Link?

Toney Robertson

>Could you please supply a link to Arbortech? I could not find it with google.

Thanks

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#15

Re: Pic of this stuff

Carole Valentine

>Well for that matter, a toilet seal ring will soften up, but I would not use it on my turnings. The museum wax is made to be reusable so it never really hardens whereas Renaissance Wax buffs to a relatively hard finish. One little can of the stuff lasts for years because you use so little of it. If that $24 is going to break the bank, then use a version of wax made for finishing, not fixing stuff in place. I have tried the Conservators Wax and do not like it. I have not checked but I suspect that it has a lower % of solids than Renaissance because it is even softer.

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#16

Re: Wax substitute? Why?

charlie belden

>Bruce wrote"

===============================

I use Renaissance wax and love it. It's not cheap but it goes a LONG way when not over applied. I'm all for saving a buck, but the question is: If turners can easily spend thousands on a lathe along with a large variety of needed support equipment and turning tools, then. . . Why the do we all find it so important to try and save a couple of bucks by replacing a fine quality, proven wax? Shouldn't the quest be to search for the ultimate, or Holy Grail of Wax instead of merely a cheaper version? Or am I missing something here?

======================

Though I didn't spend thousands on a lathe, I think the JET VS mini was around $329 when I bought it, I'm not adverse to spending money on tools and equiptment. Hell, I dropped a grand on the DOMINO package after trying one out at a woodworking show, and seeing the potential value of the system - later confirmed. So this isn't a penny pinching thing for me.

I bought this stuff to keep things I value from falling over and possibly being damages when the ground out here moves - suddenly (the SF Bay Area is in an earthquake zone). The enclosed paper work stated that it was a microcrystaline wax and I recalled that RW was also a microcrystaline wax. Since I'd heard good thinks about RW I was wondering if this stuff could be used as a wax finish for some turnings, and how it might compare with RW in terms of results. I've found that just because Brand A is three or four times more expensive than Brand B, it doesn't necessarily mean that Brand A is three or four times better, if at all better.

From responses I've gotten here and over in the news group rec.craft.woodturning, there's a range of opinions, but none from anyone who has used both and has a preference of one over the other and can explain why.

As for going with the "proven wax" and not trying anything else - at some point RW was new and unproven. If something better comes along to replace a "tried and true" - well I'll try it if I think it might be better or easier, though I must admit I have a thing for french polishing shellac - made from shellac flakes I've ground myself.

The world is constantly changing, and the rate at which it's changing seems to be always increasing. I'm a curious person by nature and enjoy exploring new possibilities - to use new materials and technology, or using existing materials and technology in a non-conventional / non-traditional way. If I find something I think others may find useful - I pass info along.

I'm heading off to the nearest WoodCraft store (about 20 miles away) to pick up a jar of RW and will try and come up with an objective way to compare it with this other wax.

Any suggestions for the comparison?

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#17

Re: Conservator's Wax

John in Ks

>I use KIWI Neutral Paste shoe polish and it even smells like Conservator's Wax that I have from Lee Valley. Not sure it is the same thing but it really works well and can be purchased locally.

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#18

Re: Link?

Don wilcut

>Try this one.

http://www.arbortech.com.au/woodmain.html

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#19

Re: Link?

Don wilcut

>This one works

http://www.arbortech.com.au/view/woodworking

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#20

Re: Link?

Toney Robertson

>Are you sure that is the link of wax?

I tried it and all I could find was information about a power carver.

Thanks,

Toney

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#21

Re: Link? *LINK*

Don Evans

>Toney:

I purchased it from Klingspor's woodworking shop in Raleigh. Woodworking shop is headquarted in Hickory, NC. They have web site but there is lot of stuff in store that isn't on web site, may have to call them.

Don


Klingspor's Woodworkingshop

Re: Renaissance Wax substitute?

#22

Thanks, (nt)

Toney Robertson

>nt