Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Fixing mistakes

Posts

Fixing mistakes

#1

Steven Antonucci

Fixing mistakes

Steve antonucci

>The other night at a club demo, I commented that a good turner knows how to fix his or her mistakes. i also posted a vessel that I recently made that I felt was "a mistake"...

I decided that I had very little to lose by remounting it, since I hated how it sat, and I think that this is a huge improvement. It may actually get another visit to the lathe and another trim around the bottom to a much broader radius. It still got to be sanded, but I probably am 80% of my initial vision...

Steve


img

Re: Fixing mistakes

#2

Re: Fixing mistakes

Greg Haugen

>Steve,

I think it's really coming together. It's looking good! Can't wait to see it when it's finished.

Nice job!

Greg H.

Re: Fixing mistakes

#3

Ellis Walentine

Re: Fixing mistakes

Ellis Walentine

>Getting there, Steve. The transition from the side to the bottom is bound to be tricky, and may be a good topic for discussion. Here's my take, at risk of being too simplistic: The curvature in the side is not an accelerating curve, so you can't transition geometrically from there to a base curvature. That means that you are dealing with an intersection of curves. Maybe you need a meniscus-shaped bottom curve (with enough of a foot or recess to keep the piece solidly grounded) that meets the gentle side curve at a relatively defined transition point. I would suggest working out the design on paper before taking off any more of your remaining thickness.

I'm sure this sage advice is worth at least as much as you paid for it. :-)

Ellis

Re: Fixing mistakes

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Fixing mistakes

Keith Tompkins

>Steve, the curve from the neck to the sides look great; perhaps a similar treatment at the base would tie the piece together. Just need to leave enough to keep it stable. Ellis is right on....sketch the possibilities.

Re: Fixing mistakes

#5

Don Pencil

Re: Fixing mistakes

Don Pencil

>All of this advice is great and absolutely "Right on".

BUT!!!!!!!! The experienced turner never makes mistakes. These deviations from the origional work are what we refer to as "design changes". No more, no less. Work that is not subject to "design change", in my humble opinion, has no doubt exited the lathe in such a way as to make me greatful a trip to the ER was not necessary. Although that has been known to happen also.

Be Well and here's to creative design changes.

Don