Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Questions on turning holly.

Posts

Questions on turning holly.

#1

Questions on turning holly.

Barry Irby

>I picked up a couple of short holly logs about 12" in diameter. I am thinking of Turning bowls out of them. They are green, cut about a week ago. What can I do to keep them from getting mold? I'd like to keep them nice and white. Second question. What would you turn out of them? Would they make decent salad bowls?

Re: Questions on turning holly.

#2

Re: Questions on turning holly.

Jeff Brockett

>I would seal the ends so they can dry out with out to much cracking or checking. Bowls would be a good choice - if they are solid white you could dye them or do some special finishes.

Re: Questions on turning holly.

#3

Re: Questions on turning holly.

Ken

>This is from expeiance.Seal the logs on both ends,then put it out of the weather for about a year,uless you have access to a kiln.Then cut the blanks,leaving the walls about 3/4 on an 8 or 9" bowl,then seal the endgrain wrap in paper and chips and put it away for about 6 more months.I learned this the hard way last yr and found a turner who turns quite a bit of it and this is how he does it,and doesn't loose to many that way.There may be other ways,but I havn't found them an I did a lot of asking.They say thats why it is expensive in the wood stores.Hope this helps.Its just one of the woods that you can't rush.

Re: Questions on turning holly.

#4

Re: Questions on turning holly.

Carole Valentine

>Barry, if this holly was just cut, you best rough it quick and soak it in alcohol for any chance at all of keeping it white. It's full of sap right now and we have the heat (already here) and humidity of a VA summer coming up. Personally, I would not make any sort of utility bowl out of Holly...I think it would start to look pretty grubby after a bit of use. Hollow forms, carving would be my choice.

Re: Questions on turning holly.

#5

Re: Questions on turning holly.

john lucas

>I'm new to turning green holly. It moves a lot. I have been getting greenish streaks that must be from the tool. I guess the tanin in the wood reacted with the steel. I was able to sand most of it out but some still reamains.

I can't answer how long it lasts or how to keep it white. I've sealed the ends with wax and put them up for now.

Re: Questions on turning holly.

#6

Re: Questions on turning holly.

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I never have lost a holly bowl from cracking or excessive warping (I have turned quite a bit). One bowl is around 15" in diameter. I discovered several years ago that the denatured alcohol soak seems to prevent the wood from staining. That 15" bowl and many others were treated in such a way during warm weather; they remained white.

I have concerns about the ways in which a holly bowl could be used because of the risk of staining. It is one of the few woods I use a poly finish on. I have found that a thin water base poly will soak into the wood and hopefully give protection; I use several coats, sanding with 600 grit between each and after the last. I have not checked to see if the finish will hold up to a raspberry vinaigrette salad dressing. :-)

Re: Questions on turning holly.

#7

Re: Questions on turning holly.

Don Evans

>John:

Would this be ornamental holly by chance? I've seen the green in it before a turning tool touched it. We all try to keep this stuff white and I've had fairly good luck with it but there are spores in the air that just seem to love holly. Actually probably all wood, we just notice it on holly more. The sealer I use is one from Klingspor, white milky wax, and i've see it turn green on lot of holly end grain also. I've got some in shop right now that has turned black and I've seen that before and said "hotdog it is going to spalt" but no such luck, the black was only in the wax.

There is something in holly that just reacts to this stuff.

I would be real surprised to learn it is the tools that is doing it.

Also one other consideration is where is it stored in shop, has it been subjected to other wood dust when other woods are being cut, etc.

Don

Re: Questions on turning holly.

#8

Re: Questions on turning holly.

Don Evans

>Barb:

That makes some sense to me, see above to John.

Wouldn't the alcohol kill spores? I'm using the term "spores" very generically here. Not necessarily wood bacteria spores are we normally think of them.

Don

Re: Questions on turning holly.

#9

Re: Questions on turning holly.

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>The Holly I have turned is American Holly.

The blue stain is usually caused by fungus spoors. Sometimes Holly has some natural blue-gray color in it but it is quite different from blue stain.

I assume the denatured alcohol both kills the fungus spoors and also causes the wood to dry faster. Also, the bowls that are put into the alcohol bath are slightly thinner than those rough turned and put into a bag (per Dave Smith's instructions). That assumption is based on the conditions that encourage blue stain.

I rarely see the green appear. I have seen it twice. Once when I decided to try drying a small Holly bowl in the microwave. The second was when I dried a Holly vase in a paper bag.

Re: Questions on turning holly.

#10

Re: Questions on turning holly.

Don Evans

>I'm almost sure the only time I've seen green stain is when it was ornamental holly. Note that ornamental holly also has a greenish tint in the bark, at least mine did.

I found it interesting that a guy I know who sells wood on internet told me that it is not possible to keep holly white it will always stain. Note that in his experience and environment he would have only seen what was cut up on a machine (bandsaw) and room where many different woods were being cut up from many different species of wood, domestic and exotic. He only sold green wood that was end sealed in a large dunking vat of wax.

I told him that my experience told me that you can, but it must be dryed in a kiln immediately and growth type stains cannot multiple without moisture.

As alcohol also helps in quicker than air drying I wonder if that has lot to do with your experience?

Don

Re: Questions on turning holly.

#11

Re: Questions on turning holly.

john lucas

>Barbara The holly I was turning was totally white while I was turning. When I started to sand I noticed round bands along the turning axis that tells me this is some sort of relation between the turning tool and the wood. It's not just a random stain I don't think.

Re: Questions on turning holly.

#12

Re: Questions on turning holly.

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Don, that guy was wrong. I have cut thousands of bd.ft. of Holly over the last 29 years with my WoodMizer and little ever stained. I sawed it in the winter and stickered it in the upstairs of a shed with a tin roof. The air circulation was good. It is important to get the moisture down quickly without reducing it too quickly.

Pine on the other hand has stained overnight when I was forced to cut it in hot weather.

It was warm weather when I cut the big chunks for the large bowls. That is why I used the alcohol.

I have seen green under the bark of American Holly but it has not influenced the color of the wood.

John, I don't know anything about the green and tools and sandpaper. It has never happened to me. I really think the environmental influence must play a part in the whiteness of Holly.

Re: Questions on turning holly.

#13

Re: Questions on turning holly.

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN------WebKitFormBoundar

>I have enjoyed working with American Holly. Like two other beautiful woods, cherry and dogwood, holly just wants to crack. Most does, some does not. I cannot make a definitive prediction which way it will go. If I had rubbed snake oil on the ends of the pieces that did not warp, I would swear by snake oil. I have never seen the need for expensive sealing solutions, as any decent paint seems to do as well (think about the intended use for exterior paint).

And, most of the bowls I have turned from holly eventually warp, which is not always bad. Some of those blue streaks can be very attractive.

The best way I have found to deal with holly is to throw it in the corner for a year or two, let it crack if it wishes, then cut blanks from the sections not cracked.

American holly is also a beautiful wood to use as a source for white inlays and inserts. Wait until you are sure it is dry, then cut the plugs or inlays.

Re: Questions on turning holly.

#14

Re: Questions on turning holly.

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN------WebKitFormBoundar

>Correction: snake oil to prevent cracking, not warping.

Re: Questions on turning holly.

#15

Re: Let it spalt

Russ Fairfield

>Why worry about keeping it white when it spalts like this?? Just my opinion.


img