Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

Posts

No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

#1

No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

charlie belden

>In an ideal world, the finish on a piece would be "from the tool" - the perfect cut burnished by a polished bevel directly behind it.

In the real world

sandpaper followed by sanding sealer followed by some light sanding followed by one, two or twenty applications of a wax or shellac or lacquer or and oil which will harden, with light sanding between applications

often is the finishing schedule for a piece to achieve a semi-gloss surface on the piece.

But if the goal is a burnished wood surface, why not just burnish the wood - with a polished burnishing tool - steel or a hard smooth stone - like say agate.

The Black Pots of Andrews Pueblo's Maria Martinez were given their semi glossy finish by rubbing with polished stones. Works for clay.

Works on at least some woods. I'm using an old jeweler's agate burnishing tool on a redwood lid of a ginger jar. Compressing the grain on the outside of the piece produces a shiny surface - AND - because the grain alternates between soft and hard, the resulting surface has a subtle yet discernable texture you can't see, but can feel.

Have you used burnishing as a finish, and if so, your impressions of the results and any tips you'd care to share,

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

#2

JL

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

JL

>I often burnish my spindle turnings with shavings. I grab a handful in a paper towel and press it against the work very hard while turning. I tried doing the steel rod thing - but I didn't like the surface.

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

#3

Steven Antonucci

Interesting question

Steve antonucci

>A lot of the stuff I make is prbably too fragile to be burnished using this method. I assume that you need to apply a moderate amount of pressure, and the walls would fail on most of my pots under this strain.

I like the idea because it leaves the wood in it's natural state and color. I strive to make things finish the way that they came off the lathe- since that is what I am trying to capture. I wonder if you could do this with a wet cherry log? :-)

Steve

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

#4

Re: Interesting question

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>You know, I've wondered why many have counseled not to use old sandpaper because it will burnish the wood. And I always thought, "So what? -- I kind of like the burnished look". Now here's a post about going after a burnished look. Indeed, why not?

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

#5

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

Russ Fairfield

>There is nothing wrong with burnishing as a finish, just be prepared to renew the finish once a year, and more often if you live in an area with a high humidity, lots of vegetation, or an acidic atmosphere. If steel rusts easilly, an unprotected wood surface will also deteriorate quickly.

Compaction of the wood surface is a short term finish because there is nothing to protect the wood from the moisture and contaminants in the atmosphere. The compacted wood will relax over time. We are speeding up this natural process when we remove a dent in a wood surface with steam from a wet cloth and a hot iron. That dent is compacted wood. The same thing happens naturally to the exposed wood surface. The only difference is that it takes longer.

A coat of wax will extend the life of the compacted wood surface.

Sanding to 1200 grit and finer, wetting the surface to raise the grain along the way, followed by a coat of wax, might be a better solution to the "no finish" finish, because it will look the same as the burnished surface and maybe brighter, there will be no compacted wood to relax over time, and it is easilly renewed as the wax deteriorates from contact with the atmosphere.

Burnishing is a good thing to do under any finish because anything that hardens the wood surface will add to the durability of the finish that is put on it. Sayinmg that compaction of the surface will interfere with adhesion of the finish is an "old wives tale" that is kept alive by those who have never done it. (My opinion)

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

#6

Re: Interesting question

john lucas

>Eliot The reason I don't use old sandpaper is that it still has some of the old grit left. So 220 might sort of sand like 320 or 400 but it leaves a little scratch hear and there like 220. So it might be burnishing the wood but it's still scratching at the same time.

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

#7

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

john lucas

>Stain doesn't go on evenly on burnished wood. When I turn spindles that are going to be stained I often have to rough up the skew turned areas with fine sandpaper to make the stain go on evenly. Unless I take a lot of time with the spindle gouge, those areas will be less polished than the skew areas and they don't take the stain evenly. It will still go on uneven in side grain vs end grain but that's another problem.

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

#8

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

Peter Hyde

>Russ here's a true story that might give you something to think about. As an apprentice I was the only person left to do the card scraper and hand sanding on furniture pieces before they went into the french polishing shop. Being a typical smart a*** kid I found I could get a shiny surface by turning over the 220 grit and burnishing the surface.

The first piece came back (a desk) with a very irate polisher. He showed me what happened to his finish as a result of my burnishing. the french polish could be totally removed with the back of his thumbnail whereas on a 220 grit surface it could not. Maybe it only happens with french polish, but I stopped burnishing or sanding beyond 220. Now as a hobby turner I use finer grits but usually only under an oil finish or between coats.

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

#9

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

charlie belden

>Burnishing with shavings with the piece turning on the lathe - especially if the shavings are of the same wood. Works - better on dry wood pieces. Shavings of wood harder than the piece can scratch the piece rather than burnish it.

As for loaded up sand paper burnishing the wood - yes it can - but not in any controlled way - leaving ridges in the surface.

Doing the burnishing off the lathe gives more control than burnishing with the piece spinning, but takes longer. Hand burnishing lets you compress the wood more in some areas than others - like in areas with end grain coming up out of side grain - a knot and around a knot - or on the top of an end grain turned piece for example. And with hand burnishing, you can apply more pressure in specific spots.

Regarding problems with dyes and stains and compressed wood - burnishing can be an advantage since end grain left unsealed or unburnished absorbs a LOT more dye or stain and therefore gets a LOT darker than side grain.

As Russ noted, a burnished finish is a temporary thing, and exposure to humidity, sunlight and things in the air will change the look of the finish over time. Personally, I like the idea of a piece that adapts to the owner and the owner's environment.


img

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

#10

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

Rick Davenport

>I always use a no finish finish on cedar pieces.

I use a paper towel, turn up the rpms and warm up the sanded (to 800) cedar.

It brings out the oils which create a slightly hardened satin shine. And it brings out the cedar aroma.

I have one piece in our walk-in closet that my wife uses for odds and ends.

The smell eventually faded, but the look and feel is still quite nice.

Here's and unfinished finished piece that got selected in last years' Edmonds Arts Festival juried competition.

R


img

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

#11

Re: No Finish Finish - Post Lathe Burnishing

Bob Macgregor

>I wonder if you could deter the deterioration of a burnished piece by first giving it a light coating of a polymerizing oil, poly or somesuch, then burnish and have the finish "glue" the compressed fibers in place. Maybe this is a bit of what Rick was getting at with his mention of the cedar oils?

BOB