What is Willow like to turn?
Bob Henderson
>They're cutting down a Weeping Willow tree about two blocks from my house. Before I go begging for wood, has anyone turned with Willow before? How does it turn? How does it look?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
What is Willow like to turn?
Bob Henderson
>They're cutting down a Weeping Willow tree about two blocks from my house. Before I go begging for wood, has anyone turned with Willow before? How does it turn? How does it look?
Re: What is Willow like to turn?
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>Bob, there are different types of willow. I went to a lot of trouble collecting some Weeping Willow after seeing a bowl made from some other willow. I was very disappointed and ended up throwing it away. The wood was very soft, tore out easily and was not very pretty. Maybe someone else has had a better experience.
Re: What is Willow like to turn?
Peter Charles Fagg (UK)
>Barbara sums up the qualities, if you can call them that, of Willow.
It appears to make no difference whether it is from the UK or USA it has a long grain that tends to tear out very easily. I found it very difficult to get a good finish.
It would take a lot of persuasion to use it again!
Regards, Peter.
2 tons of it covered in burl laying in the woods
Steve antonucci
>I hauled one test chunk out, and with a freshly sharpened tool, I couldn't get a clean cut no matter what I did. that's why the entire burl covered trunk still sits in the woods...
It is simply the WORST WOOD I HAVE EVER ATTEMPTED TO TURN.
S
Proof
Steve antonucci
>
Re: What is Willow like to turn?
John K Jordan
>I made some magic wands from willow that a fellow WCer sent to me. While it was a little stringy and a challenge to cut cleanly, I was able to make some nice pieces with sharp tools and a little patience. It sure isn't cherry.
JKJ
Re: What is Willow like to turn?
Don at Central Illinois
>I think it is a close kin of cottonwood and that is really hard (at least for me) to avoid tearout, etc.
Re: What is Willow like to turn?
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>You are right, they are in the same Family. Cottonwood at least has the redeeming quality of often having magnificent figure. I found Weeping Willow to be much more difficult than Eastern Cottonwood.
I have never turned anything except plates and bowls from Cottonwood.
I have...
Steve Kubien
>I've turned some willow though I cannot tell you what type of willow it was/is. I have some which came from the very base of the tree and it has some nice swirling figure, kinda like mellow curly maple. Colour is a cross between cherry and maple. It is tough to get a clean surface but it sands easily. It's not my favourite wood (by a long shot) but I like it enough to have just picked up a chunk of crotch wood (3 good-sized branches coming off the main branch).
Steve
Re: I have...
Dick Hines
>Sounds like to me you need to pick up a couple of pieces and try it for your self. The only thing you have to loose is your time.
Re: I have...
Bill Crommett
>I keep a chunk of Black Willow around to cannibalize for small pieces of bark to replace broken off pieces of natural edge bowls with compatible bark design.
Many years ago a friend brought me a trailer load of 2 1/2 foot diam Black Willow logs to cut up for firewood. After burrowing three wedges which I had to saw out, I took the rest of the logs out to a new sawmill to cut up for paneling for my basement.
Re: Proof
Bill Blasic
>Steve,
This is a Willow Burl and it turned very nicely.
Bill
Re: Proof
Denis Putland
>This is a Laural willow crotch piece, very soft and subject to dints from bumps or even finger nail marks. It can have beautiful grain patterns.
Denis
of the two, yours appears closer
Steve antonucci
>Are any of them the same as weeping willow? I watched that tree with baited breath- waiting for the day it would be mine. I was so disappointed that I haven't even given it a second look.
I might just fire up the chainsaw tomorrow and take another shot...
Will report back...
Steve
Re: of the two, yours appears closer
mike Nelson
>Some of my first turnings were willow, it will turn punky very fast but if you catch it at the right time you will find great colors and spalting.