Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

What is Willow like to turn?

Posts

What is Willow like to turn?

#1

What is Willow like to turn?

Bob Henderson

>They're cutting down a Weeping Willow tree about two blocks from my house. Before I go begging for wood, has anyone turned with Willow before? How does it turn? How does it look?

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

#2

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Bob, there are different types of willow. I went to a lot of trouble collecting some Weeping Willow after seeing a bowl made from some other willow. I was very disappointed and ended up throwing it away. The wood was very soft, tore out easily and was not very pretty. Maybe someone else has had a better experience.

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

#3

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>Barbara sums up the qualities, if you can call them that, of Willow.

It appears to make no difference whether it is from the UK or USA it has a long grain that tends to tear out very easily. I found it very difficult to get a good finish.

It would take a lot of persuasion to use it again!

Regards, Peter.

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

#4

Steven Antonucci

2 tons of it covered in burl laying in the woods

Steve antonucci

>I hauled one test chunk out, and with a freshly sharpened tool, I couldn't get a clean cut no matter what I did. that's why the entire burl covered trunk still sits in the woods...

It is simply the WORST WOOD I HAVE EVER ATTEMPTED TO TURN.

S

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

#5

Steven Antonucci

Proof 

Steve antonucci

>


img

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

#6

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

John K Jordan

>I made some magic wands from willow that a fellow WCer sent to me. While it was a little stringy and a challenge to cut cleanly, I was able to make some nice pieces with sharp tools and a little patience. It sure isn't cherry.

JKJ

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

#7

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

Don at Central Illinois

>I think it is a close kin of cottonwood and that is really hard (at least for me) to avoid tearout, etc.

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

#8

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>You are right, they are in the same Family. Cottonwood at least has the redeeming quality of often having magnificent figure. I found Weeping Willow to be much more difficult than Eastern Cottonwood.

I have never turned anything except plates and bowls from Cottonwood.

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

#9

Steve Kubien

I have...

Steve Kubien

>I've turned some willow though I cannot tell you what type of willow it was/is. I have some which came from the very base of the tree and it has some nice swirling figure, kinda like mellow curly maple. Colour is a cross between cherry and maple. It is tough to get a clean surface but it sands easily. It's not my favourite wood (by a long shot) but I like it enough to have just picked up a chunk of crotch wood (3 good-sized branches coming off the main branch).

Steve

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

#10

Dick Hines

Re: I have...

Dick Hines

>Sounds like to me you need to pick up a couple of pieces and try it for your self. The only thing you have to loose is your time.

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

#11

Re: I have...

Bill Crommett

>I keep a chunk of Black Willow around to cannibalize for small pieces of bark to replace broken off pieces of natural edge bowls with compatible bark design.

Many years ago a friend brought me a trailer load of 2 1/2 foot diam Black Willow logs to cut up for firewood. After burrowing three wedges which I had to saw out, I took the rest of the logs out to a new sawmill to cut up for paneling for my basement.

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

#12

Bill Blasic

Re: Proof

Bill Blasic

>Steve,

This is a Willow Burl and it turned very nicely.

Bill


img

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

#13

Denis Putland

Re: Proof

Denis Putland

>This is a Laural willow crotch piece, very soft and subject to dints from bumps or even finger nail marks. It can have beautiful grain patterns.

Denis


img

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

#14

Steven Antonucci

of the two, yours appears closer

Steve antonucci

>Are any of them the same as weeping willow? I watched that tree with baited breath- waiting for the day it would be mine. I was so disappointed that I haven't even given it a second look.

I might just fire up the chainsaw tomorrow and take another shot...

Will report back...

Steve

Re: What is Willow like to turn?

#15

Re: of the two, yours appears closer

mike Nelson

>Some of my first turnings were willow, it will turn punky very fast but if you catch it at the right time you will find great colors and spalting.