Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

SCREWED????

Posts

SCREWED????

#1

Don Pencil

SCREWED????

Don Pencil

>Ladies and Gentlemen,

Before I start on this one let me say that this is a personal review of my years of faceplate turning concerning "what size screw to use" and how I would use them.

This will no doubt get me in trouble with some but please keep in mind it is just my personal view.

As to the screws I use in my faceplates, I have never used anything but #6 x 1.25" drywall screws. On end grain and larger bowls I use longer screws. Must of my turning is done with this length screw. The large block of green wood I am turning on my main web page is hanging on a 3.50" dia. with 1.25" x 8 tpi faceplate. The screws are #6 x 1 5/8" drywall screws. When I put the screws in I "toe" them in at an angle for better holding power. Just like I would when nailing boards together. I do not attempt to over tighten the screw. I just want to pull the faceplate up snug to the work. If I set the clutch on the screwdriver to high then it will twist off the head of the screw when it seats in the faceplate. The screws do not cost much so I use them a few times then get rid of them.

I do not see a problem with using bigger, better, longer, stronger, higher quality screws. Use whatever floats your boat. Try some of the suggestions listed in a previous post. I'd bet most of them work or the turners using them would not be using them.

Just my thoughts.

Don

Re: SCREWED????

#2

Re: SCREWED????

Texian

>Don, Yeah, me too, but prefer to call them "deck" screws, which seem to be less brittle than "drywall" screws. Usually drill pilot holes in face grain blanks (or aux. faceplates) to give best grip without excessive torque.

Re: SCREWED????

#3

Re: SCREWED????

Ken

>I apprecate your thoughts and respect them,but the reason that most recomend against useing drywall screws is that they are brittle an can snap much easier than others,why do I say this,it is because it has happened to me.I now use the blue masonary screws with the hex head and I have had some nasty catches on some pretty big bowls and have never had one break on me.Yes they are a bit more expensive,but much safer.

Ken

Re: SCREWED????

#4

Don Pencil

Re: SCREWED????

Don Pencil

>And you be right.

As noted earlier, bigger and better will not hurt a bit.

When you feel safe and comfortale about how the wood is hung then you can think about turning and not worry about these other issues.

That sure makes turnin' a lot more fun.

Be Well,

Don

Re: SCREWED????

#5

Re: SCREWED????

david------WebKitFormBoundarylRgnhGioIdOlFg+1

>Most of the time, the screws break off when I am in the process of removing the faceplate. And I normally try to feather the drill trigger to remove them slowly, without consistent success. I have broken off drywall screws, stainless steel sheet metal screws, coated deck screws, and plain steel sheet metal screws. Removing the imbedded threads is time consuming and a real pain! The stainless screws were probably #12, but the others seemed to be #8s. Will try the blue Tapcon concrete screws next.

Re: SCREWED????

#6

Re: SCREWED????

john lucas

>Ditto what Ken said. I snapped the head of several so then you have to remove the good ones and use vise grips to get the rest of the screw out so you can put a new one in. That's a pain and it's so easy to use sheet metal screws which are much tougher.

I also don't use phillips head or flat blade head for the same reason. I use either hex head bolts or square drive. I've never stripped the head on either of them.

Re: SCREWED????

#7

Steven Antonucci

I love this one- (comes up every so often)

Steve antonucci

>Like Don, I used to use drywall screws, and never broke a single one on the lathe from a bad catch. A drywall screw can support a shear load of around 100#, and most faceplates allow 8 screws, for a shear load of 800# before the blank will come apart. Simply put, this is never going to happen for most people with most lathes. If you turn 800# blanks on a six foot swing, you probably already know not to use drywall screws...

The bigger issue I have found is in having the proper surface to mount your faceplate to, and to have screws that tightly fit the holes on your faceplate. The mounting surface needs to be flat to slightly convex for the faceplate to seat properly. If you don't predrill, the screw will likely raise a nub around the entry hole and cause the faceplate to raise up off the wood slightly. The slightly convex profile gives the wood somewhere to go without moving the faceplate.

Another key this is to use screws that are the same diameter as the holes in the faceplate. If you use a smaller diameter, the can work free and even allow the blank to twist slightly. Matching the shank to the hole eliminates this.

Finally, if you faceplate holes aren't chamfered, take a minute to do it. Any raised grain will go into the chamfer instead of moving the faceplate.

All this said, I use concrete Tapcon screws because they fit the holes much better than drywall screws and have a square drive head. Most of the screws I've broken have been while removing them, but I have never broken a Tapcon.

Steve

Re: SCREWED????

#8

Re: I love this one- (comes up every so often)

wilbur

>"A drywall screw can support a shear load of around 100#, and most faceplates allow 8 screws, for a shear load of 800# before the blank will come apart. Simply put, this is never going to happen for most people with most lathes."

My read on this is that a FORCE of 800 lbs will shear the blank off the faceplate. This could be a 800 lb blank sitting on a faceplate, which admittedly will not happen for most people. But it could also mean a more normal sized blank going at a speed high enough to cause 800 lbs of stress if a catch occurs.

What I don't understand in these discussions is that when it comes to screws, the amount of money saved by using bargain or smaller screws is really quite small. The #6 x 1-5/8" drywall screws mentioned above are about $6 for a box of 200 at the local borg, which comes out to about 3 cents a screw. A box of 180 #12 x 1-3/4" Spax screws works out to be 7.5 cents per screw, and these screws are demonstrably stronger than drywall screws. So for 4.5 cents a screw, or a whopping 36 cents a faceplate, avoiding a spinning blank coming off the faceplate sounds like really cheap insurance to me, especially when I think about 800 lbs of force hitting me in the head.

Re: SCREWED????

#9

Steven Antonucci

It's not the cost, but the physics and strength of

Steve antonucci

>materials that drives me nuts. [Rant on]

Too many people follow these threads without understanding either one, and blindly do whatever is said, never understanding why.

A drywall screw in shear load had plenty of strength to hold most turnings, but people will argue that they've twisted the heads off of them before. A screwdriver does not apply a shear load, but a rotational load, and a catch is probably some combination of shear, rotational and tensile load.

My guess is that no one here has ever broken a dryway screw in a catch, and if they did, they probably shouldn't be turning. More likely, the've ripped the wood off of the screw or loosen it in a severe catch (which is pulling against the tensile strength of the screw), and has nothing to do with whether or not the screw is strong enough from a material perspective.

In addition, if you understand how materials fail and what engineers refer to as a factor of safety, you'd see that a drywall screw with a 100# weight hung off of it in sheer would likely not fail at all. Engineers know that most people aren't engineers, so they design in a fudge factor (usually 2X) to account for the shallow end of the gene pool. I'd bet an average drywall screw could hold 125# in shear before instanteous failure, but that's purely a guess.

I don't use drywall screws for the other reasons I've mentioned, but folks, please stop worrying about the strength issues! The artificial conditions it would require to actually simulaneously fail 8 drywall screws is either something we'd need to see on MythBusters or Darwin's Theory of Natural Selection at work!

Steve

[Rant off]

Re: SCREWED????

#10

Re: I love this one- (comes up every so often)

Ken

>I forgit to mention thise,but when I mount REAL hardwood,I not only predrill,but will smear a little wax on the screws,letting you insert an remove them much easier.

As for how much weight they will hold can up, can be misleading,because when they are holding dry wall or something ,there is no strain or torque involved,but when you mount a 5 lb blank then crank up a spinning lathe,thats where the danger comes in.

Re: SCREWED????

#11

Some physics geekery

wilbur

>So I got curious, and tried to remember my high school physics, and this is what I came up with. Apologies in advance for those who don't like metric, but it makes the calculations easier.

Suppose you have a 8" square x 3" thick maple blank, and spin it on your lathe for roughing out at 500 rpms. (I picked 500 rpms because this is the low speed on the venerable 10" Jet mini lathe.) Given the density of maple, the weight of the blank will be about 2.2 kg (5 lbs). The outside of the 8" blank will be traveling at about 1900 m/s.

Now suppose there's a catch. The blank goes from 500 rpm to 0 really quickly. I haven't ever seem anyone time a catch, but suppose that it's 0.3 seconds for the blank to stall out. (I actually think this is an overestimation -- you can win a basketball game with 0.3 seconds on the clock.) So 2.2 kg going from 1900 m/s to 0 in 0.3 seconds generates 14000 kg-m/s2 of force, or 14000 newtons. If the time to stop the blank is less, the force generated goes up.

As it turns out, 800 lbs of force is only 3600 newtons, which is much less than what I described above. Now, stalling my imaginary 8" maple bowl blank probably doesn't generate a full 14000 newtons of force, since all the weight isn't directly behind the point of contact. But running through these numbers, it seems uncomfortably close to me.

So again, at 4.5 cents a screw, I don't see that the savings by going with smaller, cheaper screws really adds up to much.

Re: SCREWED????

#12

Steven Antonucci

Your math is a mess

Steve antonucci

>Sorry, but you aren't even close. I looked just at the speed 1900 m/s is impossibly high!

let's take a 12" blank with a circumference of Pi X D or approximately 3 feet. at 500 RPM (PER minute), the blank surface travels about 1500 feet per minute, not 1900 METERs per Second. The difference is my blank is traveling abotu 17 mph while yours is traveling at 4000 mph. I would guess that would shear the heads off of any bolt...

Steve

B.E. from top 3 engineering school...

Re: SCREWED????

#13

Sorry - multiplied instead of divided by 60

wilbur

>Oops. Sorry. Don't know what happened there -- I thought I double checked everything. It looks like I multiplied instead of divided when converting rpm to rps

8" blank = 0.2 meters * 3.14 = circumference of 0.63 meters at 500 rpms is 5.25 m/s. Plugging that in, I get 115 newtons with the scenario I had above, well within the shear strength of 8 drywall screws.

Sorry about that. Still, I learned something today.

Re: SCREWED????

#14

Re: It's not the cost, but the physics and strengt

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Well, actually, I have managed to break drywall screws off with a catch, which is why I have not used them in years. I have also broken them off in enough things that I don't even use them for drywall anymore. I have even had catches where I bent decking screws, which are supposedly a whole lot tougher. Now, I don't have a lot of catches, but when I do, they are usually pretty spectacular.

As a teacher, I find it is best to avoid the whole drywall screw thing altogether. As a turner, I think they are more trouble than they are worth.

Re: SCREWED????

#15

Re: SCREWED????

Don Orr

>Don-looks like you got what you expected ! ;-))

I rarely use faceplates, but I agree with Steve about the diameter of the screw matching the hole. I feel there is less chance of vibration. Same goes for the countersinking he mentions. Every little bit helps. Go with what you know though.

Happy and Safe Turning Everyone !

Re: SCREWED????

#16

Seems I've done the impossible...

DavidWalser

>

...

My guess is that no one here has ever broken a dryway screw in a catch, and if they did, they probably shouldn't be turning. More likely, the've ripped the wood off of the screw or loosen it in a severe catch (which is pulling against the tensile strength of the screw), and has nothing to do with whether or not the screw is strong enough from a material perspective.

...


When I was very new to turning, I had a bad catch while roughing out a large bowl. The catch was bad enough it sheared off three of the six drywall screws used to hold the blank to the faceplate. The remaining three were severely bent and the blank cantered away from the faceplate/headstock at a disturbing angle.

Granted, maybe I shouldn't have been turning. I did a lot of things wrong that all combined to cause the near disaster. It as only a near disaster because the remaining three screws, while bent, still held the blank to the lathe. If the blank had let fly, or if I'd allowed myself to be hit by the blank as it spun in an ever wider arc (before I could turn the lathe off), or if the tool rest had it me as it was knocked off the lathe, etc., I most likely wouldn't be a turner today. (Not a loss to the art form.)

One of the things I did wrong was I didn't prepare a flat spot for the faceplate to be secured to the blank. I had run it over the jointer a few times, but I'd only gotten the blank "flatish". The faceplate still rocked from side-to-side before I screwed it in place. Another thing I did wrong was not to recheck how secure the blank was attached to the faceplate from time-to-time. I started roughing one evening and returned to that task a couple of days later -- without rechecking the tightness of the screws. And, of course, my tools weren't as sharp as they should have been nor was my technique what it should have been.

As I said, I was very new and made lots of mistakes. Would all this have happened with better screws? Heck, I might have been in trouble with 1/4"x3" lag bolts. However, the margin for error (and I was making lots of errors) would have been greater with better screws.

I'm a better turner today and might be able to get away with drywall screws. I like the greater margin for error I get with better screws.

Re: SCREWED????

#17

Steven Antonucci

I stand corrected :-)

Steve antonucci

>I have had a few spectacular catches over the years, but I've never sheared any screw. Between your post and Bill G.'s, I gather that the evidence that it can't be done is overwhelmingly against me.

Most importantly, you recognize that the fault was largely yours and not the screws. I bet that I could do enough things wrong to break a drywall screw, since I once snapped the tool rest post on my Crapsman lathe (which was about 3/4" of cast iron if memory serves me well) AND the scraper that I had made out of an old file (which was 1/4" x 1") [AN event I refer to as the MOAC - Mother of ALL Catches] , but oddly enough, none of the drywall screws :-)

Used properly, drywall screws are fine. Used improperly, you'd better get an impact drive for those 1/2" lag bolts and a remote power switch...

Steve

P.S. Did I mention I use TAPCONS? :-)

Re: SCREWED????

#18

Re: SCREWED????

John Jordan

>Well,if you have to figure the answer to this question in "newtons" you probably are screwed. :)

There are no catch proof holding methods, though some are better than others.

A box of SPAX screws will last for years.

John

Re: SCREWED????

#19

Spax gets a vote from me, too, John

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I remember when those guys first introduced Spax screws to America. It was a real awareness boost to realize that toughness was an option in a screw. Low end screws like drywall screws and various deck screws can't stand up to high torque or shear forces as well as Spax screws. Actually, I've used some self-tapping stainless deck screws on the ipe porch floor I installed a couple years ago. Those suckers were really tough. I don't recall any snapping off (in ipe! no less).

What it comes down to is that every fastening situation is going to involve holding power and shear strength. If you just want to play it safe, go for the best screws you can find. But for everything else, there is a continuum of strength and toughness that matches your style and the work at hand.

Ellis

Re: SCREWED????

#20

Re: Spax gets a vote from me, too, John

steve worcester

>I guess I went to a hardened screw because I kept camming out the phillips head in Spax, and the local store that sold Spax went under. But I still won't teach faceplate use with drywall screws. Now a days, after years of learning patience to cut and letting the edge cut instead of brute force, I could probably get away with them. Thing is, every now and again I still get a catch and knowing how much head injuries cost, a few cents here or there, I can buy a lot of screws for the cost of another MRI (no they weren't woodturning induced).

But like Don says, use what works for you, a good mantra.