Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Red narra box...

Posts

Red narra box...

#1

Mike Stafford

Red narra box...

Mike Stafford

>My wife gave me several pieces of red narra as a gift a while back. This box is turned from that stock and is the first box I have turned from the red narra varietal. Red narra is the red headed step child or perhaps it is better said, step parent to amboyna. When red narra is burled it gets a new name- amboyna burl.

This wood is in the same family as padauk but is not as astringent to me as padauk. Also the dust from it does not seem to dye everything it comes into contact with.

The box is 3" in diameter and 2 1/2" tall. Comments appreciated...


img

Re: Red narra box...

#2

Re: Red narra box...

Carl Barton

>I love it. Simple in design, but elegant. Thank you for sharing.

Carl

Re: Red narra box...

#3

Dick Hines

Re: Red narra box...

Dick Hines

>This is a beautiful little box Mike Now all you need is some copper wire and..............

Re: Red narra box...

#4

Re: Red narra box...

Marc Phillips

>Very nice.... I like the shape and grain orientation... looks great!

Re: Red narra box...

#5

Re: Red narra box...

Greg Haugen

>Mike, I really like this box. The form and proportions are wonderful. The form has a hint of a "bag of sand" in the form with the weight or largest diameter lower than usual. It's a hard form to get right without making it look like it's stuck or melted to the table. I think you nailed it perfectly!! The form has weight/"line as volume" but it's still so very elegant. The beautiful wood is showcased with an excellent finish. Well Done!! Very Nice!!

Greg H.

Re: Red narra box...

#6

Re: Red narra box...

George in Minnesota

>Great job, Mike!

Re: Red narra box...

#7

Re: Red narra box...

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>The first ( and only other) time I heard the phrase, 'line as volume' , was from David Ellsworth in one of his workshops. Is that where you heard it also, or form somewhere else? I am presuming that the phrase did not originate with you because you put it in quotes. I like the phrase and, after Ellsworth, try for the same effect in most of my hollow forms. And , yes, I agree that this box does convey that feeling

Re: Red narra box...

#8

Re: Red narra box...

Greg Haugen

>Eliot,

I've heard it from Bill Luce, among others. I do believe the phrase started with Ellsworth. This box is an excellent example of it.

Greg H.

Re: Red narra box...

#9

Steven Antonucci

Does it smell like Amboyna?

Steve antonucci

>I've only turned it once, and the fragrance was so powerful, that I think it stuck with me moreso than the figure. I have to assume that the wood is the same as the burl?

Like the box too.

Steve

Re: Red narra box...

#10

Re: Red narra box...

charlie belden

>Nice piece with nice grain alignment.

Pity it, and padouk, are so open grained. It's almost impossible to clean out the sawdust and stuff that gets in the open grain and shows.

Re: Red narra box...

#11

Re: Red narra box...

paul waddle

>I like your box Mike,the proportions are just right. Thks,pw.

Re: Red narra box...

#12

Mike Stafford

Re: Red narra box...

Mike Stafford

>Greg, I have been trying to come up with a box that has decent proportions and shape that is based on the bag of sand concept. Over on WoW a while back you might remember the discussion about a bag of sand form. I have not got it quite right and I continue to work on it.

Thanks for the comments everyone.

Re: Red narra box...

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: Does it smell like Amboyna?

Mike Stafford

>Steve, it has an odor but to me it is not as strong as padauk. Padauk irritates me so I don't turn it any more. I have turned amboyna a few times and I do not recall it being very strong in smell.

Re: Red narra box...

#14

Mike Stafford

Re: Red narra box...

Mike Stafford

>Thank you George.

I heard a bunch of you guys had a day at the lathe and turned a bunch of boxes. I hope I get to see them on your web site.

Re: Red narra box...

#15

keep practicing, Mike, ...

matt overton

>...one of these times it won't be perfect. Beautiful!!!!!

Re: Red narra box...

#16

Mike Stafford

A fellow does need practice...Thanks everyone!

Mike Stafford

>

Re: Red narra box...

#17

Re: A fellow does need practice

GalenV in Iowa

>Michael

Is it just a lot of practice in turning boxes that you can hold the bottom of the box by the the lip when you finish the bottom?

In one of your photos you are using what appears to be serratted jaws and yet you can turn the bottom and not leave jaw marks on the lip.

I seem to end up with jaw marks on some or have had a few make a flying trip. I use the tailstock pressure till the last final cutting. On some smaller boxes I only have smooth jaw to hold and smaller lip.

It is hard to get the feel of differnt typs of wood and the actual pressure being applied. Are some chuck better for telling pressure being applied? I have a Talon with #2 sarrated jaws and smooth spigot jaws.

I'd sure take your comments.

Galen

Re: Red narra box...

#18

Mike Stafford

Re: A fellow does need practice

Mike Stafford

>Galen, I am assuming you are referring to the photos in my tutorial here on WC. If that is the case I am not using serrated jaws but I am using smooth profile dovetailed jaws to hold the lip. I only do this when I have sized the box appropriately so that I can hold the box in a full grip without the corners of the jaws coming in contact with the lip in an angular fashion that would result in marring the flange.

The best option is to use a waste block and turn a jam chuck although sometimes I wrap the body flange with tape and then grip the wrapped surface with dovetail jaws.

I hope some of that makes sense.

Re: Red narra box...

#19

Mike Stafford

Additional thoughts....

Mike Stafford

>Galen, I realized I did not completely answer your questions. Talon and Stronghold chucks are very good chucks but I prefer chucks with dovetail jaws for the reasons I mentioned in my first response. If I have sized the box appropriately I can have just the sharp dovetail edge of jaw along its full circumference gripping the box flange and usually it will do so without marring.

Yes, experience with the different woods does play a factor. If I have any doubts or if I have turned a box that will not fit one of the many jaw sizes I have then I use a jam chuck with waste wood. You cannot go wrong using a jam chuck.

Sometimes, most of the time, I use tape to help hold the body on when I reverse chuck to turn the bottom. Tape is cheap insurance; so use it and save the heartbreak of the flying box. Just a little tape can make a big difference. Another thing that is important is to use a gouge on the bottom with the bevel gliding along behind the edge which helps hold the body on the jaws or the chuck. However if you use too much pressure the heel of the bevel can bruise the wood behind the cut which can be a bear to remove.

I hope that provides better answers.

Re: Red narra box...

#20

Thanks Mike

GalenV in Iowa

>Mike

Yes it is the Wood Central article you did on turned boxes. It did say you cut dovetail tenon but until I enlarged the one photo on turning the bottom it now clearly shows the dovetail type jaws. I guess it did not sink in gripping the lip would be back at the stronger part of the box and not farther out on the rim. I can see even if it marked it would not be like my serrated.

I have tried tape and found it was a bigger mistake to use a wide rubber band to cushion, too flexible! I did try a jam chuck but seems like every one I did would take a new size.

I could see how a little vacuum chuck for small box sizes may work but a lot of cost for boxes I do. Thought about a rubber expansion plug of some type.

Yes, I found if I was not carefull with my detail gouge and let the bevel rub too hard it worked like a nice chattering tool and created more work to correct.

I like the shape of your posted box as mine are all a little on the plain side till I can get more creative.

Thanks again for comments.

Galen

Re: Red narra box...

#21

Mike Stafford

Re: Thanks Mike

Mike Stafford

>Galen, I don't know of a way to turn boxes where I don't have to turn a different jam chuck to match. If I ever get good enough to hollow and sand every box to the exact same internal diameter I will be sure to let you know....Fat chance, huh?

You are most welcome.