Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

Posts

Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

#1

Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

Pete in Holland, MI

>Are there any serious drawbacks to an aluminum face plate? Looking for a 1-1/4" x 8 thread 3" diameter plate.

Any sources for a plate like this, in steel/iron, other than Packard & Craft Supplies?

Thanks !

Pete

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

#2

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

RPE

>I got some for my PM 3520 from Don Pencil. Good price and quality.

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

#3

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

GalenV in Iowa

>Pete

Do not have an answer but when I see the aluminum advertised I wondered if they will gall or sieze to the spindle steel threads? Some I see are anodized and this may reduce that.

Wonder if you need to use a different screw to hold the blank so it does not loosen up on soft aluminum?

Wonder if my concerns are valid or not?

Galen

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

#4

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

Scott in Socal

>I've heard many complaints of aluminum faceplates seizing or getting stuck on spindles. For now I'm sticking to steel.

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

#5

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

Jim Sebring

>I've not had any problem with my Pencil 3 1/2 inch aluminum faceplate seizing on the spindle, but I have had a devil of a time getting the stainless faceplate that came with my DVR XP loose. I finally resorted to using a teflon washer with the SS faceplate. Now it comes loose easily. Apparently it was sticking to the bearing race.

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

#6

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

Norm Smith

>I have about 6 of Don Pencils aluminum face plates and havent had a problem. They work just great.

Norm

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

#7

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

Don at Central Illinois

>This question must be an omen. I have 2 or 3 Don Pencil aluminum faceplates and was planning on going online and ordering another 2 or 3, when I saw this post. I've never had any problems, so far, with them but I don't turn really large pieces. Need a bigger lathe!

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

#8

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

Stuart Johnson

>I had a problem with an aluminum face plate sticking to an aluminum chuck reversing adapter. I finally ended up cutting the chuck off the adapter. Someone on one of the lists explained what happened that sounded reasonable. He said aluminum under high magnification looks like fish scales. When the aluminum face plate was screwed tightly on the adapter the "scales" inter locked and would not separate. The thread sort of died at that point so I don't know why this doesn't happen with all chucks or aluminum to aluminum contact. I do not have any problem with aluminum face plates and the spindle.

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

#9

Mine work fine

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I've been using Don Pencil's faceplates for my smaller pieces for over ten years with no seize-ups or other drawbacks. I have a washer I made from a coffee can lid that I use with all my chucks. Maybe that's why I've had no seize-ups.

I usually use drywall screws or zippers with my Pencil chucks, as the mounting holes are small and many. My regular #14 sheet metal screws won't fit the holes and would be overkill anyhow.

Ellis


Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

#10

Dick Hines

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

Dick Hines

>The face plate that came with my PM was steel and I got 2 more that were aluminum. Got good service form both kinds.

I don't use a face plate any more. I started a couple of yesra ago starting everything between centers. It gives be a better chance to get the efect I want with the grain fo the wood.

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

#11

I like cast iron

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Pete,

I like to turn big bowls and platters, I have both aluminum and cast iron (from Oneway) and prefer the weight of the cast iron, it adds to the flywheel factor which helps my under-rigged Nova 3000.

The only problem I had with the aluminum face plates was an errant gouge, now I have a nasty reminder that makes me pay more attention.

Jorge

Re: Aluminum -vs- steel/iron face plates

#12

Thanks all !

Pete in Holland, MI

>I think as a traditionalist and durability junkie, I'll save a little more coin and buy an iron based face plate. Thanks for all of your in puts !

Pete