Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

Posts

BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

#1

BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

charlie belden

>I still want to do a reasonably nice piece that - scurries away when it "hears" a loud noice (like a hand clamp) or feels vibration (you bumped the display case). The HexBug CRAB micor-robot I want to use can only carry 62 grams or about 2 1/4 ounces.

Working out how to hide the bot in a piece wasn't a problem, though turning a piece is tricky given the "hump" inside - but I've gotten that one solved, more or less.

It's the Less - turning a piece that's 5 to 5 1/2" in diameter and 2 1/2" to 3" tall that's the tricky part. Would be a LOT easier if I could keep things simple - but I can't.

Have the one on the right down to 3 1/4 ounces - and enough room to thin things down more - hopefully to 2 1/4" ounces - or less.

(Couldn't get the left one down below about 5 oz)


img

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

#2

Balsa wood???

Adrien Coblentz

>

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

#3

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

john lucas

>Charlie try using Catalpa. It's fairly tough and really light when dry. I usually have plenty but I'm out right now. It can also be turned quite thin.

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

#4

Re: Or willow, or cottonwood. Where are...

Jamie D

>... you located Charlie- I have a big chunk of catalpa sitting in my driveway!

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

#5

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

GalenV in Iowa

>Sounds like it is time to do some carving on the Left one or pierce a section up near the top rim of the Right one.

Try giving that bug a steriod treatment and see if the Energizer Bunny can give it a pick me up.

Finished piece must be on a short video as a still shot will just not do it for me now!

Keep at it.

Galen

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

#6

I still love your sick mind. :o)

Al Neighbors

>

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

#7

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

John K Jordan

>Significant piercing or just drill it full of holes. Or gently sand blast to thin. The weight issue was one reason I suggested a stationary vessel with legs in the air.

JKJ

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

#8

Re: Or willow, or cottonwood. Where are...

charlie belden

>I'm in San Jose, CA - Silly Cone Valley, south end of San Francisco Bay. Thanks for the suggestion and offer. I'll check with my aborist/sawyer/ woodworker friend and see if he'll put a chunk of catalpa on his Save For Charlie List.

The first piece - the one closer to a hollow form was turned from green California Pepper. All the chucking and reverse chucking and re-chucking was a nightmare since I turned some, stuck it in shavings, waited a bit, turned some more - and the piece kept deforming as it shrank. Made thinning the walls down impossible towards the end - at about 200 gms. This kind of piece - this light - can't be done with green wood - at least not by me.

This piece is in "bone dry" beech or maybe it 's birch. A sharp skew yields a presentable surface - but the hollowing is being done mainly with the MiniMonster captured hollowing systems - which scrapes rather than shears. So inside sanding is necessary periodically to get to a smooth surface before resuming scraping - rather than "texturing" (read "chattering").

Thankfully, bcause I started with dry wood, things have stayed round, making all the rechucking and reverse chucking keeping the piece running true.

The key to this piece working - aside from the 62 gms weight limit - is that the inside "hump" hiding the Bot NOT be obvious. Any piercing would have to be little holes since larger ones would reveal the inner "hump".

Executing this idea of a Scurrying Bowl or Pot has been interesting. Makes the earlier Internally Lit idea seem trivial by comparison.

If this idea doesn't pan out, putting the Bot inside a piece - legs up - with attachments that can extend out the opening in the top of the piece - and wave around - is a fall back project.

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

#9

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

Cyril Griesbach

>Consider Basswood, Charlie. Very light, strong and cuts like a dream.

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

#10

Steven Antonucci

Have you done a Proof of Concept?

Steve antonucci

>I'm guessing that you arrived at 62 grams by some trial and error, but I would imagine that the shape would alter the robot's ability to scurry? Wider will create a larger moment where narrower might center the force over the robot's center of gravity?

Hate to see you get the weight and not have it scurry. Maybe do some 2 part hollowforms to prove the concept?

S

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

#11

Re: Have you done a Proof of Concept?

charlie belden

>AFTER doing the first pot - and discovering the CRAB didn't have the oooomph to move a 220 gm piece - I stacked weights on the top of the little critter until it wasn't able to move anymore - down to adding or removing a penny. That gave me the 62 gm carrying capacity.

As for the shape of the piece affecting the bot's ability to move - I think I may have mislead you by describing its movement as scurrying. Rather than scurrying, like a roach, it crawls, more like a hermit crab. Since it doesn't accellerate or decellerate quickly, I doubt the height to width ratio will be an issue - but it might. Determining all the critical parameters - before making a first or second prototype sounds like it'd wring all the fun out of this idea. At this point, there's not much fun left in working on this idea and I'm reaching the limits of an acceptable return on investment. Already sprained a finger sanding the inside of this thing - a really dumb thing to do - as you might guess from lokking at the attached image. NOW I'll use a curve hemostat to hold the sand paper.

I still have reducing the weight of the bot itself as an option. It has extra plastic on it to make it look like a stylixed crab, including claws. I can trim down the top and remove the claws to get rid of a little more weight.

Perhaps I'll take another try at this idea - starting with DRY catalpa or basswood - if this piece can't be made to work. That'll be AFTER I regain full use of the sprained finger.

Thanks to all for comments and suggestions.


img

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

#12

Re: BotPot - The Quest For A 2.25 Oz Piece

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>By observing the rule of thirds you can reduce the size and also the depth of the foot and lose a lot of weight. A plus is that you'll very much improve the profile of the piece.

Wally