Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Bowl's Inside Curve Determine Foot Size?

Posts

Bowl's Inside Curve Determine Foot Size?

#1

Bowl's Inside Curve Determine Foot Size?

charliel belden

>Maybe it's from years of being a Futurist (what socio-economic factors will affect houshold daily vehicle trip generation and specifically peak hour trips - and how?), but I seem to look for underlying relationships between things.

Lately it's been the bowls - with "feet", two curve tangents and transition points of intersecting curves.

For the foot, the "rule" is often one of the following:

One Third The Maximum Diameter of the piece

or

Four Fifths The Maximum Diameter of the piece

BUT - if the profile is to be a reverse curve (think "S" curve with a little cut off the top and bottom) - is the "rule" referring to the BOTTOM of the foot - or - the transition point where the curve of the side of the bowl intersects the transition curve of the foot - OR - half way between the two?

(I know - you're thinking "Engineers. Always looking for a short cut or rule to use.")

There are reasons why some "rules" exist - the Golden Ratio for architects and artists for example. Until someone worked out one point and two point perspective, drawings and paintings looked pretty flat rather than more realistic. We come with some pre-wired biases - which helped our ancestors avoid extinction - a built in preference, conscious or not, for "this" rather than "that". For example, most of us can see when a hung picture isn't hanging right - we note horizontal and vertical - or not. For a woodturner - it's a "flat" or line between two curves where there should be a smooth, seamless transition.

So - I went looking for the Magic Secret to bowl curves, transtions and foot size. And I think I may be stumbling onto something which has to do with not just the outside curves - but the inside curve.

Attached for your perusal and consideration - the potential beginning of A Rule - Of Thumb.

(fun playing with curves in a simple CAD program)

Comments, suggestions, observations welcomed.


img

Re: Bowl's Inside Curve Determine Foot Size?

#2

Re: Bowl's Inside Curve Determine Foot Size?

Walter Ahlgrim

>I like your chart and it can explains why I many funnels. But it is based on the assumption that the wall thickness is uniform.

Walta

Re: Bowl's Inside Curve Determine Foot Size?

#3

Re: Bowl's Inside Curve Determine Foot Size?

charliel belden

>> I like your chart and it can explains why

> (I make so) many funnels.

Yup - developing an eye for curves that

meet at their tangent points sure improves

the flow of your profile. Getting the

proportions right also has some rules of

thumb

> But it is based on the assumption that the

> wall thickness is uniform.

Hence Rule of Thumb, not The RULE. It can

help narrow the range of possibilities and

provides one of the many ways of semi-

planning a piece that probably will look nice.

It also helps to know what to look for - or

avoid - for a nicer piece.

Re: Bowl's Inside Curve Determine Foot Size?

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Bowl's Inside Curve Determine Foot Size?

Keith Tompkins

>Interesting thought,Charle, but I think the size of the foot depends on two factors: the bowl's intended use, and the desired appearance. The smaller the foot, the better profile can be obtained, but stability suffers. The bigger the foot, the better the stability, but appearance suffers. Pretty hard to create a concrete formula for that, the one-third rule is a pretty good compromise.

Re: Bowl's Inside Curve Determine Foot Size?

#5

Re: Bowl's Inside Curve Determine Foot Size?

charliel belden

>Keith:

Good point about the function of the piece and the size of the foot - but I'm assuming aesthetics takes precedent over function for much of what's shown here.

The One Third Rule (of thumb) Ambiguity

- is the one third the max. diameter of the

piece

at the bottom of the foot,

or

at the transition point with the sides of the piece

or

somewhere between the two?

Not sure it's the same with turning as with "flat work", but it would seem at least starting out with some sort of plan in mind might make the results less uncertain.

Re: Bowl's Inside Curve Determine Foot Size?

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Bowl's Inside Curve Determine Foot Size?

Keith Tompkins

>Plan? Absolutely...you're right on the mark there!