New favorite tool
Carole Valentine
>Had to turn a bunch of stoppers today so I gave my new Thompson detail gouge a workout. That is one SWEET tool! Every shop needs at least one.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
New favorite tool
Carole Valentine
>Had to turn a bunch of stoppers today so I gave my new Thompson detail gouge a workout. That is one SWEET tool! Every shop needs at least one.
Re:And I ain't loaning mine either!!!
Jamie D
>
Had one for almost 2 years
Steve antonucci
>and I couldn't agree more...
Steve
I have 2
john lucas
>and I use one of them on every project.
I have 2 as well........
Richard Jones-
>a 3/8" and a 1/2" , what great tools, a real joy to use.
Rich
Re: I have 3 but
Denis Putland
>though I find nothing wrong with them I fail to see the wow factor that seems to abound.
I still have to go to the stone in about the same time period as for my Crown gouges.
And I am a thinking that I might prefer the shape of the Crown flutes but not a big difference.
As I said no complaint's but also no WOW.
Denis
Re: New favorite tool
Frank C. Joseph
>Have 2 and love them. with out question they are my go to tool...
Re: New favorite tool
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
>Thanks Carole and everyone, I like the flute shape on this gouge, it has a nice radius for the diameter and it's the number one tool out of all of them.
Re: I have 3 but
john lucas
>The wow for me on those tools is the rigidity. They do hold an edge longer but what I like is being able to hang them over the tool rest really far when needed. The lack of vibration is really noticeable.
I sharpen mine to 40 degrees so they are really great at cleaning up problem areas in bowl interiors as long as the bowl is shallow enough. They also chatter a lot less when hollowing deep boxes.
Re: I have 3 but
Richard Jones-
>Denis,
I can only compare them to the Sorby's that I own. In that regard, I really think they are the heads up favorite. They are all ground the same as far as angle is concerned, and the Thompson's stay sharper quite a bit longer. I also feel that, to add to what John said, they are so much stiffer than my Sorbys that the cut just feels so much different and smoother to me. The flutes are different on each brand, so it's hard to compare them evenly. I do know that I reach for the Thompsons first.
Maybe no WOW factor from me, but a definite "Oh my". It's also entirely possible that I would feel the same with the Crown's. I'm not a "brand" type person, I use what I like and what works for me, regardless of the name.
Rich
Re: I have 3 but
Gordon Seto
>I believe they are the best friend for multi-axis turning when there is always a large tool overhang over the tool rest. I ground mine around 30 degree, that is something that you have to get used to; but it allows me access to very tight spot.
Last year I did a hands-on off set demo for our Club and a class afterward. The member was using my detail gouge for the whole afternoon; regular spindle gouge can't extend that far without chatter. I sharpen my tools with Tormek; I hate to mess the grind up with dry grinder. The Thompson steel are so tough, it takes time to convert the grind back to my Tormek setting. My Thompson detail gouge was not sharpen for the whole day. IT stayed sharp the whole time; our member was impressed with the tool and asked me what that was and wanted to buy one.
I have 3
Bill Clark
>I now have 3. All bowl gouges. One is a "V" flute and 2 are "U" flutes. I put them in Dave Peebles' handles. For me the combination is perfect. The Peebles handles give me an even grip anywhere on the handle and the extra weight stabilizes the tool. The long lasting edge and smoothness when working far over the tool rest allow some pretty amazing cuts. I also grind them to 40 degrees but back bevel the heel to make tighter inside cuts. This is necessary for me because the flutes are not as deep as some of my other gouges.
Re: New favorite tool
Ed Conhaim
>Newbie question...what is the difference between a detail gouge and a spindle gouge. What are the best applications for each? Thank you
i gotta have one!
robert davis
>i have a3/8 spindle gouge and 3/4 skew , they are great. this will have to be next
It depends on who you ask
john lucas
>Doug's detail gouge has a shallow flute compared to the spindle gouge. This leaves more metal under the flute which means a stiffer tool.
Re: New favorite tool
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
>The detail gouge is made to turn coves and beads while the spindle gouge does well on flowing curves. It all has to do with the width of the flute, the spindle gouge has a wide flute so a large radius is ground on the cutting edge while the detail has a narrower flute so a smaller radius is ground.
I make custom tools for 8 different professionals, they could go to any manufacture but come to me because the steel and heat treatment is better than anything else on the market today. The list of professionals who use the standard tools is as long as my arm. This started a couple years ago with a batch of 29 tools and now I'm one machine away from being able to manufacture any product. There are woodturners who have great ideas for a product but can't get it manufactured at a fair price... I'll do it by the end of the year.
And isn't it nice....
Steven Kubien
>....when you can support the smaller scale, independent tool maker? This is part of why I love dealing with the Thompson's, Niles and Knights of the world.
Cheers,
Steve Kubien
Re: i gotta have one!
Richard Jones-
>Robert,
I bought a 3/4" Raffan skew a year or so ago, and it's a great tool. I bought a 1/2" Thompson skew about 4-5 months ago, radiused it 'cause that's the way I like it, and it is hands down superior to the bigger skew. Cuts cleaner, stays sharper longer, easier for me to use, etc.
Rich
Yep!
Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine
>You got that right Steve.
That is why I delight in dealing with them.
jorge
Re: New favorite tool
Dick Hines
>I have 2 detail gouges in the 3/8" size. I could not do finials if I did not have them.