Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Molly Winton plagerism

Posts

Molly Winton plagerism

#1

Molly Winton plagerism

mfoster

>I recently attended the Totally Turning symposium in Saratoga Springs and really enjoyed the time. I met many of the people who post here and was overloaded with ideas that the presenters shared. I attended a couple of Molly's presentations, as well as one by Rolly Munro regarding texturing and carving. My interest has been leaning in this direction, so I thought I'd give a go at some texturing. I really liked the idea of Molly's small vessels, and the idea that turning and texturing one is a relatively instant gratification. Moreover, a small vessel seems an ideal way of experimenting with form and surface decoration. I recently purchased a burner, and have multiple carving tools which I have used, but not for texturing. So this is a little Molly vessel with carving texture done with the Ryobi on the bottom, stippling with my dental handpiece in the upper band, and texturing on the top with the burner. I liked Molly's carved openings, so plagiarized this as well. I tried to compliment the carved opening with the pattern of the burning.

I thought the final result would look better in black rather than natural and wanted to experiment with that as well. I didn't have black gesso on hand, so used some india ink and finished with some flat black spray enamel. I'm thinking about trying a finish coat of black (or perhaps some color) oil paint (as in fine art oils).

I had a little chat with Ruth Niles while I was there and she did not think Molly would mind me using her ideas. I give all the credit to Molly, (thanks Molly) but it was really fun, and I think these little vessels could be addictive.


img

Re: Molly Winton plagerism

#2

size

mfoster

>forgot, ash, 3" x 3"

Re: Molly Winton plagerism

#3

Re: size------WebKitFormBoundary8wCWnDRsAy9Jf+4m

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>If I were writing this post, I think I would use a term like, 'influence', or 'inspiration' -- not 'plagerism'. I presume you trying to be lighthearted.

------WebKitFormBoundary8wCWnDRsAy9Jf+4m

Re: Molly Winton plagerism

#4

Re: size------WebKitFormBoundary8wCWnDRsAy9Jf+4m

mfoster------WebKitFormBoundary6h+hF1gNvuvabq+x

>I thought about using "influence", but this is so close to what Molly has been doing, that I had to really give all the credit to her. I guess I'm sensitive to an artists style/body of work and consciously try to NOT copy others work. This is so blatantly what Molly does, that I could not take credit for it. Although I produced the product, the idea remains Molly's. I love what Molly has been doing, and just could not resist trying my hand at one of her pieces.

Mike

Re: Molly Winton plagerism

#5

Re: Molly Winton plagerism

George Van Beynen

>You did a good job Mike; this would be recognizable as a Molly clone. At first reading the title I thought you had come across someone selling a table full of Molly� copies. I'm sure you had fun doing this and learned a lot in the process doing this will make you appreciate Molly�s work that much more. Molly will undoubtedly be pleased.

Re: Molly Winton plagerism

#6

Re: Molly Winton plagerism

Carole Valentine

>To my eye, the only thing I think you could directly attribute to Molly is the square carved opening and who knows - someone may have done that before Mol. People have been doing black and textured for ages. I remember being accused four years ago of imitating some guy in VA that I never heard of when I did a black vessel with a texture like what you used on the lower part of yours. Incensed at the accusation, I looked him up and found that he did his texturing with a hammer and I did mine with a carver but the end result looked similar. Just have fun with the explorations. If any of us are extremely lucky, we MAY come up with something that's never been done before, but I am beginning to wonder if that is even possible! LOL

Re: Molly Winton plagerism

#7

Steven Antonucci

Funny how that works

steve antonucci

>While the small black vessel is clearly something Molly is know for, I don't think anyone who has seen her work and knew it would be "confused" by this piece. It's a piece of her style, but theres's a lot more to it.

Many folks have done black before Molly. Many have done carved rims. Many have done texture. It's the way that Molly pieces them all together that makes her work stand out.

I'd like to see you incorporate "black" into one of the Fibonacci objects - if you could bring yourself to paint after all of that sanding and carving :-)

steve

P.S. I understood your original intent, as I have some black gesso on the shelf in the garage too...

Re: Molly Winton plagerism

#8

Love it!

Molly Winton

>Mike, this is great. I really like what you did on the top portion, and the carved rim. I appreciate the consideration you gave me not knowing how I may react to a similar piece, but I'm totally cool with it. Copying techniques is an excellent way of learning a process. As someone said in this thread, I'm not the first person to make a black piece, or to use these texturing techniques. I learned both from John Jordan. What makes our work our own, is how after we've learned a technique, we then interpret it or use it in our future pieces. My pieces don't look like John's, but his influence is seen if you're familiar with his work, the same way as Graeme Priddle's influence is in my work too.

Please don't be apologetic. I'm completely flattered.

Re: Molly Winton plagerism

#9

Re: Love it!

mfoster------WebKitFormBoundary6h+hF1gNvuvabq+x

>Thanks Molly,

I really enjoyed your presentations I sat in on, and I really enjoyed doing this piece. I can see doing more in my future. I'm sure that I will take what I learn and put my own slant on it.