>I have the Raffan dvd on Turning Boxes,but I need a little more clarification on how to make the joint between the top and bottom of turned box. The top needs to pop relatively tight(ly) closed, and pop from the vacuum when removing-I get neither.. ha ha. I believe Elloit send me an explantion eons ago,but my filing system,however great for filing,is not worth a hoot for retrieveal!! Maybe a picture and sketch of the pertinent cross section would be great. I've woren John Lucas out,them Tenneseans get mean if you interrupt their naps...ha ha. pw.
>Making a pop fit lid is really just sneaking up on the fit. Make the sides that overlap as parallel as possible and then sneak up on the perfect fit. I use a 6" ruler to check to see if the lip of the vessel is parallel to the lathe bed. Put the ruler on the lip and then adjust your head until you can see how the ruler aligns with the bed of the lathe. You would be surprised how accurate this is. Remove any taper from the lip so it's perfectly parallel. Now just work on the other part (whether you do lid first of base first) and do the same thing but sneak up on the fit until it is either a press fit (which I like for small boxes) or a slip fit( which I use for larger or longer boxes). I use a loose fit on boxes larger than 3".
>John Explained it well. I have not turned a box in a while, but I learned from Richard Raffin. Books, videos, and a two day demo. I turn the lid first. Do as John said and get the recess as nearly parallel to the ways as you can. Then, when you turn the box, You and get close to the right size and do a "burn" fit. Turn the spigot, slightly too large with a small cone on the open end. With the lathe running. try to install the lid, holding it gently against the spinning spigot. You will get a burned ring on the cone that tells you what the diameter is. With a really sharp tool (I used a scraper) sneak up on the cut, trying the lid over and over. My experience is that you must cut this cleanly, you can not sand it. Sanding will deform it. You might brush it with 400 but not much.
I also found that under cutting the spigot was a good idea. That is, taper it very slightly so that it is wider at the top and smaller at the shoulder. And, the spigot must be fairly long to make the "pop". Perhaps a 5/16" up to a half inch. Something like 3/8". That way there is a little build up of suction as the lid slides up the spigot.
I don't think it's just Tennessee. Maybe its the south. I'm a little peckish. I have missed my nap.
>Watch out for that sneaky part of turning boxes. I'm still learning and three of my boxes I had to put in the freezer as I could not get the top off. I have been lucky this works. Get them very cold and then used the heat of my hand to warm the lid and so far have gotten the lids off. One of these days it is not going to work. Loose fit lids are easier to make! :>)
I have to figure out what to do with the 21 boxes I have turned before I make any more. An experienced turner can sell or give as a nice gift, but trying to figure out what I can do is a puzzle?
>Thanks for explaning,but is there no round "hook" shape on either the top or bottom? I can see how one would get it on,but I'm afraid I'd be like Galen. Any one ever cut a slit in one of the components? There has to be another way besides just relying on tactil sensation,maybe a beading tool for the bottom and cove for the other?? Make us a couple of tools John... I', not dismissing the time honored way gents,but if fit is this critical,won't the moisture play havoc? Ok, I'm letting this dog go.. pw
>I'd be afraid to cut a slit. You might start something that will run down the wood. It would work. I've done that for wooden chucks. I cut 4 slits and use a band clamp of some sort to squeeze the wood to hold whatever I need.
some turners do put a slight lip on the top of the tenon part. These are called snap lid boxes. There isn't any easy way, you have sneak up on this just like the other ones. It's probably a tiny bit more forgiving. BAsically you make a very snug lid and then undercut the tenon just a little leaving a bead on the top of the lip. This is real slight so using the term bead is a little overkill.
>I made a 'pop' fit lid last year (or was it the year before?) while learning. Sneak up on it, as John suggested. I was showing to a friend on Saturday, and it still 'pops', so the moisture content hasn't been a problem so far. Good luck and keep trying.
>Hopefully (He said wistfully) the moisture issue is addressed by the fact that the box is made of a single piece of wood and twice turned. I make up box blanks, often out of cutoffs and scraps that show promise. Turn them with a chuck spigot on both ends, cut them into two pieces, and rough hollow them. (Already visualizing the design and cutting and allowing for it) Then I tape the two pieces back together and put a species and date on them and set them aside to dry. Later, (months or years) I put them back on the lathe and complete the box. The fact that they are from a single piece of wood originally SHOULD mean that they will expand and contract and warp equally and whatever fit you started with should stay about the same. I have made them so that right off the lathe the top will spin freely as if lubricated by the air in the join, latter they still fit nicely, but will no longer spin because both pieces are now very slightly oval.
Some people really like the pop fit. Its neat, shows effort and skill. Not very practicle, if you give the box a really good POP, your collection of treasures will go flying. Its really a Wood Turners Trick. Probably appreciated more by fellow turners than the public at large. A disadvantage to a suction fit is that when someone lifts the box by the lid, the body of the box will fall off just before they get their other hand under it. If it does, they will sort of sheepishly walk away and not buy anything because they are embarrassed. Not good to trick your customers. So, make little boxes with nice snug lids and bigger ones with lids that lift right off.
Keeping the blank together also allows for the grain to match. I have a box I made out of little pieces I brought back from St. Croix. The bottom is mahogany and the to is Tibbet. (Wish I had a bunch of tibbet.) The fit is a snap fit. Sometimes it really SNAPS and other times not so much. Use it every day.