Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Tool rest update

Posts

Tool rest update

#1

Tool rest update

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I just finished milling my cast iron tool rests and installing 1/4" O-1 drill rod in the grooves. I used JB Weld to glue the rod in the grooves, and it's solid as a rock. What a difference it makes!

Now I'm wondering if the O-1 was the right choice, as my hard bowl gouges seem to be able to dent the rod slightly when roughing a big vessel. Nothing like the cast iron did, but still troubling. Is there something harder than would resist denting by something the hardness of a Thompson gouge? I imagine carbide would just break.

Ellis






Re: Tool rest update

#2

Re: Tool rest update

Greg Haugen

>Ellis, nice work on the rest. It looks great. That's an interesting situation with the rod denting. I wonder what the rod is on the comfort rests. I have Thompson tools and M4 (one is a 2030 and one is M4) steel skews. There's no denting on the Comfort Rests.

No matter what, nice work on that rest. Well Done.

Greg H.

Re: Tool rest update

#3

Re: Tool rest update

robo hippy

>Ellis,

I had thought that the drill rod you buy still has to be heat treated for final hardness and tempering.

robo hippy

Re: Tool rest update

#4

I should know that...

Ellis Walentine, Host

>... but I don't. Sounds plausible. Maybe I ought to melt the epoxy, heat treat the rods and reinstall.

Ellis

Re: Tool rest update

#5

Re: I should know that...

JohnKyler

>I agree that is likely the solution. The stuff I bought for a three point came so you can work it and then temper after.

Re: Tool rest update

#6

Re: I should know that...

john lucas

>Drill rod does come soft and can be hardened. I don't know if I would want it any harder than the tools I'm using but I haven't tried it so I don't really know. You would need a pretty good oven to heat a rod of that length to the proper temperature and then a pretty good size vessel to quench it as well.

I know you can buy already hardened rod from places like Enco and MSC. I haven't looked into it but did glance over them the last time I was ordering. That might be an easy option. I've been thinking about adding it to my big powermatic tool rest.

Re: Tool rest update

#7

Thought of using Thomson Shafting?

Al Crandall

>Check out www.McMaster.com and search page 1056. 12" piece of .250 case hardened shaft is only $4.78 and they have a huge selection of diameters and lengths in small increments. I'd never mess with hardening and then tempering drill rod when I can by this stuff so cheap. Long lengths of small diameter rods present a challenge to the novice heat treater because they want to warp badly if not done corectly.

Re: Tool rest update

#8

Re: Tool rest update

Terry Quiram

>Ellis

Why not try your set up first and see if you dent the rod. You can always change it later. No sense making work if you don't need to.

Re: Tool rest update

#9

Re: Tool rest update

Ellis Walentine, Host

>I turned one good-sized chunk of spalted hard maple with the new rest, using a Glaser 3/4" V-15 bowl gouge and a Thompson 5/8" bowl gouge, and there are definitely some small dents in the drill rod already. Not near as deep as they would have been in the cast iron, based on the same amount of pounding. I'm just going to live with it the way it is for a while and see how it holds up. The whole point is to have as smooth a surface as possible to run tools over. Tiny dents aren't going to make much of a difference.

Ellis

Re: Tool rest update

#10

Everything has to be somewhere????

Barry Irby

>If you make the rest/rod really hard and it won't dent, won't the dents show up in the tool? Which is better, a few slight dents in the rest or dents in the underside of your gouge?

Re: Tool rest update

#11

Re: Everything has to be somewhere????

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Now here's a fellow who understands Newton!