Marblewood
Paul Zerjay
>Marblewood and Walnut match each other nicely, but the walnut is not my first choice for detailed finials or pedestals. 10-1/2" tall and a little over 5-1/2" diameter (I know I still have the headlight syndrome)
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Marblewood
Paul Zerjay
>Marblewood and Walnut match each other nicely, but the walnut is not my first choice for detailed finials or pedestals. 10-1/2" tall and a little over 5-1/2" diameter (I know I still have the headlight syndrome)
Re: Marblewood
matt overton
>nice form. I like the crispness of the finial and stem.
very nice piece
robert davis
>
Re: Marblewood
charlie belden
>Taken individually, the three elements of this piece are quite nice and well done. It's the transitions - straight line to curve, curve to straight line - which keep the three elements from becoming a coherent, more pleasing, whole.
With a simple tenon on the top of the base and the bottom of the finial, it's difficult to "blend" them with the central element which is curved since you'll end up with delicate "knife edges".
BUT - if the holes for the tenons are "stepped", you've got some meat below the finished curved transition - and no knife edge.
I hope you don't mind, but I've used your piece to illustrate what I'm trying to describe and tweeked your picture to show the results.
While this will make the turning process a bit trickier, the result may be worth the effort.
Good job explaining what I was thinkign :-)
steve antonucci
>I too had some issues with those transitions, but couldn't figure out how to say it. I agree with Charlie 100%
S
Re: Marblewood
Paul Zerjay
>Wow Charlie, I DO like that much better!! Thanks for the tip...
Re: Marblewood
Donna Banfield
>Charlie, thank you for that comparison diagram on the photo.
I'm sure it will help a whole bunch of us who may have trouble visualizing the written description of how a piece can be improved by making a couple of changes in a transition. Not that Paul's piece was bad - I've never been able to turn finials that crisp - but the slight modifications in the transitions of the finials show how to take a pretty good turning into a pretty spectacular one.
Transitions - Tangents
charlie belden
>Transitions between elements is often what distinguishes a really nice piece from a pretty good piece. If you can get curves to intersect at their tangent points the eye will see a smooth continuous curves profile. A transition that is not tangential get's picked up by the eye and noted as incongruous - and unless it's done for an obvious reason - "not quite right" - even if you can't say why.
It's easy to miss a not quite right transition while you're turning it since you have a tendency to watch where the tool is cutting instead of the "backside" of the profile where the results are more easily seen - and noted - since the tool isn't in the way.
When I get close I put down the cutting tool and pick up the cutting paper - yes, sand paper. Some smoothing of a transition that's not quite right requires 120 grit and some only 320 or 400 grit - at least for me.
Another source of missing a transition problem is that you're seeing the piece on its side while turning. If you take it off the lathe, still in the chuck, and stand it upright, things you might miss while turning become a bit more obvious when upright, especially if you can get a contrasting background behind the piece (white if the wood's dark, dark if the piece is light).
Getting the right combination of curves and great proportions - well that's the tricky part. Getting the curves to blend - that's a bit easier.
Re: Transitions - Tangents
Keith Tompkins
>Nice work, Paul! Charlie, I agree with your assessment of transitional points; something I talk about in my classes.