Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Steel

Posts

Steel

#1

Steel

mfoster

>I sat in on a couple of Rolly Munroe's talks at totally turning. He's an interesting guy and a real innovator and do-it your-selfer. I can relate to that. I have to admit that I am a real novice when it comes to working with metals, but he got me wanting to give a go at making some of my own carving burs. He suggested using 1040-1045 steel, or perhaps 4140, then heat treating the result. I looked at MSC and they do sell 1045 rods in the diameter I want, but they are 6' long. More than I really need, but not expensive except I think shipping may be steep for the price of the steel. Is cold rolled steel that you get at the hardware store the same as 1045??

Re: Steel

#2

Steven Antonucci

look at Enco

steve antonucci

>Their shipping is very reasonable. I don't think cold rolled is good for anything with an edge. Enco also sells O1, which is used as drill rod. That's what I use.

S

Re: Steel

#3

Re: Steel

john lucas

>Buy Drill rod. You can get it from MSC, ENCO, Travers and others. It makes good tools, comes in 3 foot lengths and is pretty inexpensive.

Re: Steel

#4

Re: Steel

MFoster

>Thanks John and Steve. Looking at both ENCO and MSC I came up with reasonably sized (length) blanks in 4041 and drill rod and they're on the way. Now to play with them to come up with a working tool should be fun. I haven't decided whether to quench in oil, or water when hardening it. May play it safe and just use water.

Mike

Re: Steel

#5

Steven Antonucci

I use Mineral oil

steve antonucci

>mainly because I use it to finish bowls and have it. If you use it, put it in a metal tin, and dedicate that tin to your quench bin. There will be scale in it after a while, so I wouldn't use it for anything afterwards.

Also, if you have a small bit of rod in a lot of oil, no worries about a fire. Barely makes the oil warm. If you have a large hunk of glowing steel and a small bucket of oil, that is the fire hazard.

Steve

Re: Steel

#6

Re: Steel

john lucas

>When you order the steel you order water hardening or oil hardening. Use the appropriate one. I use peanut oil when oil hardening. It supposedly has a lower flash point but I use it because I don't have to worry about disposal and I can buy it at the grocery store.

If I'm using a metal I know nothing about I quench in oil. That's usually a safe guess.

Re: Steel

#7

Re: Steel

Dave Noon

>CRS from the hardware store is likely 1018/1020. The last two digits refer to the amount of carbon in the steel e.g. 1045 has 0.45% carbon.

You can harden it but it's somewhat limited, you might get 28 Rockwell C but it would be brittle.

4140 is an alloy steel, includes chromium & molybdenum with 0.40% carbon, and will oil harden up to low 50s Rc. It is strong but if too hard becomes brittle. It is used a lot for shafts.

For tools/cutting edges O1 will work much better. It is an oil hardening tool steel, that's what the "O" means. It will get up to high 50s Rc and wear much better.

HTH

Dave

Re: Steel

#8

Re: Steel

john lucas

>Dave I would have to look at my notes if I can still find them but I think the Drill rod I buy can be hardened above 62R. I temper it back to between 58 and 62 according to the specs. I don't know if I still have the instructions that came with it but I will look.

Re: Steel

#9

Re: Steel *LINK*

Dave Noon

>You're absolutely right John, it will go above 60Rc but that's more for thinner stock. For the stock for gouges I wouldn't go above 58Rc.

Here's a link to O1 information.

Dave


AISI O1

Re: Steel

#10

what just flew over my head?

mfoster

>You guys are way out of my comfort zone. I'm going to try some basic tempering and see how it goes. With the tools I'm after (die grinder bits for wood carving), just hard (using the file test Rolly talked about) will be good enough for me.

Re: Steel

#11

Lots of good books

nick

>There are lots of good, non-technical books about making tools in your home shop. One of my favorites and the one that got me started making tools is The Complete Modern Blacksmith or something similar by Alexander Weygers. You can find it at an online bookseller. Also, there is a very good book on making woodworking tools by Ray Larson. My woodshop has a small forge in it- very handy.

Re: Steel

#12

Re: what just flew over my head?

john lucas

>For most tools I don't actually worry about the true hardness. I will be glad to send you my heat treating article for making simple turning tools. Just send an e-mail to the above address and tell me what you want. Most of the time if it's a metal that is not hardened I simply grind it to shape,then heat it cherry red or to the point it's non magnetic and then quench it in the proper medium. Now it's too hard so I take it into the house and put in in the oven at 425 degrees for 1/2 hour. That's it. The oven knocks the hardness back down to a tolerable level for wood tools.

I looked up all the proper hardening procedures because I wanted to have some idea of what I was trying to do.

Re: Steel

#13

2 excellent books, I have them both

john lucas

>

Re: Steel

#14

Re: John, it's even simpler than that....

Russ Fairfield

>Heat the tool until it is red hot on the grinding wheel, and immediately quench it in water. It now is hard on the edge with a softer steel behind it. Take off the burr in the flute with a slip stone. Then take it back to the grinding wheel, and make a light pass across the edge to clean it up. I usually make this last cut after turning off the grinder and while it is spinning down - a poor man's variable speed grinder.

Re: Steel

#15

Re: Steel

Russ Fairfield

>The cold rolled hardware store steel doesn't have enough carbon in it to do much hardening. It is the same as all-thread and cheal bolts and screws.

Plain old 30W motor oil works fine for quenching O1 steel. I buy the cheapest generic brand I can find.

Re: Steel

#16

Steven Antonucci

Simple hardening procedure

steve antonucci

>I think if I were a toolmaker and I needed to do these things optimally and repeatable, I'd worry about the recipe. I just heat the steel with a MAPP torch (as high as I can go, which is yellow/orange, and then drop it in mineral oil. Period.

Whether it RC 58 or 62 doesn't matter. Both are sufficient to hold an edge. Since the entire shaft isn't hardened, usually only the outer surface is hard. In a small diameter, you'll never anneal it properly, so you might as well not even try. A torch and an oven are nowhere near accurate enough to do it properly, so do it well enough and quickly. 90% of what you need is in the torch and the oil...

steve

Re: Steel

#17

Re: Simple hardening procedure

john lucas

>Steve I disagree about not being able to do it accurately. Now of course you can't do it as accurate as a serious heat treating oven but for our purposes it works well. I checked my oven with Temple sticks. These are plastic sticks that melt at very specific temperatures. It was within 2 degrees of accurate and according to my charts that's easy enough to get you close to Rockwell hardness you want.

If the tool is too hard the burr doesn't last if you use it as a scraper. The same is true for any tool that needs a fine edge.

I will agree that if you don't harden it properly you will probably not reach the hardness it is capable of. For example you need the steel needs to be heated to the red hot temperature for a certain period of time per thickness to achieve the proper hardness. If you don't heat it long enough you have hardened it some but not all the way or evenly through out. consequently you could get the edge you are happy with by pure luck. There is quite a bit of leeway.

I stopped trying to do it to the "N"th degree because most of the tools I make only need to hold a decent edge. Consequently I now just more or less follow the procedures without taking careful track of all the times. Blacksmith's have done it this way using just color for years and get a decent tool.

When I want to make a good tool I use known tool steel that I can look up the specs on and follow the charts to get everything as close as I can.

Re: Steel

#18

Steven Antonucci

I think we're in violent agreement-

steve antonucci

>My point was only that the heating and quenching will produce a more than acceptable result. The annealing is optional, since I'm only making 1/4" shanked tools anyway (how much can you anneal an 1/8" of steel anyway?)

As far as the "n-th degree" goes, I don't see any way to accurately control the heating part using a torch, so I can't imagine that using a controlled environment to anneal can make all of that great of a difference. Assuming that introduces some error in the Rockwell scale, I have stuck to the time honored tradition of testing it with a file. Whether I get 58-62, both hold an edge and cut wood.

My response was to let Mike know that while you can take it to the Nth degree, heat and quench will work just fine (in small diameters).

S

Re: Steel

#19

I dunno, Steve

Ellis Walentine, Host

>... and I mean that. I'm no expert, but I remember being told early and often that hardened tools are susceptible to fracturing, or at least having their edges chip because of being too brittle. If that's true, I'd probably be even more concerned about thin or narrow tools, as they could snap off completely if you were unlucky.

I've always tempered tools by judiciously passing them over a low torch flame about an inch or so behind the edge and quenching them when the shiny metal at the edge turns to a straw yellow color. I'm not sure you need to be any more careful about temperature than that, unless there is some critical requirement for hardness.

So, what's the scoop? Is it okay to make tools from old files without annealing them? I dunno.

Ellis

Re: Steel

#20

Re: I dunno, Steve

john lucas

>Ellis I would have to look because I don't remember exactly but straw color is around 400- 425 dgrees. In the oven you can just heat to that temperature and let it cool by itself. To do it the blacksmith way you heat an area behind the tip and watch the straw color creep toward the tip, then quench it when it gets there.

The file questions is still up in the air but not a good idea for most people. Throw them in the oven at 425 degrees for about an hour and the brittleness is gone but some say they are still weak at the point the teeth are stamped. I've made a lot of tools from old files but usually not turning tools. Turning tools take a lot of force and can break even good tools if handled improperly. I make carving tools, cutting tips for turning tools and made one of my thread chasing tools from one. I use them mostly because I've got them. I bought a box of old files for $1 and actually use some as files. The worn out ones are in the scrap bin to be used for other things. You are much better off to simply buy tool steel. It isn't that expensive and you know exactly what you get and how to heat treat it properly.

Re: Steel

#21

Re: I dunno, Steve

Russ Fairfield

>Ellis, my opinion is that you should never use old files for anything other than what they are - oil files. Old files can be dangerous any time a bending force is applied to them. They are an accident waiting to happen. You can anneal them to make them softer, but you cannot remove every one of those little stress concentrations that are made by all of those grooves, and just waiting to fracture when you are least expecting it.

Re: Steel

#22

Steven Antonucci

I'd never use an old file (again :-)

steve antonucci

>I did once when I was learning and had the MOAC (mother of all catches), which completely snapped the file and the toolrest on my Crapsman monotoube lathe and force me to go change my shorts...

There is no way to remove all of the hairline fractures in a file and make them useful as turning tools. When my file broke, it exactly followed the mill groove and thankfully went in some other direction. Having bark fly off and hit me is one thing. Having a sharpened bit of file do the same is something very, very different.

Like anything, a certain amount of smarts needs to be applied. The tools I make are used for hollowing interiors, and if they break (which hasn't happened yet), they are captured inside the vessel. No harm, no foul.

I have broken many hooks trying to cold set them. Safe to say that they are brittle enough that they cannot be cold set, but have never fractured from turning related maladies...

Steve