Eccentric Chuck
Don wilcut
>I'm interested in branching out into new turning methods.I'm looking at a Sorby 1-1/4'' x 8 Eccentric Chuck. Help me with the decision making process of what kind of chuck to buy.
Don
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Eccentric Chuck
Don wilcut
>I'm interested in branching out into new turning methods.I'm looking at a Sorby 1-1/4'' x 8 Eccentric Chuck. Help me with the decision making process of what kind of chuck to buy.
Don
Re: Eccentric Chuck
Greg Haugen
>Don,
There are basically two types of eccentric chucks, off centering (Sorby's chuck and the Deluxe #3 Escoulen are this way)-where the piece stays parallel to the bed of the lathe and the other is Ball and Socket (the only one still available is the original Escoulen)-where the piece pivots on the ball socket from a center point. These are two different principles. There is a new Escoulen chuck that Vicmarc has made that with an additional accessory it utilizes both methods.
The pieces that Escoulen is famous for are mostly from the original "ball and socket" chuck. It is a little limited (more spindle work) to "Cup" size for the tenon unless you have the faceplate attachment. The Sorby and the #3 Escoulen can handle larger work like platters, etc.
Woodworker's Emporium carries the two Escoulen chucks and there's a few places that carry the Sorby chucks.
Depends on what you want to do and the price you'd like to pay for the chuck.
I know it's not much help..
Greg H.
Re: Eccentric Chuck
Donna Banfield
>Don, one thing that may limit the chuck availability for you is the type of lathe you have. I know that the Escoulen chuck only comes in a couple of spindle sizes, one of them being the M33. I don't recall the other size, but it would fit the spindle of a full-size lathe. I don't know about the Sorby.
Escoulen did that intentionally so that the chucks could only be used on larger lathes, for safety reasons. He didn't want someone to try turning with his chuck on a mini-lathe.
I have the Escoulen, and use it on a Oneway. A piece of wood that is 4-6 inches proud of the spindle, but swinging off-center can generate a tremendous amount of vibration.
Re: Eccentric Chuck
Don wilcut
>Thanks Donna, I have a 300 VicMarc and can turn up to 24" I know the dangers and limititations of turning off center like that and knowing that the person that could get hurt is ME, I'm always extra careful.
Don
Re: Eccentric Chuck *LINK*
Gordon Seto
>There are many choices in eccentric chucks.
The major draw back of the Sorby is it has to use tail stock when turning off-axis. You can't turn delicate spindle with it, hollow a box that is not parallel to main axis. Sorby has a new Wobble Chuck in their web site. It was said to be introduced in January; but I haven't got any response from them for more information.
The first two Escoulen chucks (original & deluxe models) also have limitations on what they can do. There are functions that the original can and the Deluxe can't, vice versa. The 3rd generation of Escoulen has counter weights. I have seen the early version of the #3 demonstrated by Jean Francois Escoulen. The latest version looks very promising. It may have the potential to replace the first two.
Axminster has the advantage of repeatability, but has great limitation on functions.
Sorby Wobble Chuck
Re: Eccentric Chuck
Don wilcut
>Thanks Greg, Appreciate the information.
Don
Re: Eccentric Chuck
Don wilcut
>Thanks Gordon. I knew I could get some great information from the Woodcentral crowd. Lots to digest and mull over. Will let you know what I decide.
Don
Re: Eccentric Chuck
Gordon Seto
>The Sorby can do both off-center and off-axis; but must use tail stock when turning off-axis.
The Escoulen Deluxe (#2)can do both, but not well in either. It is a more massive chuck than the original. The center screw doesn't hold the end grain of a spindle well. You can also say the same thing about the Sorby.
The early #3 can't do off-axis, but I believe the latest version manufactured by Vicmarc may have solved the problem. I have not used this one.
Re: Eccentric Chuck *LINK*
Fred Holder
>Hello Don,
The first eccentric chuck to turn up on the market was the Robert Sorby Eccentric Chuck, I've had that one for over ten years and found it worked great within its capability.
The Escoulen Ball and Socket chuck followed some time later and brought a different motion to the offset work. The work piece is offset at an angle and provides a different motion than you can get with the Robert Sorby Eccentric chuck.
Somewhere in there Axminister came out with their eccentric chuck, which has two plates that pivot on one screw and has several off center points that one can put the other screw into. This chuck does allow you to return to a previous offset point precisely. It is limited in its amount of offset to specific points.
A few years ago, Escoulen came out with another chuck that uses the movement of the Robert Sorby chuck on the front side and the ball and socket on the back side. This chuck gives more flexibility than I have imagination to fully use.
Vermec in Australia came out with an eccentric drive center that allows one to offset pieces between centers and does a nice job if one is only interested in three sided objects. My wife, Mildred, recently did a three sided box using this device. A photo of her work is attached.
The newest eccentric chuck is being manufactured by Vicmarc and distributed by a firm in Italy. They hope to have United States distributors by June. I was going to order one directly from them, but the shipping cost and money transfer costs made it way too expensive at this time.
You can, however, do considerably multi-center turning in the spindle mode by offsetting the workpiece between the drive center and the tailcenter. I recommend the StebCenter for both drive and tailcenter when doing this. Petter Herod (sp) of Norway does a lot of this with his little multi-sided boxes and spiralled boxes.
I own all but the last of these chucks, but am simply limited in imagination to fully use any of their capabilities. Good luck.
More Woodturning Website
Re: Eccentric Chuck
Dick Coers
>Here's a couple of links to possibly make your decision tougher.
http://www.token.crwoodturner.com/ecc/
http://www.davidreedsmith.com/Articles/TwoJawChuck/TwoJawChuck.htm
Re: Eccentric Chuck *LINK*
charlie belden
>You can dabble in multi-center and eccentric turning without a special chuck. The size of the blank is limited, but you can start getting a feel for what's involved - on smaller stuff. Dedicated special chucks provide more ease of use - and better holding power - of course - for a chunk of change.
You can do multi centers between centers
by just changing the ends centers on the drive end as well as the tailstock end, or hold one fixed and change the other, or use just two opposing jaws of a regular four jaw chuck.
You can also do some of what you can do with a ball chuck by merely turning the ball on the drive end of your blank and mounting it in a normal four jaw chuck.
Being able to predict outcomes when turning off center and eccecntric requires a little mental gymnastics. Some of the illustrations on the attached page, and subsequent pages may help.
Multi-Centers and Ball In Chuck Methods
Re: Eccentric Chuck
Don wilcut
>Thanks Charlie. I've tried some of these before and now that you reminded of the process, you may have saved me +-$300. Thanks again
and there's at least one other chuck *LINK*
bob elliott
>ggggg
shape shifter tools
Re: and there's at least one other chuck *LINK*
bob elliott
>This chuck was introduced to a few of our members at a recent club function. His website does not provide all the details but here is what I learned. It requires the purchase of a threaded spindle adapter from Nova. That adapter is screwed into the back side of this chuck so the body can be screwed onto your lathe spindle.
The large threaded section is 1" x 8 tpi and will allow you to screw on a faceplate or regular 4 jaw chuck.
I personally have not used this chuck. Some members have bought it for the ability to turn multi-sided pens.
(sorry for the previous post, I hit the "post button" instead of the "preview button"...)
ShapeShifter Tools
I have several
Fog Tanner
>I have several eccentric chucks that I use. I have the Escoulen #1 and #2, the Vicmarc Escoulen, and the Kelton Angle Faceplate. I use the #2 and the Vicmarc Escoulen the most. For smaller pieces I still use the #1. For the really large pieces I use the Kelton, leaving the mid range to the other two chucks.
The Vicmarc Escoulen will do everything that the Escoulen #1 will do, plus things it cannot do. I can angle a piece the same as the #1, but then move it offcenter and rotate it at different points. It will use the same balls and faceplate as the #1. I like the ability of rotating the piece by loosening three set screws and rotating it a mark or two.
The offcenter mechanism has a 1 1/4" range from center, would be nice to have twice that - but I can live with it. There are three counter weights to help adjusting the off balance. But, I have the Vicmarc balancing system which I use most of the time. The quality of the chuck is first rate and it appears to be nickle plated which is a plus. There are a number of adapters available, which you can find on the Vicmarc site. I have the ball socket adapter, the faceplate adapter, along with a couple of faceplates.
With that said, I also use the #2 quite a bit as it is better suited for some work than the Vicmarc Escoulen. I currently have a 9" bowl mounted on a glue block which has rebates for both the #2 faceplate and the ball mounted faceplate in the Vic/Escoulen. I have turned some of the axis on the Vic/Escoulen and some on the #2, there are currently 19 different axis so far with a couple left to go.
It all depends on what you what to do as to which one would be the best fit. If your scale is small to medium, then the Vic/Escoulen will do anything you want. If all your work is mid range size and you have no desire for the small items, the #2 would probably keep you busy for a couple of years. Be prepared to spend some layout time with each piece, I spent 8 hours the other day laying out different axis points and settings on my #2 Escoulen. Then when I satated turning, I decided I didn't like what the result would be and spent part of that day finding new axis points. I did take notes of the first one and will think about another time - just didn't fit what I was looking for this time.
Good luck in your journey,
Fog
Vicmarc Escoulen
Fog Tanner
>This is the Vicmarc Escoulen with a piece mounted on the ball faceplate. It is 1 1/4" offcenter at some angle, relative to the axis, and a rotation setting relative to zero. There a number of settings for each axis turned, this was number 14.
The rear of the glue block has two different sized rebates for the different faceplates. Also markings to help relocate back to the original setting on the other chuck. I also rotated the piece 60 degrees for an additional change on the other chuck.
Fog
Escoulen #2
Fog Tanner
>This is the same piece remounted on the Escoulen #2. This is offset the maximum about, both with the faceplate and the angle on the ball. At this point I have 3 or 4 more axis to turn. This is on the face side, I am still thinking if I want another 5 on the bottom. That will require another chucking mechanism and another days worth of work.
This extreme settings also require a balancing system if you want to turn above 400-500 rpm. I have the Vic system on the lathe and did shoot some more pics trying to show the image blurring. I got to 2000 and could not get any blurring. I do occasionally turn that high on various pieces, but this one is being turned down around 900-1300 - depending. Without the balancing system 500 is pretty much the max for this piece due to the large amount of steel off center.
Fog
Fog
Re: Escoulen #2
Don wilcut
>Thanks, Fog and Bob for your responces. The jury is still out on the purchase.