Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Walnut box

Posts

Walnut box

#1

Keith Tompkins

Walnut box

Keith Tompkins

>This is a small box, turned from a walnut crotch. I chose a pear-shape for the piece; the large base gives stability, the curve at the base gives it some lift. The bead is part of the box for added stability; I wanted the form to flow right through the bead and into the lid. The form looks good with the lid removed because of the bead. The grain lines up all the way around, and the lid lifts off with a nice suction fit. The finish is a traditional french polish, using shellac, alcohol, and oil. I turned this during a box-making class I gave, I plan to base future work on this shape. Comments welcome.


img

Re: Walnut box

#2

Re: Walnut box

John K Jordan

>Keith,

I like that form a lot. Do you have a picture of the inside?

JKJ

Re: Walnut box

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Walnut box

Keith Tompkins

>Hi John, Thanks! I don't have a picture of the inside, but I can assure you, it's finished to the same standard as the outside.

Re: Walnut box

#4

Re: Walnut box

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>Keith,

I think it is an excellent box. The form is very good. For my taste the bottom is a little fat relative to the height. If the diameter is 2 3/4, I might go with 2 5/8 or even 2 9/16. Just my two cents.

Ed

Re: Walnut box

#5

Re: Walnut box

arkie

>A beautiful piece of wood, and superb execution of the form - as nicely done as I have ever seen. That ring could be a separate piece, the line is so continuous from box to lid.

The only opportunity I see for improvement is the finial. Did you consider a shorter finial, or one without the point, to more nearly match the shape of tthe overall box?

Re: Walnut box

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: Walnut box

Brad Vietje

>Beautiful box, Keith. I hope you can bring it to the New England Turning Symposium in May so I can see it in person!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Walnut box

#7

Was the final turned with the lid or added on?

Adrien

>

Re: Walnut box

#8

Re: Walnut box

GaryG in MD

>That's very nice Keith. I'd like to see it with the top off to go with your comment about the shape of the bottom alone. You did justice to that piece of wood. ...Gary

Re: Walnut box

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Walnut box

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Arkie, thanks for the kind words. It's not always easy to get just the right combination of proportions. The idea was to continue the flow of the box all the way to the tip of the finial (knob). The base of the finial mimics the base of the box; but it did occur to me that a rounded shape may be a better choice. Once I begin to turn a piece, I don't change the design; instead, I'll make a new piece incorporating changes inspired by the first piece. That way, I always have new ideas to try, and I can see the progression of ideas.

Re: Walnut box

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Was the final turned with the lid or added on?

Keith Tompkins

>HI Adrien, The finial is part of the lid, not added on. Thanks

Re: Walnut box

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Walnut box

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Brad, Ummm, er, well, it's gone. I have only a few days to finish my next piece before TT, otherwise, I'm coming emptyhanded. See you there!

Re: Walnut box

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Walnut box

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Gary. Thanks,I just went through my photos...no top-off image. This piece went out to the gallery last week, perhaps they'll take a photo there and post it to their site.

Re: Walnut box

#13

Re: Walnut box

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Beautiful!!

Love it,

take care,

Jim

Re: Walnut box

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Walnut box

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Ed. Thanks. I'll make a few versions of this form to see which proportions I like the best. Then, after I'm happy with the shape, I'll cut, grind, carve, and burn the final version. :)

Re: Walnut box

#15

Very nice, thanks for sharing the picture.

Gil Jones...Georgia...

>

Re: Walnut box

#16

Really Lovely !

Don Orr

>

Re: Walnut box

#17

Mike Stafford

Re: Walnut box

Mike Stafford

>Nice box, Keith. Beautiful finish!

My suggestion would be to raise the maximum diameter a little higher in the piece, say about to the point where it is about 1/3 the height from the bottom and make the bottom a little rounder so the box does not appear to be sitting so heavily on the table.

Re: Walnut box

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Walnut box

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks, everyone. Mike, There always seems to be a compromise...if I raise the point of maximum diameter, I lose the reverse curve between the largest diameter and the bead. The best I could do would be a straight line, or a severe change in direction in order to meet the bead. Either would change the shape too much for my taste. If you look closely at the shadow line, the piece is sitting on a very small part of the base. I'm not all that happy with the finial/knob, it needs some tweaking.

Re: Walnut box

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: Walnut box

Keith Tompkins

>Mike , This is a poor photo, but shows the profile better. The first shot was angled down, so the base doesn't show as well.


img

Re: Walnut box

#20

Re: Walnut box

Frank C. Joseph

>very nice, that will be a very interesting line to see develop

Re: Walnut box

#21

Mike Stafford

Re: Walnut box

Mike Stafford

>This is a much better photo for the profile. It shows the details so much better. I would not have guessed that the box was shaped like that from your first photo.

It looks great just as it is. I stand corrected...not outstanding in a field like someone we know and love...

Re: Walnut box

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re: Walnut box

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Mike, thanks. I already knew what the shape was, and didn't think about the angle of the first shot distorting the view of the base. Something to keep in mind in the future. I like your newest box as well... good stuff! I didn't understand your last statement (?)

Re: Walnut box

#23

Mike Stafford

Mr. Grumbine, of course....

Mike Stafford

>

Re: Walnut box

#24

Keith Tompkins

Re: Walnut box

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Frqnk, I don't believe we've met. Welcome aboard! I'll post images of where this idea is going..

Re: Walnut box

#25

Re: Walnut box

John K Jordan

>The side profile confirms my first impression - I still like that form a lot. Somehow I was able to visualize the shape from the first picture but the second shows it better. The dome lid with the gentle outward sloping rim that flows nicely into the bottom vaguely reminds me of a shape I saw in a book from perhaps a century ago. I made a little walnut box whose base is very close to the shape of yours (bead and all!) although a bit shorter, but after seeing yours I realized immediately that I blew it on the top (mine was too top heavy).

Does the top fit loosely? My last few boxes have loose fitting inset lids that lift with no effort. I'm starting to like that better than the more common suction fit.

I'm still curious about the inside. I assume the lid is domed inside. Is the bottom hollowed to follow the pear shape, or did you leave the wall thicker near the bottom? I've left some thicker and I really liked the feel and balance from the extra mass near the base.

JKJ