Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

Posts

I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#1

JL

I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

JL

>I mean, I do the occasional set of candlesticks. I'm exploring turning spirals.

But the vast majority of what I do is spindle turning. I guess according to the likes of the "artistic" turners, I'm not really a turner. I turn legs, stretchers, arm posts, stiles. I make furniture. Most of the furniture that I make takes weeks to complete. It takes me a month or more to do a set of chairs.

But you know, I like making furniture. It will be around for a while. It will be knocked around, sat it, get shoe scuffs and generally get torn up. It is life. Maybe being in a rut ain't so bad.


img

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#2

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

Jim B

>If it spins, your a turner. Whats wrong with furniture? If you sat on my peppermill, what use would it be?

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#3

Rob Wallace

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

Rob Wallace

>JL...

FWIW I think there is a greater technical challenge to turning spindles than there is turning 'artform' bowls and vessels.

I do my share of turning replacement balusters and chair parts, and I can tell you that making spindles for me is WORK, having to match the existing turnings to the point where differences, if any, are invisible when installed. The mark of a great spindle is that it is NOT unique, but the same as the others it "lives" with. In contrast, the majority of bowls an vessels are unique and free-form, and if the dimensions or curves are off a bit, who cares? Off from what? IMHO, it's far easier to turn bowls and vessels than it is to turn well-done spindles. Even though your "rut" may seem like an unfavorable condition, I can tell you that for many turners (and you ARE a turner), doing spindles well is a significant technical skill, in some ways surpassing "expert" bowl turners.

I think everyone thinks they experience 'ruts' from time to time (...and the deer population relies on this!), but find satisfaction in the fact that there are turners who would want to have your skills in spindle turning!

Rob Wallace

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#4

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

John Jordan

>Nothing wrong with making chairs, or turning any kind of spindle. Only you know what you really want to do.

But, any *real* artistic turner would never be critical, but would rather enjoy, your turning. (If it's well done) This thing about "artistic" turners is largely other people saying what they suppose we must think. Don't believe it. A real chairmaker wouldn't approve of that Unisaw, but I'll bet you don't let that bother you. Nor should you.LOL

Let's see a picture of your parts made into something. :)

John

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#5

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

Bob Rogne

>JL

Give me a piece of wood to turn into some sort of container (bowl, box). I'm in love. Just turned 3 spindles for a customer, never again.

Bob R. WestMac Turnings Still in Mesa

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#6

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut... *LINK*

Fred Holder

>I see nothing wrong with turning spindles for any purpose. I too must be stuck in a rut. In the last 10 years, I turned over 200 Chinese Balls and just finished one of the nicest ones yet today. It is hanging to dry after being dipped in Walnut Oil. I've turned them from most types of wood, from Alternative Ivory, from PVC, from cast acrylic and still enjoy turning them. I've added a picture showing some of my Chinese Balls that are still residing at my home.


img

More Woodturning Website

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#7

nothing wrong with spindle turning

john lucas

>and chairs in general have a long tradition of excellence.

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

Keith Tompkins

>Hi JL,

I really don't think you are in a rut. I'll bet you really don't think you're in a rut either. Frankly, you are creating the things that interest you...otherwise, you wouldn't be spending the time turning all those components. If my guess is correct, you are doing exactly the thing you WANT to be doing. If you aren't interested in turning art pieces, then why should you?

I'll also make a guess that more art turners than you may expect actually respect the type of work you do. After all, how many turners can build a Windsor chair, let alone even attempt it? How many chair makers have improved over the original designs?

Personally, I have a great deal of respect for anyone who can turn out a high-quality traditional piece. I've put together more than a few myself. I think it's important to keep in mind that at one time, the Windsor-style chair was viewed as revolutionary; how could a chair that weighed just over seven pounds support a 300 pound man, and last for several decades? A pretty good piece of engineering! I wonder how many craftsmen of the period gasped in dismay as the chair's maker gave it several coats of milk paint, obscuring the wood's natural beauty? Yet today, it's the accepted, traditional method. If someone didn' try something new, we would all be building and sitting in those dark, clunky, gothic behemoths that the Windsor replaced.

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#9

Amen John!

Molly Winton

>I agree whole heartedly with John. A *real* artist wouldn't turn up his/her nose at your chairs or spindle work. A *real* artist would appreciate the artistry and recognize the skill applied. I would love to see one of your completed projects JL. Do share.

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#10

Brian McKearney

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

Brian McKearney

>I know what you mean. Quite some time ago (12+ months) I decided to tackle the main stairway in our home - I built my own raised panel system and covered the walls. It was a much larger endeavor than I had ever imagined, but I installed the last panel just a few weeks ago. Still have a bit of trim left, and then I plan to install hardwood stair treads. Between that and work, my lathe even been powered on for quite a few months. Kinda missing it and hoping to get this project completed once and for all very soon (if work allows me to get to it) and maybe then I can get back to turning!

Nothing wrong with those projects that take a long time - they're often more challenging and require far more patience. And besides, the family loves furniture and it sure beats buying commercially made furniture if you can make it yourself!

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#11

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>Have you ever seen that Raffan video on spindle turning, where at the beginning he quickly turns a six inch bowl, and then sort of pokes fun at how easy that is compared to fancy spindle turning?

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#12

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

charlie belden

>I wasn't putting down spindle turning, or bowl turning or any other type of turning - but merely trying to encourage trying something new - outside the Comfort Zone. Could be turning something familiar - with a different tool or technique - or something you've been thinking about trying - but just haven't tried - yet.

Still not sure how "art" got into this thread

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#13

Lyle Jamieson

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

Lyle Jamieson

>Most people that know me would not believe I just turned 100 hollow Christmas orniments a few months ago. Its not my favorite thing but I learned a lot.

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#14

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

John Jordan

>Because he said that "artistic" turners wouldn't consider what he did turning. I don't believe that's true, that's all.

If anyone is particularly good at what they do, you can bet they've done a lot of it, regardless of what it is.

John

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

Keith Tompkins

>I agree John. It's not true at all. I spent much of my adult life as a furniture maker. When I began to focus on turning, I was already skilled in many areas of woodworking, including carving and finishing. The reason I began to focus on the lathe was because that was my WEAK area, and I wanted to bring my skills up to speed. I was a decent turner, I wanted to get better. Looking through the books at Barnes and Noble one evening, I spotted book written by Ray Leier, Jan Peters, and Kevin Wallace. BANG! One look inside that book changed the course of my woodworking career. In the back was information for the AAW, which I had never heard of. I joined immediately; I haven't built a piece of furniture since. And, I set a goal for myself that someday my work would be represented by Ray and Jan at Del Mano Gallery. My work took a serious change in direction, but that didn't diminish my appreciation for flatwork or traditional turning. In fact, I'm now embellishing my work with more and more carved details, which I think is a very traditional approach.

Re: I guess I'm stuck in a rut...

#16

Nice Rut to be in!

Don Orr

>Those are beautiful chair parts JL. I wish I could do as well. To me that is the true esscence of turning. You are producing funtional, beautiful heirlooms from your heart and hands. Like they did "back in the day". To me this is one of the highest levels of skill in turning. I would also like to see your finished product.

And who is this Art guy everybody keeps talking about? And what did he do to cause so much trouble ? ;-))