>I'm not a turner but I will eventually dive into this remarkable arena.
My question is not about turning but about using green wood which is in your area of expertise.
I usually make spoons and other carved projects out of seasoned wood and have no problems. Recently I tried making spoons out of green wood and they all split despite the use of walnut oil. I really know virtually nothing about working green wood...any guidance?
>Dean if you have to use green wood, you should do a little research into the different types of wood. There are many other contributing factors to the stress that cause wood to split including the part of the tree from where it came, growing conditions, drying conditions, etc. Some woods split more readily than others. I don't know what dimension wood you need but unless there is a good reason to switch from dry to green, why would you want to?
>The only reason is sentimental. If one of my daughter's is in town and we trim some limbs on or property I thought it would be fun to make spoons together. We tried and it didn't work well.
>Oh boy have you asked the Million Dollar Question. And there are shelves and shelves of books and reports and papers on the subject of "why does green wood often crack and split and warp and twist and cup and bow?"
So let's start with what you're starting with.
Are we talking about beginning with a two inch diameter branch or a piece of wood cut from a larger log?
Is the finished spoon going to contain any of the pith of the branch or log? If so - DON'T. The pith is a cracks generator.
Are you working with a fruitwood, a resinous wood, a wood from a tree with leaves, or needles?
Are the growth rings tight or loose?
Is the spoon relatively thick - or thin and delicate?
Is the "bowl" of the spoon end grain or side grain?
Are you carving just cut wood, wood that was pruned several days to a week ago, or wood that was cut weeks or months ago and left outside?
After you carve the spoon, are you doing anything to control its moisture loss or just letting it sit out - in the heated shop - or house?
What you want to do is control the rate of mositure loss - and thus allow the wood to adjust its internal stresses and strains. Given time and controlled drying, the wood can try and even those things out. Lose too much of the "free water" too fast and the cell walls will collapse and lose their strength - and let go of each other (crack, split, check). Soaking the piece in oil - preferably in a vacuum - will slow down the loss of free water - but it won't stop it.
Google "wood drying" and "wood shrinkage", along with "radial shrinkage" and "tangential shrinkage" PLUS "wood".
Also think of the growth rings as concentri rubber bands, the ones closer to the bark stretched, the ones farthest from the bark loose. If you cut through the rubber bands - what will happen?
I've been meaning to put some web pages together on this subject. Your question has got me working on it - again - finally.
>Good post Charlie, except that I'm pretty sure you don't get much shrinkage (and therefore cracking) until the free water has departed and you start to lose the bound water from the cell walls. In other words, the moisture content of that outer layer of cells has to go below the fiber saturation point (roughly 25 to 30% MC) before the wood starts to check.
>Just dry your wood properly Dean. You can turn of carve whatever your heart desires and without correct drying, you saw what happened. I turn green wood every week. It goes into a DNA bath for a few days, wrapped up in news paper for a couple of weeks and BAM! ready to finish turning or carving. The trick is that the alcohol displaces the water. When the alcohol evaps out...no more moisture issue. There is usually some warpage so plan you piece accordingly.
>All you need is basic knowledge of the material. Bruce Hoadley's understanding wood is a good easily understood reference. There is an article on my website about green wood.
You can carve spoons using limb wood just fine. Most species will work. It will need to be sawn or split to eliminate the pith. Keep it wrapped when not working on it to moderate the drying. You don't need to do much of anything else.
Green wood spoons have been used for a LONG time, and green woodworking used to be the norm, even for much refined work, but we have gotten away from that largely. (Not me ) :)
Here is Del Stubbs web site, more info than you can imagine.