Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

O T lively discussion

Posts

O T lively discussion

#1

O T lively discussion

paul waddle

>Mea Copa(sp),I really like this forum and don't want to endanger my stay,Ellis may ask me to pay up or shut up....

Hmmm,wonder if Cindy has anything on You tube?

I understand and agree with you all about owning a dvd on a subject you are intersted in,I continually review lyle Jamieson's excellent bowl making dvd. I knew I would,but what if I didn't? I checked out Hollow Forms from our local club,viewed it,and had no futher interest. Oh well,have a good evening. pw

Re: O T lively discussion

#2

You did nothing wrong, Paul.

Joe Pack

>

Re: O T lively discussion

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: O T lively discussion

Keith Tompkins

>Paul, I don't think it's a crime (at least not yet) to ask to borrow something, even a turning tape. Please don't take it too seriously.

Re: O T lively discussion

#4

Rent what you want... *LINK*

Peter Teubel

>They have everything imaginable in instructional content.


SmartFlix

Re: O T lively discussion

#5

Re: O T lively discussion

Don Evans

>I thought it was interesting that one who objected to the DVD borrowing offered a special tool earlier in another thread for someone else to use. What is the difference between borrowing a DVD or borrowing a Tool? In both cases both makers lose out money wise.

The only difference I see is that tools don't come with an enclosed warning note. It's mostly just how you think about things two different items and two different thinking patterns but both actions the same, hum, interesting (to me anyway).

Don

Re: O T lively discussion

#6

Re: Rent what you want...

paul waddle

>Danke Herr Teubel for the link. pw

Re: O T lively discussion

#7

Re: O T lively discussion

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>Don,

Since I haven't offered to lend a tool I assume that I am not the target of your post. This whole fiasco boils down to this:

A guy walks up to a gal, he says something, she slaps him, and he walks off. A second guy walks up to the same gal, he says something, she hooks her arm in his, and they walk off together.

And the point is: It was how he said it.

A request to borrow a Cindy Drozda DVD, phrased differently, very well could have elicited no negative response from anyone. In this specific case the choice of words did bring some of us out of the woodwork.

Now, to your question about borrowing a tool. I suggest that you read my response to Wally near the bottom of the original thread. My response to you is also there implicitly. Let's suppose I have purchased a "whizzer" tool made by "Joe" that has caught the attention of the woodworking fraternity. You ask to borrow it to try it out, and I lend it to you. (It's one tool and where it goes is no problem - Joe has not been cheated out of his profit.) Now, suppose you try the whizzer, you like it, and you decide to make your own whizzer. Provided that you don't have a "tool copier machine" that copies the tool, but if all you do is look at the whizzer, maybe write down some dimensions, and then make your own whizzer that is absolutely fine.

Continuing, if you decide to make more whizzers that are exactly like Joe's whizzer and sell them, then you have stepped in the ethical cesspool, as it were. Note that I am talking about personal ethics here, not legalities.

My comments here are in no way meant to represent the motives of the original poster, Paul.

I am in the process of designing a curriculum for an ornament class that I will teach at John C Campbell Folk School in November. There is an ornament made by a friend of mine that I would like to include there, but I know that this friend has a strong sense that it is "his" ornament. So I won't touch it. One of my best friends, Bob Rosand, and I have an agreement that allows me to make, teach, and sell ornaments similar to ones that he makes - and vice versa - he can do the same with ornaments that I make. That said, Bob and I share one venue and there we only send our own ornaments and not ones similar to the other's work. I don't send globe or acorn ornaments there and Bob doesn't send them sea urchin ornaments.

I hope that I have clarified what I see as the ethical approach to all this.

Ed

Re: O T lively discussion

#8

Steven Antonucci

Why is it OK to copy a tool and not a DVD?

steve antonucci

>If you strongly believe in the IP right of the copyright holder, why is it OK to infringe upon a toolmakers living? Assuming that I was making and selling tools (making, yes, selling, no) wouldn't I have the same rights to my IP that the DVD makers did?

The unfortunate reality is that most people don't respect IP rights anywhere. Music. Computer programs. Design. Commercial DVD's are copy protected, which makes it harder, but not impossible. Unless you recognize that IP rights apply across the board, it is pretty hard to pick and choose where it if "fair to the artist/maker/designer".

BTW- I agree that Paul's original tone was "off", but it's not my job to defend Cindy's IP rights or worry about what Paul may or may not do with the DVD that he has EVERY right to borrow. Even if he wants to copy it, it's no business of mine, so why make it mine?

Two cents, adjusted for Obamanomics-

Steve

Re: O T lively discussion

#9

Re: O T lively discussion

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Paul, if I had been treated as you were yesterday on this forum, I would be really angry. You asked if someone would lend you a DVD for a couple of days. Period. I read the 3 posts you made in the thread and can find no reason to assume that you intend to unlawfully make a copy or copies of the DVD. However, others did choose to make that assumption. You were lectured and altogether treated very badly.

I think that some members of this forum owe you an apology.

Wally

Re: O T lively discussion

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Why is it OK to copy a tool and not a DVD?

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Steve, Yes, toolmakers have the same rights as writers and photographers. Maybe even more. Copyright protects the actual design or printed materials concerning the tool, a patent protects the actual tool, and the way it works....at least in theory.

Believe me, people copy tools as well, not just dvd's! I've seen copies of my gauge at several turning events, and now one company is marketing calipers with brass balls on the ends instead of sharp pointed ends like most calipers. It wouldn't be so bad if I hadn't sent the guy a sample of my gauge for evaluation. Gee, wonder where he got THAT idea from?

People copy other turners work as well, often times not even giving the original maker any credit at all. How many times have we heard "Hey, I attended your demo, and I paid good money for it! It's now mine to do with as I please!" ?

Re: O T lively discussion

#11

Re: O T lively discussion

Carole Valentine

>Wally, perhaps Paul had no ill intentions at all. No one knows but Paul. If he didn't, perhaps he should not have said up front that he "knew it was a no-no". To me, that implies that one is planning on doing something that they know is wrong. I think that is what prompted most of the negative responses. Had he simply asked what type of tool Cindy used (which later in the thread was his stated reason for wanting to borrow the DVD), or even where he might rent the DVD, he would have gotten a ton of helpful answers and none of this would have ever happened.

Having said that, I loaned Bill Grumbine's first bowl video to a student WITH the stipulation that he include it in the order I was helping him put together for some tools from a supplier. He did. I explained to him that the turning world was a relatively limited market, and because of that, it was cost prohibitive to include copy protection in those videos like that built into movies and software. If everyone simply borrowed or made copies of the DVDs, we would soon find ourselves with no new DVDs coming out because it resulted in a negative cash flow for the artists who made the video. It may come to that anyway with all the clubs having lending libraries.

Re: O T lively discussion

#12

Re: Why is it OK to copy a tool and not a DVD?

Russ Fairfield

>Steve, it isn't OK to copy someone else's tools and sell them, just as it isn't OK to copy someone elses DVD, or to borrow their lawnmower when they aren't home. But that doesn't stop people from doing these things. We see it all the time in tools, hollowing systems, and other things we use. It's an individual decision whether we copy, borrow, or steal it; and if we chose to buy, whether we buy it from someone else who copied it, or buy it from the person who developed it. The excuse I hear most often is that "it was cheaper".

I have been making and selling videos, and have written several articles that are here on Wood Central and on my own website. I know people are copying them. What to do about it? The choices are mine - I could spend the money to pursue legal action, or I could accept the fact that there are thieves among us and not worry about it. I have chosen the latter route with the knowledge that the majority of woodturners are good and honest folks. I suspect that the others who make videos have the same attitude.

Re: O T lively discussion

#13

Re: Why is it OK to copy a tool and not a DVD?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>You are right Russ,

Most woodworkers are clear thinking people. I also will say that few people make a living at selling tools, dvd's etc, you sell your skill with your name and reputation, most of us here do this for fun, having been around many of you here that do sell your work I also know that it's not a lucrative career, but choice of passion in a narrow market, be it a turned item or knowledge sharing.

I have a good friend who makes tools for a living, his attitude is that any one can make what he makes, he see's it as an experience that he shares with other tool makers in the same field as he. He and I talk often about the concept of sharing and growth, there is enough work in his niche market to go around, it's a narrow one, much narrower than turning.

I think we need to keep some of this concept of Copyright in perspective, for me at times it's stifling to read what I see on line about it, I work it every day in my day job, it has its place, but is there anything new out there really that has not been thought of before? Sure we need to defend what we develop or create if it's part of our economic balance, but is every word we say subject to copyright, just becasue we have a dvd , does that make us the guardian and owner of it's information?

I think my tool making friends attitude is all about sharing what we know with others who make the same type of things to make us all better is a good direction to take in my opinion, the illusion of being "famous" for what we say or do complicated with money and reputation takes the oxygen out of my interest in many things I do for fun.

By the way the only thing I led out of my shop is my Belt Sander....

:-)

take care,

Jim

Re: O T lively discussion

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: O T lively discussion

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Carole, I went back and re-read Paul's original post. I believe he asked "Is it a no-no", not "It is a no-no". Perhaps he was just making an innocent request.

Re: O T lively discussion

#15

Apologies to Paul!

Carole Valentine

>You are absolutely right Keith. I should have opened another window and and re-read his post as I was writing. I read "Is it" as "It is". My sincere apologies to Paul, if he was in fact ASKING if it was a no-no!