Re: O T lively discussion
Ed Moore in SW Virginia
>Don,
Since I haven't offered to lend a tool I assume that I am not the target of your post. This whole fiasco boils down to this:
A guy walks up to a gal, he says something, she slaps him, and he walks off. A second guy walks up to the same gal, he says something, she hooks her arm in his, and they walk off together.
And the point is: It was how he said it.
A request to borrow a Cindy Drozda DVD, phrased differently, very well could have elicited no negative response from anyone. In this specific case the choice of words did bring some of us out of the woodwork.
Now, to your question about borrowing a tool. I suggest that you read my response to Wally near the bottom of the original thread. My response to you is also there implicitly. Let's suppose I have purchased a "whizzer" tool made by "Joe" that has caught the attention of the woodworking fraternity. You ask to borrow it to try it out, and I lend it to you. (It's one tool and where it goes is no problem - Joe has not been cheated out of his profit.) Now, suppose you try the whizzer, you like it, and you decide to make your own whizzer. Provided that you don't have a "tool copier machine" that copies the tool, but if all you do is look at the whizzer, maybe write down some dimensions, and then make your own whizzer that is absolutely fine.
Continuing, if you decide to make more whizzers that are exactly like Joe's whizzer and sell them, then you have stepped in the ethical cesspool, as it were. Note that I am talking about personal ethics here, not legalities.
My comments here are in no way meant to represent the motives of the original poster, Paul.
I am in the process of designing a curriculum for an ornament class that I will teach at John C Campbell Folk School in November. There is an ornament made by a friend of mine that I would like to include there, but I know that this friend has a strong sense that it is "his" ornament. So I won't touch it. One of my best friends, Bob Rosand, and I have an agreement that allows me to make, teach, and sell ornaments similar to ones that he makes - and vice versa - he can do the same with ornaments that I make. That said, Bob and I share one venue and there we only send our own ornaments and not ones similar to the other's work. I don't send globe or acorn ornaments there and Bob doesn't send them sea urchin ornaments.
I hope that I have clarified what I see as the ethical approach to all this.
Ed