>After being in the Navy for 33 years (no tree's at sea) and growing up in Southern Idaho ( no big trees except sage brush) I find it difficult at times to tell what tree's are what just by looking at them.
For example, I saw a fairly large tree about 4 weeks ago, about 8in in diameter, that had been cut into sections and laid on the crub for trash pick up. As I approched the log I saw that the inner core of the tree was white, almost prue white like a holly. So I grab several of these cut up sections home with me. The outer bark is fairly smooth. I took one branch and turned it on my lathe to about 3in and then I coated it with sealer.
Now I notice after about four weeks the white seems to have turned a different color, sort of bluish in portions of the turned branch, while the other logs I have remain white. I do not have a camera so I can not post pictures.
I have two questions:
1-Is there a book or website that I can get/use to see a pictures of live trees and then I would be able to get to know a live tree when I see it in the woods or along the crub.
2-Can anyone ID the wood I picked up with the description I gave.
>Remlik is near Urbanna which is in Middlesex County. I am not very far from Virginia Beach. It takes me about 1 1/2 hours to get to the Norfolk airport. How long have you been in Virginia Beach?
>Been here since 1979. I left home, Idaho, in 1978 when I joined the Navy. I spent 22 years on Aircraft Carriers out of Norfolk, one tour in Pureto Rico and the rest of my time here. I retired this past January. Still trying to not get too bored around the house. Still have one kid in hight school and the LOML teaches college. Oh yea, we still have two 20 yr olds living with us. Trying to push them out the door, one left, but she came back.
>This tree may be holly, but if not, there is a good chance it is Southern Magnolia -- as suggested by the smooth bark with blue lines appearing in the turned wood. Large, thick, waxy, smooth edged, dark green leaves would confirm this identification. Both of these woods are among my favorites.
>Cheez Carl, you haven't seen many trees since you think 8" dia is fairly large, HA ha. If it's getting blueish, it's either a buckeye, or it's starting to mold. Probably not buckeye if the bark is smooth. My favorite tree ident help is google images. I have started searches like, smooth bark, white sapwood, and see what pops up. You should also visit a state park or state forest preserve. It's pretty common for each state to have a book with common state trees. I googled West Virginia trees and got a couple of good hits;
>I have not yet found the "perfect" book. Some have great pictures of leaves, for example, but since many leaves vary widely within a species, sometimes a drawing is more useful. Bark photos are notoriously less than useful due to the wide variations, sometimes even on the same tree. Bark on younger trees often looks far different than bark on older trees.
Some ID books have better written descriptions; some are missing information or have "interesting" ways too organize things. I have to rely on a number of books.
The Audubon Society books are good. They have versions for various regions. Keep in mind though that just like birds, a tree can sometimes be found far outside it's normal range. I like the fruit, flower, and autumn color photos in the Audubon field guide and the text is some of the best.
I find the illustrations of the leaves, twigs, and fruit in the color plates of the Peterson field guides to be more useful than the photographs in other books. However, some of their other information is incomplete, such as photos of bark.
My new favorite book is the recently published National Wildlife Federation "Field Guide to Trees of North America". This book has excellent organization, good photos, and useful text. Their section "How to identify a tree" is great.
The book "Identifying Wood" by R. Bruce Hoadley is probably the best for IDing wood when you don't have access to the rest of the tree. Hoadley teaches you how to look at a small transverse section of wood with a hand lens or low-power microscope and determine the type of wood from the structure. It's easy to narrow down most common species by their pore structure, tyloses, and rays. He even provides some chemical and UV fluorescent tests.
For the best tree ID without examining the wood structure, try to get the bark, the leaves, and the fruit. This is usually impossible for "found" wood. I sometimes carry a field guide in the woods and I'm getting better, but sometimes I have to return to a tree later in the year for the leaves or fruit.
Note that the US Government will make up to five wood IDs per year for citizens. This takes about six weeks. One WC member sent a sample and it came back with a one word ID: "elm". That was the same conclusion I made using the Hoadley book and looking at a sample with a microscope.
The absolute worse way to identify wood is to show a bunch of people a photo of the wood and even the bark. This will generate a number of guesses, each believable since the overlap in natural variation causes so many boards and bark look alike, and most wrong. Unless the wood or bark is very distinctive, you might as well pull a name out of a hat and just call it that. I suspect that a huge number of turnings and artworks are mislabeled. (but what does it matter?)
>Wow, I did not think about the magnolia tree, of course I did not know the wood from this tree was white either. There was no leaves around the log sections when I picked them up so it could be a magnolia. There are a number of these big tree's around here and that is one of the few tree's I do know if I see a live one.
>That is close. You know the wife and I have been meaning to go over there to the National Park, we collect those passport stamps from the parks. I just might give you a shout this summer.
I cleaned out my shop yesterday. :) But it was raining last night. I need to make a picture frame for my daughter, she did a painting in school this year and now it is taped to the wall.
LAUGHING...... well an 8in tree is big for me since my bandsaw is only a 14in Jet, but for Christmas I LOML bought me the conversion kit to make it bigger. :) Just need to get out there and convert it.
Man, I just did not know that it would be that hard to ID a tree. I do like the sound of the book you mentioned and I will be looking for it. And since LOML is s Geologist and I bought her a microscope a few years back I might get to play with it myself now. :)
>>>>I find the illustrations of the leaves, twigs, and fruit in the color plates of the Peterson field guides to be more useful than the photographs in other books. However, some of their other information is incomplete, such as photos of bark.
My new favorite book is the recently published National Wildlife Federation "Field Guide to Trees of North America". This book has excellent organization, good photos, and useful text. Their section "How to identify a tree" is great.<<<<<<
I can also highly recommend the NWF 'Field Guide to Trees of North America' [by Kershner, Mathews, Nelson, and Spellenberg, 2008] as an accessible, well-produced, and very helpful overall guide to the subject. A bit 'thick' for convenient use in the field, it now is my go-to book when I can't readily recognize a tree species from previous experience. (.....I'm a botanist and biology professor!)
I also routinely use Hoadly's wood identification book to find the name of (or confirm) the identification of wood samples.