Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew
charlie belden
>An earlier thread regarding how to grind a detail/spindle gouge got me wondering about terminology.
What IS the difference between a detail gouge and a spindle gouge?
With the exception of cove cuts, as far as I can see, most everything that a detail gouge/spindle gouge can do can be done with a curved cutting edge skew. And depending on the sweep of the cove, the skew can do coves as well, perhaps with not as nice a finished surface as a detail or spindle gouge, but pretty good.
And a skew will get into tighter places than a detail or spindle gouge - PLUS you have a straight line cutting edge rather than a fingernail grind to keep track of.
I find a narrow spindle (or maybe it's a detail) gouge - in the 3/16th inch range, twitchy and proned to catching - far more often than a larger skew that'll get in the same places. It's just too easy - at least for me - to have the area of the edge slip from the roundish tip to the side grind - and control of the cut lost.
And when it comes to pull or push cuts for peeling/shear cuts the skew does great, even with a curve in the cutting edge. It'll also do "vertical cuts" which are tricky to do with other gouges.
So, with the exception of narrow coves, why detail/spindle gouges?



