Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

Posts

Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

#1

Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

charlie belden

>An earlier thread regarding how to grind a detail/spindle gouge got me wondering about terminology.

What IS the difference between a detail gouge and a spindle gouge?

With the exception of cove cuts, as far as I can see, most everything that a detail gouge/spindle gouge can do can be done with a curved cutting edge skew. And depending on the sweep of the cove, the skew can do coves as well, perhaps with not as nice a finished surface as a detail or spindle gouge, but pretty good.

And a skew will get into tighter places than a detail or spindle gouge - PLUS you have a straight line cutting edge rather than a fingernail grind to keep track of.

I find a narrow spindle (or maybe it's a detail) gouge - in the 3/16th inch range, twitchy and proned to catching - far more often than a larger skew that'll get in the same places. It's just too easy - at least for me - to have the area of the edge slip from the roundish tip to the side grind - and control of the cut lost.

And when it comes to pull or push cuts for peeling/shear cuts the skew does great, even with a curve in the cutting edge. It'll also do "vertical cuts" which are tricky to do with other gouges.

So, with the exception of narrow coves, why detail/spindle gouges?

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

#2

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

john lucas

>I'm not sure about all detail gouges but the thompson gouges are thicker than spindle gouges. This means you can hang them over the tool rest much further. This is really handy when doing square pommels to round. I also use them to do inside out turning for the same reason. You simply can't get the tool rest close to where your cutting on these so there is a lot of tool hanging out there to vibrate.

Because of the narrow point and flatter flute I can reach in to tighter areas than I can with a standard spindle gouge.

I will agree with you to a point on the skew doing the same job and some jobs better. I'm a skew proponent. However when it comes to turning beads I think it's hard to beat a good spindle or detail gouge. For some reason it is much easier to stay on the bevel and not get a kick back with a small gouge than it is with the skew.

I do use the toe of the skew to reach into tight areas such as "tucking in" a bead. this is cleaning up the bottom area between 2 beads.

I have found on occasion that a skew will tend to tear out some woods when doing long tapers or curves. When this problem occurs I switch to a smaller spindle gouge. I don't know what the difference in the cut is because the angles and all look the same but I've done this repeatedly and found the spindle gouge leaves a cleaner cut than the skew.

When cutting coves with the skew I get the same quality of cut that I get with a spindle gouge. You are limited somewhat in the size cove you can cut because of the longer bevel and grind on a skew. To prove this I ground a skew to about 50 degrees. It had a very short bevel and let me turn really sharp coves. I still pick up the spindle gouge to do coves because I can control the shape better.

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

#3

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

Cyril Griesbach

>John is right about the detail gouge...at least he's right about the 3/8" Thompson I have. I recently did a demo of a stylized figure turned on three parallel axis. This set up could not allow moving the tool rest very close and the detail gouge gave me more support extending over the tool rest. My understanding of a detail gouge is that it's a spindle gouge with a shallower flute giving it more mass under the flute.

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

#4

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Could I add that when a flute is milled in round stock a depth of 50% of the diameter will create a flute as wide as the diameter, this is a spindle gouge which is ground with a large radius across the entire diameter. Now a detail gouge with a shallower flute depth also has a narrow flute width, the extra steel on either side of the flute is waste so the wings can be ground away to create the smaller nose radius to fit the width of the flute.

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

#5

Why Not?

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Charlie,

The detail gauge is just another skew with a different shape, I can do everything you were talking about with a straight skew, I don't care about the curved ones, and then I can do everything I can do with a straight skew with a detail gouge. I use a lot the heel of the skew and sometimes the toe as well, but I can do the same safer with a DG.

They have a learning curve and like the skew they must be very sharp, but now I am using them more and more, and not just for details, I can shape things like an egg or rough a bowl outside and inside with the DG alone, actually I can finish the outside of the bowl with the DG and then finish the inside with a bowl gouge.

Jorge

Like the skew, each DG comes with 200 catches, so have at it and use them all in both tools, then you will be a happier turner... :o)

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

#6

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

Donna Banfield

>Which is exactly how I have ground my Thompson 3/8's detail gouge.

It has a very sharp point, that allows me to reach into areas that I wouldn't/couldn't get with most skews. It can be grabby if you're not paying attention, and can cause a problem, but then, so can almost every other turning tool that you use. ;^)

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

#7

Re: Why Not?

David Walser

>

...Like the skew, each DG comes with 200 catches....
Only 200 catches? For some reason, my skews came with more than that -- and they didn't even charge me extra! Must be some sort of volume discount.

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

#8

Re: Why Not?

john lucas

>I think there are a few repressed catch's that only come out later in the tools life. I had one show up the other day.

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

#9

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

Gordon Seto

>The thickness of the steel remaining under the edge of a detail gouge creates a long hollow grind. I find if I round off the heel, a short primary bevel is easier to maintain bevel control and reduce catches.

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

#10

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

charlie belden

>This forum is a wonderful source of information - ask a question and you get great, thought out and well written answers from good sources who are willing to pass along the knowledge theyv'e acquired.

I now understand the difference between a detail and a spingle gouge and the advantages and disadvantages of each for specific applications.

I still see having a cutting edge on either side of the tip of the tool as doubling the opportunity for one to contact the wood where it shouldn't - but I see that there are ways to reduce the problem.

I really like the idea of turning tools with a "number of catches built in" rating system.

Thanks all.

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

#11

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

john lucas

>It also make sharpening faster, especially if you use diamond hones. The one downside, the bevel is so long that you can't position the tool rest really close to the work. Not a problem with that tool.

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

#12

Re: Detail Gouge, Spindle Gouge, Skew

John K Jordan

>My new favorite gouge is the Thompson shallow detail gouge. Ground swept back, this will get into incredibly tight places. Since it is made with a shallow flute, more metal remains in the cross-section resulting in a very sturdy and vibration-free tool. The standard spindle gouge is better for making coves.

JKJ