Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

End Grain Tearout

Posts

End Grain Tearout

#1

End Grain Tearout

John T

>Fairly new to turning, and having some difficulty with tearout on the end grain parts of a bowl. Stock is spalted silver maple, very dry. Had some roughened end grain in the outside contour of the bowl, but it wasn't too bad, and have it under control with light cuts and sanding.

Problem is in the inside surface of the bowl, the endgrain is still tearing out rather than cutting. Granted, the spalting is more pronounced in the endgrain, but I can't get it smooth enough to feel confident that the 60 grit gouge will fix it.... The "face grain" parts of the bowl are working beautifully.

I'm turning at the lowest speed my lathe can go (allegedly 875 rpm, based on pulleys). Sharpening tools helps a bit, but still not getting a good cut.

Faster speed? Tips on using the gouges, or is there a better tool to use on endgrain? Can I apply some shellac (or maybe CA glue) and cut again when its dry? (I'm worried about discoloring the wood if I use CA...)

Thanks in advance for any insight.

-John-

Re: End Grain Tearout

#2

Re: End Grain Tearout

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>I've done just that with end grain, I have applied a bit of CA to hold the end grain and then shear cut with the edge of a gouge to get as Bill Grumbine called it once with me, "Angel Hair" shavings...when you get it, it works really well.... I use the same principle with weak end grain on pens, it holds the ends strong to let you make that clean cut.

Take care,

Jim

Re: End Grain Tearout

#3

Re: End Grain Tearout

ktkjr

>light (shear) cuts, and sharp tools.

Re: End Grain Tearout

#4

Thanks, Jim - So

John T

>So the CA won't really affect future finishing? I was intending to go with clear shellac and wax, but may use a water-based poly, based on some of the threads I've read here (not to open another thread on finishes for spalted maple!). Mostly worried about the CA limiting my choices for a finish.

Thanks again for the response.

-JOhn-

Re: End Grain Tearout

#5

Re: End Grain Tearout

john lucas

>I would say increase the speed, use a freshly sharpened tool. Thin the shellac and apply it or if it's a small are use the thin CA. Normally I just put some paste wax on and try a cut or two. If that doesn't work then I use either thinned shellac or thinned lacquer. Sometimes it takes a few coats if the wood is really punky.

Re: End Grain Tearout

#6

Thanks

John T

>Thanks for the response. Seems like I'm sharpening more than turning, and I've been trying shearing cuts, but still have bigger chunks thank I'd like.

My tools might not be scalpel-sharp, but they're as sharp as I'm likely to get them, so I'll have to make do....

Thanks again for the reply.

-John-

Re: End Grain Tearout

#7

Thanks, John

John T

>Thanks for the reply - I'll try spinning faster - Like 1200 or 2000 range??.

I don't think the wood is really rotten or punky - it's not soft or "spongy" feeling - just nicely marbled looking. I suspect I'd be having a similar problem with end grain no matter what wood I'm turning, but my inexperience is being accentuated by the spalting.

The problem area is probably less than an inch square, so I'll try the CA. Seems to me CA will be harder and cut cleaner than shellac.

Nice to know about the wax trick , too!

-John-

Re: End Grain Tearout

#8

Re: Thanks, Jim - So

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hi John,

My experience is that it did not effect the finish, the CA (not thin) held the fibres firm while they were cut.

I turn a lot of spalted woods for pens as well, again the CA holds the fragile end grain at the bushing strong while i make the last light cuts with a freshly honed tool edge.

Take care,

Jim

Re: End Grain Tearout

#9

Correction > I meant Use Thin CA

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>

Re: End Grain Tearout

#10

Re: End Grain Tearout

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Hi John,

Lots of good ideas so far. But sometimes certain woods are just a pain. Dry spalted maple can be one of them. It also depends on the shape of the bowl you are trying to turn. If it is a very open bowl it is sometimes easier to get a clean cut. Steep sided bowl can present many problems on the transition areas.

Also I have found that doing excessive sanding will result in very muddled areas after you apply a finish. It seems smooth after sanding, but just rears its ugly head after the finish is applied.

In my humble opinion, sometimes it is just better to move on to a more forgiving piece of wood. That is why I have a wood stove. :)

Also, if you list your location, someone may live nearby who would be able to give you a few tips. If you are near NW Ohio, my door is always open.

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: End Grain Tearout

#11

Re: End Grain Tearout

Carole Valentine

>Good point, Dave. New turners can benefit from trying to conquer end grain tearout - it's part of the learning curve. But there are some pieces of wood that you are just wasting your time on and that can be very discouraging. As an example, Barb had given me a large pawlonia blank(not right spelling but I have not finished my first cup of coffee) that was giving me absolute fits. When she was here last weekend, she tried to turn it and we both decided that it would benefit from either a visit to the burn barrel or the texture experiment bin.

Re: End Grain Tearout

#12

Re: End Grain Tearout

john lucas

>That must be an east coast variety. I turn a fair amount of the stuff and haven't ever had cutting problems with Pawlonia. In fact it's one of my favorite woods for hand mirrors. Of course those are dry wood. I have turned the green stuff with no problems. Of course wood is wood and has a mind of it's own. Now really dry box elder gives me fits and that is the wood I use to experiment with all these tearout problems. Well that and any badly spalted wood that is punky.

Re: End Grain Tearout

#13

Re: End Grain Tearout

John K Jordan

>I generally use sanding sealer (basically thinned shellac or lacquer) or oil. Occasionally water or wax. Sometimes I can get a good surface with a cabinet scraper where the gouge gives me problems.

JKJ

Re: End Grain Tearout

#14

Thanks, all

John T

>Thanks for the responses - the tearout isn't really bad enough for me to consider burning the evidence, and the shellac and higher turning speed seems to work better - have to mess around with it some more, maybe tonight or later this week.

Appreciate the insights. I've got some Pawlonia blanks to try, too, so we'll see if the tearout is the woods fault or operator error.

Thanks again.

-John-

Re: End Grain Tearout

#15

Re: Thanks, all

Al Neighbors

>I mix Lacquer with about 60 or 65 percent Thinner, and put on a coat of it, let it dry about 30 minutes, then turn the speed up to almost unsafe, and take very light cuts with a freshly sharpened tool.

And if that doesn't work, I put a curse on it, and toss it into the burn pile. :o)

Re: End Grain Tearout

#16

Re: Thanks, all

Carole Valentine

>Pawlonia is not always tearout prone. I have turned a fair amount and had no problem. It was just the particular piece was really soft.