Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

If I Knew Then What I Know Now

Posts

If I Knew Then What I Know Now

#1

If I Knew Then What I Know Now

charlie belden

>Patience is not one of my few virtues. Foresight isn�t on that list either, despite the fact that my �working career� was in long range urban transportation planning. The lack of JUST these two virtues has affected what I turn, both in terms of the size of pieces as well as the types of pieces.

I bought a JET mini and some basic turning tools to turn magic wands and wheels and axles for toys for kids in the neighborhood - my primary interest in woodworking being flat work - primarily solid wood stuff using traditional joinery. Not surprising, I graduated from turning cut offs from flat work projects to turning prunings from neighbor�s trees. Wasn�t much of a jump - in terms of tecniques or size - to do weed pots. The acquistion of a scroll chuck was a logical progression, opening up hollowing possibilities.

Unless you�re a segmented turner, you can�t do hollow forms out of flat work scraps or boards. And if you�ve turned a green branch pruning big enough to hollow, you know about the Pith In Cracking Problem. And if you�ve turned a lidded box out of green wood you know how green wood distorts as it dries - and the problems with the lid fit that causes.

If I knew when I started turning to begin collecting and bandsawing blanks from all the logs and logettes (little logs) of all kinds of free wood available to an Urban Forrester, I�d have a stash of dry wood to play with - NOW. Alas, the stacked and covered black and claro walnut, magnolia, poplar, cherry, apple, deordor cedar and various junipers are half to several years away from becoming lidded boxes or other hollow forms.

If I know that by merely grinding a curve on the cutting edge of my skews, they�d have become my favorite turning tools a year or more sooner - and I�d have that much more practice using them under my belt.

If I knew when I started what the possibilities are with turning, would I have started off with a bigger lathe?

What�s on YOUR list of If I Knew Then What I KNOW NOW that you think a newbie to turning should know NOW?

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

#2

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>You mention not being able to turn hollow forms from boards unless you're doing segmented turning. Well, you're right. But you may not be as right as you think. You may be thinking of the usual kind of segments that are built up in flat rings. But do you know about STAVED segmented turning? In this kind of segmentation, the staves are glued together to form something like a tepee. Relatively little wood is required, and it comes from flat boards. The tricky part is that each stave has to be cut with a precise compound angle that depends on( and only on) the number of staves and the slant angle of the tepee shape. If this kind of segmented turning would be useful to you, because of all the flat boards you have, let me know, and I can help you out -- all this assuming that you don't already know all about it.

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

#3

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

paul waddle

>Patience is not my strong suit either Charlie,but I do keep on. Explain the virtures of the rounded skew-maybe post a picture. My regular skew does ok,but won't stay sharp(Freud vanadium possibly a carbon steel). If I'm not mistaken,a turner just recently said he didn't like the round skew? pw

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

#4

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

David Walser

>This one's easy: If I knew then what I know now, I'd have started turning sooner! I never touched a lathe in high school. When I worked at a furniture mill while going to school, all the lathes were automatic multi-spindle monsters and I stayed away from them there, too. So, my coming to turning is pretty much accidental and came about only because my wife said she'd wanted to learn how to turn since before we'd met. (A former boyfriend's father turned her a bowl and she was fascinated with the process.) So, I've missed out on 30 years or so when I could have enjoyed this wonderful hobby. If I knew how fascinating it was back then, I'd have started turning back then -- and I'd know a lot more today that I'd wish I'd known back then.

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

#5

Cross Sections & Cutting Edge Curve

charlie belden

>Paul wrote:

Explain the virtures of the rounded skew-maybe post a picture. My regular skew does ok,but won't stay sharp (Freud vanadium possibly a carbon steel). If I'm not mistaken,a turner just recently said he didn't like the round skew? pw

================

I was referring the a straight vs curved cutting edge on the skew. I found that putting a curve to the cutting edge turned the skew from my most feared tool to my most favored tool. Getting the long pint/ote and heel away from the center of the cutting edge made shear cuts much less prone to catches and spiral cuts. I also learned, from watching how a bedan is used, to use the long point - facing DOWN - to begin and make rolling cuts, v-grooves and "pomell" (sp?) cuts (square to round with vertical transition).

As for oval and round skews - I have trouble getting semi-symetric bevel angles on them since there's no "reference" flat area to go by.

Attached illustrations may help.

The cross section of skews is a different issue. Easing the sharp corners of a rectangular cross section, or even rounding the top and bottom edges makes sense - to me. Oval or round cross sections? That's a trade off - lose cross sectional area and thus some support strength in return for what? And then there's the "no refernce" for bevel angles.

Hope this clarifies some things. If not, ask a clearer question and I'll see if I can do another illustration - assuming I know the answer to your question.

As for sharpening and holding an edge - I found that the WorkSharp - with the "slotted" wheels makes it quick and easy to touch up an edge so I do it more often - though not often enough. HIgh speed steel tools hold and edge longer than "vanadium steel" and overheating them quite a bit - as while grinding - doesn't cause them to lose their temper.

Maybe getting a better quality skew could be part of the answer to your problems. Which cross section - that's your call ; )


img

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

#6

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

charlie belden

>David:

I had to read and re-read that last line several times. It's a version of "I feel more like I do now than I did when I got here."

I'm of the Things Happen When They're Supposed To Happen - IF - You Pay Attention school. Earlier in life you probably had more responsibilities, kids to enjoy raising, less space and fewer resources (read "disposable income").

I think this explains one of the reasons turning is so attractive to "more mature" people than younger folks.

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

#7

Re: Cross Sections & Cutting Edge Curve

paul waddle

>Thank you Charlie,I need to try one of those round skews. And yes, I need to up grade to hss tools.pw

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

#8

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

john lucas

>Charlie reminds me of my former boss who was 86. He always said if he knew he was going to live this long he would have taken better care of himself.

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

#9

Round Cross Section or Curved Cutting Edge?

charlie belden

>When you say "round" skew - do you mean round cross section or curved cutting edge?

If you have a straight cutting edge skew and want to put a curve on it, that's not hard to do. Just rock the skew left/right to remove more metal on the ends than in the middle.

The round cross section skews seem like they'd be kind of twitchy since the cutting edge is so short. But I guess if you're cutting with the long point that's less of a problem.

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

#10

Re: If I Knew Then What I Know Now

Texian

>Turning or life, pretty much everything is on the list.