Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

Posts

How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#1

How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

paul waddle

>Can the wolvorine, or any of that type of jig, be used to sharpen a detail gouge? The bevel is compelety rounded back with the edges of the flute gound to a sharp edge.. Secondly,are caches frequent since one can no longer "ride the bevel"? pw

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#2

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

john lucas

>I do use the Wolverine to sharpen my Thompson detail gouge. I put a block in the Oneway V to block to raise my Wolverine up so that I get a sharper angle on the detail gouge than I would have on my bowl gouge. Depending on the angle you use on your Wolverine the wings on the detail gouge may come out really long. I don't mind that myself.

I'm not sure what you mean by not rubbing the bevel. I always rub the bevel on my detail gouges just like any tool. On the Detail gouge I do grind a secondary bevel. Mostly I just want to get rid of all that metal under the first bevel. This lets me reach into tighter areas and also makes sharpening faster since I'm not sharpening such a long bevel.

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#3

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

paul waddle

>Thks John,I've seen pictures of detail gouges that did not have a secondary bevel,just a very long grind. Thats why I figured there was not an exact bevel to ride,just anywhere along the grind.. I was also thinking of a pull cut on the outside of bowl for sorta smoothing using the sharp part next to the flute. I'm buying a Thompson detail gouge on your recommendation. pw

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#4

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge *LINK*

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Paul, if you go to the link below you'll see how the Vari-grind was set when the tool was sharpened... you can put the Vari-grind right on the full size picture to set the leg angle on your jig.

The detail is sharpened to a fingernail with a small radius at the nose to get into tight spots. I don't know if a 40 degree angle would work on a bowl... the one to ask is John Jordan.


Sharpening guide

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#5

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

john lucas

>Paul I don't think the detail gouge is a good tool for pull cuts. The wing portion is too short and kind of blunt. A bowl gouge on the other hand can have a longer wing and the sharpening angle on the side grind is usually much more acute than it would be on a detail gouge.

a 40 degree grind works quite well on shallow bowls. I use it frequently with my bowl gouge that has a Stewart Batty grind. I have also use the Thompson detail gouge and my thompson 1/2" spindle gouge for cleaning up problem woods inside bowls. The are both ground to 40 degrees. You do have to be really good at staying on the bevel or you can get a good catch.

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

Keith Tompkins

>Hey John, try a long grind on a detail gouge...you'll love it.

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#7

Hey, Keith, the long grind.....

Al Neighbors

>is that with the wings long, and the nose also... about like 30 or so degrees???

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Hey, Keith, the long grind.....

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Al, Just guessing, but the nose angle is about 40 degrees, and the wings about one inch back from the tip. I also grind a secondary bevel.

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#9

Mike Stafford

Re: Hey, Keith, the long grind.....

Mike Stafford

>I grind my detail gouges like this...

In the attached picture three detail gouges are shown. The top one is a Henry Taylor with a short bevel which I like for hollowing boxes because the shallow flute provides a lot of support when the tool is extended over the tool rest. The steep bevel allows me to cut end grain nicely.

The second tool is a Packard detail gouge with a similar bevel. It can be used for hollowing but I prefer this tool for working on exposed end grain like the lids and bottoms of boxes.

The last tool is another Packard detail gouge with a long bevel which I use for shaping the body of my squat/plump boxes. The long sweeped back flute acts much like a skew when I am working downhill on a rounded cut and severs end grain cleanly.


img

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#10

Re: Hey, Keith, the long grind.....

john lucas

>Keith Mine looks like the bottom gouge mike is showing. I do have a long grind on the wings and I do use it but I don't think it makes a very good pull cut compared to a bowl gouge.

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Hey, Keith, the long grind.....

Keith Tompkins

>Hey John, I probably should have clarified. I just like the long grind...great for getting into tight places, planing along a thin finials and for hollowing end grain. I use it for light pull cuts, but you are right, bowl gouges are much better for the heavy stuff.

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#12

Re: Hey, Keith, the long grind.....

Gordon Seto

>I think the bottom gouge looks like a spindle gouge than a detail gouge. A detail gouge has shallow flute. The side grind has blunt angle. If we sharpen the side grind to a sharp angle, not much steel is left.

In the picture, the flute up side down has a long side grind, there is not much meat left. I think that defeats the purpose having a detail gouge, which can extend over the tool rest for detail work without chattering.

The middle layer shows the top view of my gouge. The flute of detail gouge is above the largest diameter of the rod.

On the bottom layer, the top has a 40 degree primary angle and the 2nd has 30 degree angle. Both were sharpened on Tormek. The heels were rounded on dry grinder. The sharper the angle, the more difficulty in control.

The main benefit of a detail gouge is the shallow flute with lots of steel under the flute. We can grind the tool to acute angle and extend it over further over the tool rest, to reach into tight area without chattering.


img

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: Hey, Keith, the long grind.....

Mike Stafford

>Gordon, if you look you will see the gouge is shallow fluted.

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Hey, Keith, the long grind.....

Keith Tompkins

>Gordon, no offense, but I really don't recommend the grind in the photo. My grind is exactly like an Ellsworth bowl gouge grind. The important feature of this grind, when done to David's specs, is that the swept back sides actually curve back inwards, not flaring outward as in the photo. Side grinds that flare out will be grabby, catchy, and very hard to control. I'll post a photo when I can.

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: Hey, Keith, the long grind.....

Keith Tompkins

>Here is a side view of my gouge grind. Viewed from the front, the sides appear to curl inward, not point outwards.


img

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Hey, Keith, the long grind.....

Keith Tompkins

>front view, notice lines which show cutting edge sloping inward.


img

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#17

Re: Hey, Keith, the long grind.....

Gordon Seto

>I find curling inwards, the included angle is very blunt on a shallow flute detail gouge. It would take more effort to slice through.

The flute upside down gouge was not a real gouge. It was a mild steel replica gouge Doug Thompson milled the flute on to experiment on the grind.

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#18

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Paul, look at the grind that is on the tool you receive, the slight curve on the wings to the smaller nose radius is a very good starting point.

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#19

Re: Hey, Keith, the long grind.....

Gordon Seto

>Keith,

I replied before seeing your 2nd picture from the end.

I think there are some confusion about the definition of detail gouges.

I am referring to Thompson detail and shallow detail gouges. The depth of the flute is only about 20% to 33% of the height of the diameter.

It seems to me you have a deeper flute gouge (closer to a spindle gouge) than I have in mind. I believe flute shape determines what kind of grind we can achieve.

The grind that I use is the one that on the 3 3/8" gouges. That was the grind that Jean Francois Escoulen taught and I adapted it to Tormek setting. The upside down mark up gouge grind has never been tried. I admit it looks ridiculous.

Re: How to sharpen a shallow(detail) gouge

#20

Keith Tompkins

Re: Hey, Keith, the long grind.....

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Gordon,Looking at the photo again, I see the difference...the lower tools really don't have the long wings I grind. The advantage of the long grind is that material is removed to allow access to the base of a cove (flute 90 degrees to the tool rest), and to hollow end-grain pieces, such as boxes and goblets. It leaves adequate material for needed rigidity as well. This tool will hollow and end-grain piece with amazing speed, using the gouge as a drill, then pulling from the center outwards. How fast? I can complete the bowl section of a goblet in about 20 seconds. I usually add a secondary grind to keep the heel from rubbing too much in spindle work. The grind curving inward gives complete control; something I learned from David himself. Try it...I guarantee you will love this grind.