Often after bandsawing etc we throw our wood blanks on the shelf horizontally, perhaps stickered, to dry. I came across the link below and the gentleman there is suggesting that drying lumber vertically involves less cracking and splitting. Just wondering if anyone has tried this with their blanks and noticed any difference in speed of drying and/or cracking.
In one way it makes sense because the natural orientation for wood is (usually) with the grain running vertically.
>Evaporation is evaporation. It will occur no matter which way the wood is stored.
Does this sound plausible? Sure. I would want a controlled study before I took much faith in the theory though. It is not like there are valves which only operate in the horizontal direction. It may be that you pack the wood in closer when you stack it vertically. Therefore the localized relative humidity is greater - therefore less evaporation of moisture.
Re: Drying wood with grain oriented vertically *LINK*
>I have heard about this method of stacking before many times over the years. I have never tried it in the sawmill as space is an issue. I can only speculate on the effectiveness of using it on potential short logs for turning and that would only be a waste of time.
Re: Drying wood with grain oriented vertically *LINK*
After having read the article at the link you supplied, I tried to think of actual reasons why someone might believe this is true. There 'may' be some truth in the vertical orientation thing if freshly-cut 'green' (wet) log sections are oriented vertically, and that some (or most?) of the non-bound water in the wood (xylem) cells might literally drain out of the log more efficiently if in a vertical orientation (using gravity). I presently have several pieces of wet walnut that were cut yesterday morning which came above freezing temperature mid-day; water began oozing from the cut surfaces, particularly in the sapwood areas. I stood them on end (vertically) and soon thereafter, water was puddling beneath them, and continued to do so slowly for most of the afternoon. This is where I think the vertical orientation MIGHT have some credibility in terms of reducing drying time. But it ends there.
AFTER non-bound water is removed, and the wood has lost sufficient water to reach the Fiber Saturation point (FSP) - [roughly 28-30% moisture content], the development of cracks, checks, warping, and other defects has to do with how the wood is cut relative to the annual rings (getting at the quarter-sawn 'stability' concept), and how the wood shrinks as it dries. The evenness and rate of drying has everything to do with creating or avoiding these kind of effects - NOT the orientation of the log or grain of the wood as it dries. If there are differences created in rates and amounts of wood drying (as in ends versus 'heart' or middle of the piece), internal stresses will be set-up, and there will be distortion or defects created, whether the piece is stored vertically, horizontally, or any angle. If storing the pieces vertically or in some other configuration assists in the maintenance of controlled rates and evenness of drying, it would seem this idea to be true, but in actuality, it likely has NOTHING to do with the orientation of the pieces or how they grew in nature. Rates and evenness of drying are the key elements, NOT orientation, whether up, down, or crosswise!
Concluding that boards/wood dried vertically have less defects than those dried in other physical positions seems like quite a load of horse-puckey, unless the proposer(s) can substantiate this claim with actual data. Given the amount of research done by the USDA and the Forest Products Laboratory, I highly doubt that this claim has any merit, for if it truly were correct and actually worked, this would be recommended and practiced in commercial applications. It just doesn't make sense from the wood science standpoint.
Rob Wallace
Re: Drying wood with grain oriented vertically *LINK*
Re: Drying wood with grain oriented vertically *LINK*
Fred Holder
>I know Bill and have found that his method works with sawn lumber. I tried it when I heard about it from Bill several years ago and the boards did dry with little or no cracking or end checking. However, storing on end is difficult for large quantities of wood and I'm sure not practical for large quantities of sawn boards.
I don't think that it necessarily would work if the log section were left in the round, but have never tried it. I think unless the pith is removed the log section would crack from the stresses of drying. Sawn boards, however, are a different matter.