Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Chucks...

Posts

Chucks...

#1

Chucks...

Marc Phillips

>Now that the 1236 is gone and the 1642 is in it's place, I have started turning larger bowls... at least I am trying to...

I have the old regular Nova chuck... been using it for about 6 years..

So, looking at new chucks.

Vic.... Supernova2... Oneway talon and stronghold...

My immediate instinct is the SuperNova2... $169, which makes it quite a bit cheaper than the others...

So.... what does the extra $80 - $120 or so get you with the other chucks?

If this is much asked question I apologize...

Re: Chucks...

#2

Re: Chucks...

john lucas

>I don't think there is a lot of difference anymore. It is the little things that make a difference. I played with a brand new PSI chuck that comes with 5 sets of jaws a drive center that resembles the steb center, and a screw center. It seemed to work just fine. It's kind of gawdy being gold but if you want to pimp out you lathe it's a good addition. It's $200 and comes with a nice plastic storage case for all the parts.

I have an old Nova tommy bar chuck that I still use. I do like my Vicmarc's but if you took them away I could still turn all I do today with the original Nova. I do like the extended jaws of the vicmarc which is why I bought it over other chucks on the market.

I think the good quality chucks simply have better metal, better coatings to prevent rust, stronger keys, a little less slop in all the parts and a wider variety of spindle threads.

Re: Chucks...

#3

Re: Chucks...

Philip Morris

>Marc,

Just went through the process you are. I recently downsized from a Oneway 1640 to a Jet 1220. I still have the Oneway Stronghold chuck that I used on the 1640. However, it is kindof overkill for some stuff (i.e., small lidded boxes) on the 1220.

I was looking for a small chuck and narrowed the choice between the Nova G3 and the Oneway Talon. I have turning buddies with each of these and was able to compare. As John mentioned, there is a difference in the metalurgy. My Stronghold and my friend's Talon were rust free. The G3 was covered with surface rust. On both Oneways, the jaws matched perfectly when closed. Even after loosening the jaws, closing the chuck and re-tightening the jaws, the G3 jaws just did not all fit the same. It also mattered to me that the Oneway closes with clockwise rotation of the key and the Nova closes with counter clockwise rotation (which is not as natural for me).

It also helped that Hartville Tool has their winter sale and free shipping right now. I bought the body only and added the jaws I wanted. They also have a special where you get 4 Raffan DVDs free when you buy a complete chuck. BTW, Jason at Hartville said he would knock $38 off the complete chuck price if I did not want the DVDs.

I found G3s on sale on eBay for $120 with free shipping. To get the jaws I wanted would have been another $55. The Talon was around $205 with free shipping. I'll probably use that chuck for the rest of my life, so the $30 difference will be lost in the background.

Re: Chucks...

#4

Re: Chucks...

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>When I bought my first chuck, I did the search as we all have. Most of the major brands are great. After trying several of the chucks out there, I finally decided on the talon. I turn on a Jet Mini VS, but feel the talon will work for me no matter what lathe I turn on. I now have 3 talons, one with #2 jaws, one with #1 jaws, and one currently with flat jaws, and a Nova midi, dedicated to mini Cole jaws. My workhorse is the talon with #2 jaws, but I think it would still perform admirably with a set of #3s if the need arose. I'm interested in the new Delta Midi when it comes out and doubt I would ever need anything larger than that lathe.

Our club lathe is a 1642 and I would be comfortable using my talons on one, mainly because of the type of work I do.

keithz

Re: Chucks...

#5

Re: Chucks...

Texian

>Since you ask about the extra 80-120 bucks, feel compelled to mention the $99 Grizzly chuck, said to be a clone of the Vic. Got the first one (of two) several years ago (it was $79 then) and still satisfied with value per dollar. They may not center as perfectly as the high dollar tool, but once the tenon is mashed a bit and the blank is turned round, it does not matter. No sign of rust, but I rarely turn really wet wood. "Chuck snobs" might sneer at you, but both of mine grip the wood securely and cause it to rotate when the lathe is turned on. Always mark the #1 jaw position on the tenon in case the work needs to return to the chuck.

Re: Chucks...

#6

Bill Blasic

Re: Chucks...

Bill Blasic

>I have 9 Nova chucks and not one has any sign of rust SN, 2 SN2, 3 G3, Precision Midi, Original Nova and the Titan. They all run true without a problem. Yes they do open and close by turning in different directions than others but I no longer notice that, matter of fact I'm so used to them that other chucks open in the wrong direction for me. Every set of jaws that is made for the Nova chucks will fit on every one of these chucks except one, the Titan Power Jaws, these only fit the Titan. All others are interchangable within all the chucks. Now with that said I do not believe that if you by a Nova, a Vicmarc or a Oneway that you will be disappointed as they are all very good chucks!

Re: Chucks...

#7

JL

Re: Chucks...

JL

>I have a Stronghold and a smaller basic Oneway chuck (with tommy bars). If I were to do it over, I'd get something like a Stronghold and a Talon or a Vicmarc.

Re: Chucks...

#8

Re: Chucks...

john lucas

>I have one of the Grizzly copies of my vicmarc chucks. I use them interchangeably with the Jaws and inserts. It's a good chuck. Not as nice as the Vicmarc but very serviceable. It does rust easier but not a big deal. I just clean it regularly.

Re: Chucks...

#9

Re: Chucks... *LINK*

Philip Morris

>Bill,

After reading Russ Fairfield's article on chucks, I was a little surprised to see the rust on my friend's Nova G3. So much so, I called Tim Geist, Nova US rep. He indicated that Nova had changed the metalurgy and that they will rust. This was confirmed on Nova's website (see link below).

Guess one other thing that was not mentioned in this thread. I understand that the Talon will accept almost all of the Nova jaws.


How to Prevent Rust on Nova Chucks

Re: Chucks...

#10

Re: Chucks... *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>Nova has a long nose jaw; it is my favorite.

The chart would give you some suggestion based on the size of work. Such as the powergrip jaw is not recommended on the smaller chucks.


Nova Jaws

Re: Chucks...

#11

Re: Chucks...

John Jordan

>The Stronghold or larger Vicmarc are well worth the extra money. You can do anything with them you can do with the smaller chucks, but the converse is not true.The width of the shoulder on the Nova chucks that I have used is too small, and the shoulder is what provides much of the strength. I have no experience with the other small chucks, but they will have the same issues.

John

Re: Chucks...

#12

Ok... I ordered a.... *LINK*

Marc Phillips

>Powergrip Barracuda4 Lathe Chuck System #CSCBARR4 from the Wood Turning Center. It is a larger chuck, which makes sense for me since I have the smaller Novas..

It sure looks like a great deal..

#CSCBARR4�Retail Value: $219.95 - Price through the center is $135 + $10 shipping

Ideal for Large Lathes�Versatile 9-piece Self-Centering lathe chuck system for large lathes.

Heavyweight/Heavy-Duty�Large body chuck designed to be used on lathes with 10� swings and larger.

Powerful Grip�Geared key mechanism provides a powerful grip capable of holding large diameter work.

Single Hand Tightening�The �T-handled� key allows single hand tightening with a long shaft that clears larger diameter work.

Standard thread is 1-1/2� x 8tpi.

This complete Lathe Chuck system includes:

� #1 Step Jaws

� #2 Round Jaws

� #3 Wide Jaws

� Pin Jaws

� Screw Chuck

� Jaw Tightening Wrench

� �T-Handle� Allen Wrench

� Chuck Body

� Wooden carrying case

I will post a review when I use it.... I have provided a link to the place if anyone else is interested...

Thanks again for all the advice...


Wood Turning Center

Re: Chucks...

#13

Bill Blasic

Re: Chucks...

Bill Blasic

>Philip,

Thanks for the info, always good to know. Guess I'm lucky as I have no rust on any of them but will now keep an eye out for it.