>Another linenfold winged bowl. Turned, then carved from Black Walnut, which is one of my all-time favorite woods to work. I used the figure in the wood to accentuate the linenfold illusion, which circles the bowl, and ends at the foot. Finish is Bush Oil. The bowl interior is finished with metal-leaf. Thanks for looking, Keith
>I guess you'll never get to post it on the traditional woodturner site but I'm glad you posted it here. I like the way the linen unfolds from the bowl. spectacular piece.
>You know John, I have nothing against traditional turning, in fact I spent years building chairs and other pieces that involved traditional turning. What I don't understand is...why on earth would anybody put artificial limits on their work? Even worse, impose those restrictions on others? What an awesome feeling to stand in front of my lathe, knowing I can create anything I want, the only limit is my imagination. I encourage everyone to use ALL of their talents and abilities without restrictions.
>Keith I also admire well done traditional pieces. I still do a lot of spindle work and that's more traditional than bowls and hollow vessels. I just wonder what happens when a long time contributor to the site one day decides to carve a little detail in the rim or fix a crack with stone inlay. It seems like a hard line to draw.
I hope I don't sound like I'm putting the group down. I wish them all the luck to get this going. We have room for more groups. I would like to see them be a part of the AAW the way the segmented turners are doing. More members give all turners more a stronger voice.
I appreciate all work and love to see it. I know new turners often don't want to post because they feel their pieces aren't up to the site. What they don't realize is that we were all there and I love to watch them grow. It's fun to see how the pieces advance in quality.
>I agree John. There is room for us all. I think the problem is that the artistic pieces seem to get all the attention and praise, and all the magazines are full of the artsy stuff. This may give the appearance that traditional work is underappreciated, and some traditional turners are mad as hell about it. I can't think of any known turner who didn't start out at the same place as anyone else, that is, learning the basics, and growing from there. And, very few of these turners fails to share just about everything they have learned. The bar has been raised so high that to get any recognition with a traditional piece, it must be done to exceedingly high standards, such as the pieces done by Bill Luce.
A prime example of Concept and Execution. Carving straight folds well and convincingly ain't trivial. Carving curved folds so convincingly is even more difficult. Integrating them with the turned . . .
Re: CWA - I don't think membership in AAW or that one ALSO . excludes one from becoming a member. They're promoting/preserviing one branch of turning that is, to some extent, being ignored, or lost in the firehose stream of things people are doing with what starts out as a turning. It's not an A OR B thing, but an A AND B thing. If one does both, CWA will be glad to show the pieces that aren't carved, pierced, colored, scorched, charred , sand blasted or uses stone inlays etc..
And I think there is something to be said for preserving some things that would leave a hole if they were lost.
And let's face it, AAW is promoting "Studio Turners" and "Art Turning" - the tradtional pieces getting lost in what some see as the cacophony of the current turning world. Try finding Just Turned - Just The Wood pieces on the AAW site to see what I'm referring to.
Turning is a Big Tent thing. Think of CWA as yet another booth inside where people who want to find Just Turned - Just The Wood pieces in one place can. There's plenty of room in the tent - for all kinds of turners.
And I think many here will agree that doing a really nice Just Turned-Just The Woodpiece can be pretty challenging - no place to hide mistakes, or flaws in the wood.
>As a long time lurker and sometime contributor on this site, I would like to say that all of the object and practices shown here and other places have given me inspiration. Even knowing that I will never be able to attain the level of excellence shown in a piece does not detract from the inspiration, for me.
I hope those of you who can do the more complicated, multi faceted work will continue to show and inspire the rest of us. I know I am a much better turner for having stumbled upon this message board. The sharing and support on this site are wonderful and I hope you all don't loose site of that in the, to me, less important squabble over art, color, and which techniques should, or should not, be shown here
Thanks to all of you for making my growth and enjoyment of turning so much better.
>Yet another great piece Keith. I happen to enjoy astronomy and have done a few pieces inspired by the stars myself. We have a fairly large observatory that is owned by the Amateur Telescope Makers of America (Brad Vietje will correct me if I'm wrong as he used to be the president) and we have gazed through the telescopes there on several occasions. It's interesting how you've combined the stars and your linen fold themes.
Must have been a challenge to turn this one with one wing whipping around, or did you balance it with some scrap wood on the other side?
>I just reread my post and realized I didn't finish a thought. We don't have an observatory, but there is one just up the road a mile from our house that is owned by the Amateur Telescope Makers. Of all the things to find in the middle of backwoods Vermont, who would have guessed there would be such a gem as this observatory?
>HI Mike, Yes, I turned this one off-balance...whup-whup-whup-whup sounds were coming off my gouge when I turned it. High speed and big lathe were very useful. A while back I installed metal/rubber mounts to the base of the lathe. It has made a noticable difference in absorbing vibrations. I live in an area with no streetlights; at night it is pitch black. Looking up into the heavens is awe-inspiring yet makes me feel insignificant at the same time. Perhaps we are made up of nothing more than stardust. The Andromeda galaxy is often referred to in a feminine manner, which ties my linenfold reference in nicely.
>Thanks Charlie, These pieces were fun to create; that's what helps makes turning worthwhile.I do quite a bit of traditional turning as well; anyone who intends to venture into the realm of artsy stuff should master this aspect of turned art before moving ahead. It may surprise many people that embellishments to a turning cannot make up for a poorly turned or poorly sanded piece. The embellishments often glaringly show previous mistakes rather than mask them. For example, stippling a piece will still show every sanding mark left over from inadequate sanding after the finish is applied. Gold leafing will show evey minute scratch or unfilled pore in the wood. Light reflecting off a carved surface shows every tool mark. It all goes back to basics.
The battle between art and craft doesn't bother me in the least; rather, it's the mindset of some turners who cannot accept the work being done by others that does... as though it's invalidating their own work. I'm afraid this attitude will not foster an environment conducive to growth, in fact it may be fueling a feeling of alienation between the two groups. Many traditional turners have broken ties with the AAW altogether; and have been instrumental in the forming of the traditional turning group.
There is another aspect of turning; the craft is attracting very talented people from other venues, who are applying their abilities to turned wood. Imagine when a graphic artist decides to take up turning. Or a carver who decides a turning would make a perfect canvas for their work. Check out the work of Ron Layport at Del Mano's website for a great example of what I'm referring to. This work elevates us all.
>Hi Skip, I think your thoughts are right on! If I might say, never think you can't aspire to do great things. I would encourage you to make every piece you turn the very best you are capable of, focusing on quality rather than quantity. Then, make each new piece somehow better than the previous piece. Don' hesitate to try something new, or explore new techniques. Believe in yourself and your abilities. Post images of your work, and be open to critique.You will be amazed at the progress you will make!
>by personal attacks. Why denigrate the views of those whose opinions are different from yours? Stardust is a nice piece and it is very well done. It can stand on its own merit. It doesn't need to be defended - no one has made a critical remark about it.
There is good art and bad art just like there are good turnings and bad turnings. Just because a turned piece has been colored, burnt, or carved is no reason to automatically praise it or to damn it. What we must guard against is praising bad turning that has been gussied up so as to hide the faults. The old story of The Emperor's Clothes comes to mind.
Traditional Woodturning will only thrive if traditional woodturners are made to feel unwelcome in the AAW - and that is a real danger. The directors of the AAW would do well to listen to Ray Key. At one point of his career he decided that he was just going to do one-of-a-kind pieces and not do traditional salad bowls and cutting boards. The economics of the situation turned him around real quick on that. Traditional woodturning is the bread and butter of the AAW and it would be sad if "art politics" undermines it and causes a rift.
>If you get Woodturning magazine there is an excellent article about Simon Levi who is a graphic artist turned woodturner. His work is incredible. I was going to post his website but couldn't come up with it. I loaned the magazine out today so I couldn't look it up. Maybe later.