>I watch a lot of Ovation TV (the art channel) and I've noticed a recurring theme. Charlie is looking at adding motion to his turnings (and a bunch of other wild ideas), but is it to stand out or because it interests him? (NOTE TO ALL: NOT A PERSONAL ATTACK ON CHARLIE)
Some of us are contented to make things well, and others have aspirations of being "artists". The question is how far are we willing to go to get noticed and when does something go past being a gimmick into a legitimate "statement?"
>First or all I think it is impossible to define art. However I generally feel that if you think up a technique and build a piece around that technique you are going about it backwards if your goal is to produce a piece of art. (and I've done that too many times)
To me a piece of art should be something that comes from the heart. A statement, a feeling, perhaps a memory, etc. Then you use the techniques you have at hand to produce that piece of art.
Developing a new technique such as Charlie's robot may not lead to a piece of art in itself, but might be able to be incorporated into something with expressive feelings. Perhaps a piece that suggests movement in the wind.
One of my favorite songs when I was growing up was a song about a toy that moved. I believe it was called Marvelous Toy. I could easily see myself building my version of that toy with Charlie's gadget. It went zip when it moved and Bop when it stopped and Whirr when it stands still. I never knew just what it was and I guess I never will.
>Art collectors represent a small, if not very small, group of people who take an interest in woodturning. They probably like the kind of extravagansas you describe. The great majority, those looking for something that looks like it's made out of wood and which could be used or displayed in a normal home, would react more like you (and me).
There are people capable of creating their own style, of being original while respecting the traditions of the craft (in my local Richmond club we have Tom Crabb)but often these attempts at originality seem overly contrived.
>Interesting topic. For me, a trained artist and art historian, art is a journey that begins with an idea or concept. The journey from that concept to the answer comes from questions that pop into the head. This is very possibly a journey that never ends. Each subsequent piece that is created, or in our case, turned, will yield it's own question(s), which will lead to another piece to try to answer that question. And on it goes.
No offense taken and I'm pretty thick skinned, having spent time in the usenet news group rec.woodworking ; ) I try not to take myself too seriously, or at all seriously. Absurdity surrounds us. Finding fun ones is rewarding - with the right attitude.
Few ideas spring forth fully developed, and many ideas never actually get developed well, or fully. I get an idea that interests me, explore it some - and if it holds my interest enough I make prototypes or experimental turnings to get an idea of what might be involved in incorporating the idea into a more refined turned piece. If that seems promising I may pursue it further - if not - some other idea is waiting in the queue. And I share an idea with the hope that maybe someone else will use the idea in some interesting way I would never imagine - and share what they did.
But you raise the question I asked earlier - about what's gimmicky and what's not - say using LEDs to illuminate the inside of a hollow form - and piercing the piece to allow light to be transmitted from within rather than just reflected off the surface of the piece.
What differentiates gimmick from "ground breaking"?
Technology is always pushing things, be it art or craft (assuming there's a way of defining either in a mutually exclusive way - or in ANY meaningful or agreed upon way).
I suspect that the now noted Ellsworth hollow forms were initially quite shocking, and the idea of turning a gnarly burl with voids and bark inclusions was initially not looked upon favorably - but Dale Nish and others did it anyway. Grinds were developed, tools were made and cutting technology (like carbide insert tooling) made what had been difficult or impossible to do - possible. And if something CAN be done, someone WILL do it. Occassionally that may lead to a new accepted norm - or something others will emulate.
It may be a Concept/Execution thing.
A great concept that's never executed may be really interesting - intellectually - but not physically.
And the perfect execution of a technique is to be admired for the surface it can create - but may or may not result in something that stimulates the mind or is pleasing to the eye.
Perhaps the bleeding edge where "tradtional crafts" and "art" gets fuzzy is where that combination of concept and execution come together well.
For me, turning offers a platform. I can remain on the platform - and it's a really large and intereresting platform - or occassionally - use the platform as a launching pad - more like a trampoline. I bounce up over here - see something I couldn't see before - and maybe step out to explore. But I seem to always get back on the trampoline - because it's fun. And it's that Play motivation that keeps me spinning wood - and not get bored.
ps: I recall a Burl Ives version of your toy song - and man am I dating myself by admitting that.
>When does the technique overshadow the piece? I know a lot of folks that struggle to define their work as anything more than a copy of some predecessor. The work is good, but it's compared to someone else's work.
That leads to doing different things. I am not suggesting that doing these things is good or bad. I am just trying to figure out the motivation: to be noticed or because it was inside of you?
Neither one is better than the other, but they are different.
>I think one of the saddest things that I've realized is that most adults lose the capacity to play as they get older. Some get saved when they have kids, because the kids remind us that a.) play is fun b.) play is something we used to value more than almost anything in the whole world and c.) we're going to eventually die.
Life is too short to not play. Why should turning be any different? Keep up the good work, Charlie :-)
>The question of motivation is an interesting one.
I do woodworking because I find it fun, permission to play, not work. And I also like to share in the hope that it'll get someone else to play - with an idea, or technique - the "Hell, if THAT guy can do it, and made me aware of one fairly easy way to do it - I'm gonna give it a go and try it." thing - a catlyst or perhaps a Play Provocateur - or a Play Evocateur if you prefer.
I can draw, and paint, and sculpt and carve as means of getting ideas out of my head and out where I can see, and perhaps feel them - and maybe gain a perspective I couldn't see before. I can't sing to save my life, nor have I learend to play any musical instrument - yet. For now, and the foreseeable future - woodturning is fun and a way of externalizing some thoughts.
For now, ways of incorporating movement into my turnings is interesting - and fun. How far I'll take it - who knows.
Re: Chicken and egg problem:Famous is hard to do f
keith tompkins
>Good post Steve. Usually, someone will come up with something new, then everyone else copies the idea; seems some don't have much of an imagination. It's very common to see a new tv show, then all the networks come up with their own version of the show. It happens in every field, it seems. For example,one technique I see in the turning field is piercing...a few people started the trend, now it's everywhere.I often ask myself why is this piece pierced in the first place? How does the piercing fit in with the rest of the piece? Too often, I can't see the reasoning behind it, and the piercing often detracts rather than add to the appearance of the piece. The results often aren't viewed as serious work.
Re: Play is a good reason to do anything, Charlie.
John K Jordan
>>most adults lose the capacity to play as they get older
I found the cure for that. I hang out with kindergartners every week (SS class), invite kids to the farm all the time, and am the first to volunteer for babysitting.
I do notice that when families come to "play", it's mostly me and the kids having all the fun while the grownups tend to stand or sit and watch or talk. Hope I never grow up.
>Sometimes a technique someone else uses happens to be the right technique needed to answer my question, to help me get what is in my head out and to bring it to life.
I see no problem using any technique I see if it helps me answer my questions. Besides, I believe that if I use, or try, a technique, it becomes mine because my interpretation of it will be different than everyone else's.
Re: Play is a good reason to do anything, Charlie.
Don Tewell in Central Illinois
>John, years ago at a family reunion I was the only adult (22 years old) playing with the kids. A great aunt came up to me and told me to 'never grow up, just grow older.'
This may not exactly answer the question you're asking, but in reading this discussion, a music analogy came to mind. It seems like the technique vs. art issue is like the difference between a speed metal guitar solo and someone playing a solo acoustic blues song on a guitar. The former is more technique driven, the second more art.
This gets complicated by the fact that there are many fans and aficionados of speed metal. Also, many classical musicians have technical chops that leave metal guitarists in the dust, but few people would consider a classical piece with fast arpeggio runs as nothing more than a technical exercise.
>The quitar analogy is a good one, with Joe Satrianni, Eric Clapton and Andre Segovia as examples of all technique and little soul, plenty of technique and the full range of emotions expressed via a guitar, and technique used to express something no one has experienced first hand - transcendant.
Clearly a balance between good technique and creative uses of the technique(s) is necessary to produce things that stand up over time.
Then there are the rare few who develop a special technique to do something no one else has done before, and by the time the imitations come along, is into another technique and another application that no one has done before.
A guy who live up in Tahoe did wonderful little copper and brass sheet metal and brazing rod and copprer tubing dock shanties, miner's cabins perched on a rocky hillside etc. His stuff was in galleries up and down the west coast and sold at "gallery" prices. He played with this idea for two or three years, then moved on to another welding, soldering and cutting technique and created another genre of work - before the cheap knock offs came on the market - and popped up at WalMart type stores.
Another guy I know combined japanese brush painting techniques - done with acrylics - on large canvasses. He could bang out evocative big paintings by the dozens and they sold well - for two or three years before he'd saturated his market. Alas, he had no second act - and his artists career ended fairly quickly. But he made a LOT of money during his run.
>Wilbur...NOW you're talkin'!! I use music anology all the time in my demo's. In fact, one person who attended my demo in Ottawa gave me CDs of bassist Victor Wooten, who he has studied with. It was uncanny how similar our teaching style is, even down to the same words written on the flip-chart. I consider art and music virtually the same thing; you just rely on different senses to appreciate them. In music, we strive to create our own personal style, just like many of us do in art or craft. I can usually identify a guitarist after listening to just a few notes; those are the people who have made the "big time"with a signature style. Same with turners...the big name turners have an instantly identifiable style as well. We as turners have a lathe, tools and a piece of wood. Musicians all get just 12 notes, yet there are no limits to what can be produced.