Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Turning pine?

Posts

Turning pine?

#1

Turning pine?

wilbur

>I just got back from a friend's place. They took down a tree, and knowing that I do some woodworking, saved some log segments for me. I was pretty excited because they said it was an apple tree that they took down, but it's actually pine. (My friends know nothing about woodworking.)

I thought I'd try turning a chunk of this anyway, since it's not often that I run into 15"x15"x5" chunks of wood in general, but I've heard that pine is not a great turning wood. Any tips before I give this a try? Or should I just save it for making (flatwork) boxes?

Re: Turning pine?

#2

Re: Turning pine?

Carole Valentine

>Cover everything in your shop, including yourself, if you are going to turn green pine (especially pine that has been cut this time of year.) Then come back and ask us why the heck we told you to go ahead and turn it. :)))

Re: Turning pine?

#3

Re: Turning pine?

John K Jordan

>Wilber,

You live anywhere near east TN? If so, save the turning and cleanup time Carole mentioned and drop by the farm. I'll cut you a big bowl blank from walnut or cherry or oak.

I've turned pine, but only well dried. It's good for utility things and for practice. Some is worse than others - white pine can turn and look nice, but I haven't tried it green. When I cut virginia pine on my sawmill I have to wear gloves.

JKJ

Re: Turning pine?

#4

Re: Turning pine?

Ken

>It will PITH al over the place.Tried it once when I first started.It was nit a pretty site.It was my first and last green pine.

Re: Turning pine?

#5

Re: Turning pine?

john lucas

>Have you ever seen one of those horror movies where they find the giant spider web. That's what your shop will look like if you turn fresh cut pine. You'll think you were stuck in a cotton candy machine. Don't ask how I know that.

Re: Turning pine?

#6

Re: Turning pine?

wilbur

>So I take it that it's a bad idea? :@)

Although now I'm really tempted to do it to see what happens, just for the entertainment value. :@)

Re: Turning pine?

#7

Re: Turning pine?

wilbur

>Thanks for the offer, John, but I live in NJ, so it would be a bit of a drive. :@)

I guess I'll cut this stuff down some more and save it for flatwork. For lumber this pine is pretty nice. Very straight grained and clear. I'll probably also cut a bowl blank and let it dry for a few years.

Re: Turning pine?

#8

P.S.

wilbur

>I could wear my Woodcentral hat and turn the green pine. That would make a heck of a WC hat sightings picture, I bet!

Re: Turning pine?

#9

P.S.

wilbur

>I could wear my Woodcentral hat and turn the green pine. That would make a heck of a WC hat sightings picture, I bet!

Re: Turning pine?

#10

Re: P.S.

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Especially when you show up for work with your hat glued to your head. ;-)

Re: Turning pine?

#11

Re: Turning pine?

Russ Fairfield

>Don't believe what you hear. Nobody says anything against Norfolk Island Pine. Get that last word. "PINE". The only difference between that and most other species of Pine is the location of the knots. Other than that, most Pines turn and sand quite easilly. It can have some pretty grain. Knots can add a lot of interest (see the NIP). All Pines are translucent when turned thin and soaked in an oil finish.

So there's some shavings. Last time I looked, I got shaving from all species of wood. So there is a little pitch and oil. A lot of species are that way. Wipe the gunk off the tools with kerosene.

Turn something from it and make up your own mind. The worst that could happen is that you will get some turning practice.

Re: Turning pine?

#12

Re: Turning pine?

Lan Brady

>On our farm we have a stand of old growth southern yellow pine. The wood is almost orange in color. It is what a lot of people call heart pine. This wood turns great. It does not sling pitch and tar as others seem to. The shop smells like Pine-Sol when you get through. It finsihes great with just Danish Oil.

I did loose a lot that I had stored in the barn. Dang Roof leak!!!!

I will treasure what I have left. I still have 6 standing trees that are 24"+ at the base.

Lan

Re: Turning pine?

#13

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Turning pine?

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>Pine is great wood for turning, I really enjoy using something that many will say is a useless timber.

I have never turned Green Pine but I can imagine that all the warnings are true especially since it is so resinous.

Regards, Peter

PS 6 inch x 3 inch Pine bowl


img

Re: Turning pine?

#14

Re: Turning pine?

Carole Valentine

>I have turned some SY pine and it was a neat wood, Lan. What I had didn't sling pitch either but it was given to me so I have no idea how long it had been down. There is a Loblolly in my backyard that apparently has PBB because the woodpeckers are drilling rings around it. Everywhere they have drilled, it is just streaming sap!

Re: Turning pine?

#15

Re: And here is a piece of Scotch pine....

Jamie D

>...cut from a dead tree on the golf course. When I first cut the trunk with the spalting it looked very much like Norfolk without the branches, and the sap was mostly hardened into amber.


img

Re: Turning pine?

#16

Re: Turning pine?

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>The well-know turner from Main -- last name Lancaster turns bowls from it. I asked him about it because I, too, had heard that it's not a good idea to turn it. Lancaster said it was fine to turn. I turned some once when using it as "slave" wood as per Vic Wood. It turned beautifully.

Re: Turning pine?

#17

For those of you who do turn pine

wilbur

>Should I try turning it wet? Or cut it down into blanks and let them dry? I couldn't really get a sense for which would be better, but I'm probably just being dumb.

Re: Turning pine?

#18

Re: For those of you who do turn pine

Ed Larson

>I live in the mountains of Northern Calif and have turned a fair amount of pine, I'm in a pine forest. If you want a translucent bowl turn it wet and thin. If you want a thicker bowl, rough it out wet about 1" thick for a 10 inch bowl. Dry it in a paper bag with shavings. It's very dry here so in 2-4 weeks it is dry. I have a 12 inch pine bowl about 1/4 inch thick that is a great popcorn bowl, finished with walnut oil. The lodge pole pine here has knots like NIP and I keep meaning to more expreimenting with it. Have fun and let us know how it comes out.

Re: Turning pine?

#19

Re: Turning pine?

robert davis

>here is a scotch pine box. wood had sat in garage for about six months.as russ said go for it


img

Re: Turning pine?

#20

trying photo again 

robert davis

>


img

Re: Turning pine?

#21

Re: trying photo again

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>What a great turning! Very clever!

Re: Turning pine?

#22

Dick Hines

Re: And here is a piece of Scotch pine....

Dick Hines

>So what you all are saying is that if I can get some of he white pine that came down during to snow strom I should do it.

Re: Turning pine?

#23

Re: trying photo again

Lan Brady

>Robert,

you should post this in a new post!

It is gorgeous.

I would hate for people to not see it at the bottom of this long chain.

Great Job, Lan

Re: Turning pine?

#24

Re: And here is a piece of Scotch pine....

George Van

>Dick, white pine will be lower in resin than most of the pines. Pattern makers used it a lot for this reason and stability.