Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

CiL rougher question...

Posts

CiL rougher question...

#1

CiL rougher question...

Steven Kubien

>So, other than the tip being carbide (and replaceable), what makes this tool any different than a scraper? I've seen a few videos on youtube and that's what it looks like to me.

What am I missing?

Steve Kubien

Re: CiL rougher question...

#2

Re: CiL rougher question...

paul waddle

>Steve,I saw this demoed. It sure looks like any other scraper,but I do know that it works! The 99$ is what makes me pass. I do like the beefy rectangular section of the shaft. I thought about the CiL 2,but decided I would wait. pw

Re: CiL rougher question...

#3

Re: CiL rougher question...

john lucas

>I build heavy roughing scrapers out of 3/8" HSS tool bits and a length of 3/4" cold roll bar. It works just like that tool but costs about $10 to make. Just drill a hole in the end of the bar in insert the cutter. I drill and tap holes for set screws so you can easily sharpen the cutter. That's the biggest difference, the carbide can't be sharpened by normal stones so you have to rotate it. Based on my experience with the Hunter tools it should hold an edge for a long time.

Re: CiL rougher question...

#4

Rob Wallace

Re: CiL rougher question... *LINK*

Rob Wallace

>Steve:

Have a read of this recent thread (and debate) on the AAW Forum. Much of what information you ask about is tossed around (...and beaten-up!) in this tread....

... See also a follow-up thread at:

http://www.aawforum.org/vbforum/showthread.php?t=5822

Rob Wallace


AAW Easyrougher Thread - March 2009

Re: CiL rougher question...

#5

Re: CiL rougher question...

paul waddle

>Good job John,you're always coming up with something.

I wonder if you added a "y" as an anti turning device-like some of the less expensive hollow form tools,it wouldn't turn and you wouldn't have to "white knuckle" it...? Also,can't a person buy carbide insert bits from a die supply shop that you could make your own?? I can't handle 99$! pw

Re: CiL rougher question...

#6

Ric Taylor

Re: CiL rougher question...

Ric Taylor

>Steve,

The big difference with this tool is the amazing speed and ease with which you can rough turn a log or a blank. There is a huge difference between this tool and a traditional scraper. This is the best investment I've made in any tool in years.

Ric

Re: CiL rougher question...

#7

Re: CiL rougher question... *LINK*

Fred Holder

>Like most of you, I discounted this tool until I saw it demonstrated extensively at the Desert Woodturning Roundup. I watched him turn a bowl from a round wet blank to a final turned bowl, turning outside and inside with the CiL Rougher. I was impressed enough to purchase both the large one and the smaller version. I purchased them through Craft Supplies booth, they were giving a 10 Percent discount and free shipping.

When we returned home, they were waiting for us. I found the most awful piece of wood in the shed and mounted it poorly, i.e., not the truest mounting and went to work. The blank was approximately 10" in diameter to begin with, but I only obtained about a 5" bowl out of it. The thing was spalted and rotten, but the CiL impressed me significantly. There were no catches, it just cut away the wood. I found that a final pass with a bowl gouge gave me a better finish, but one could have started sanding with 60 grit sandpaper and finished the bowl well. This really is an excellent roughing tool.

I then tried it on a spindle, a piece of good wood, Red Birch that was dry. At 1000 rpm there was some tear out, but it roughed the wood quickly. I turned the lathe up to 3000 rpm and got a very smooth cut. Not as smooth as a skew chisel, but very smooth, ready to sand with 220 grit. I decided to try to make a goblet out of the wood. I completely turned it at 3000 rpm and only had to use an Eliminator to round out the bottom of the bowl. Otherwise the goblet was completely turned with the CiL.

Needless to say, I feel they were a good purchase. You can turn beads with it but not tight coves.


More Woodturning Website

Re: CiL rougher question...

#8

Re: CiL rougher question...

Steven Kubien

>Thanks for the link. Certainly a heated thread and that is not what I want to create here. I think I have enough to make a decision now.

Thanks everyone,

Steve

Re: CiL rougher question...

#9

Re: Ci1 rougher question...

Ron in Drums PA

>Your experience is the same as mine Fred.

Thanks for posting.

Re: CiL rougher question...

#10

Re: CiL rougher question...

robo hippy

>It is a scraper. The primative version is called the 'Big Ugly'tool and has been used for many years by the Oregon coast myrtle wood turners. This tool is a 3/4 inch by 30 or inch long piece of bar stock with a piece of Tantung steel (available from MSC or other industrial steel places) silver soldered onto each end. A heavy leather glove is worn on the left hand for protection. The Tantung can be sharpened on conventional grinders. Held flat, it is excellent for scraping cuts on bowls or spindles. Held on edge, you get excellent shear cuts. It holds an edge for a long time. The biggest difference between the Big Ugly and my bowl scrapers is that the scrapers are wider, and can take a bigger bite. Also, the scrapers don't hold an edge as long. Generally, the faster you turn, the better a Big Ugly or Easy Rougher works. As far as catches go, I would bet that I can make any tool catch. The smaller the cutting surface is, the more you can over come with leverage. A cut depth that would rip the tool out of your hands with a 1 1/2 inch scraper, won't do much with a 1/2 inch wide Big Ugly or Easy Rougher, or Oland tool.

robo hippy

Re: CiL rougher question...

#11

Re: CiL rougher question...

Rich Egan

>Fred:

Like you, I bought one after the roundup. Craft Supplies was kind enough to extend me the same deal, as they were out of unhandled tools at the show. I've been using it on some dry walnut rough-outs, and find it performs exactly as advertised. One of our local club members has one, and found you can replace the carbide with a replacement cutter meant for a spiral jointer/planer head. Fits and works fine, although you don't get the same radius as the stock cutter.

Rich Egan

Re: CiL rougher question...

#12

Re: CiL rougher question...

Eduardo sarmiento-hall

>Well seems that is the tool to get(I turn stuff that you guys never heard of so hard that turners use a metal lathe to round a piece)the edges on a tool even the expensive ones go to pieces almost in every case here) carbide saws dont last one hour on the mills here) Ill try the tool and make a report ,ed

Re: CiL rougher question...

#13

Re: CiL rougher question...

Mitchell Cholewinski

>I bought the CiL complete and at first didn't care for it and later learned to use it better so I made one myself and used the same carbide cutter. It cuts as good as the original and all it cost me is $13.99 to make my tool that took 40 minutes to drill and tap a hole for the cutter. For the guys who can't handle the price of the tool how about making one for $13,99? You won't beat that or the quality of the tool either.

Re: CiL rougher question...

#14

Lyle Jamieson

Re: CiL rougher question...

Lyle Jamieson

>Dont confuse the Hunter/Jamieson carbide cutters with the "Rougher". They are two different animals. The Rougher is just that, and does a good job roughing. Yes it is a scraper with the old style carbide. The Hunter/Jamieson carbide cutters are designed to be used on a dedicated angle to slice cleanly through the wood and they are made from the new technology carbide that gets and stays sharper.