Well, it's about time for another WoodCentral turning contest, don'tcha think? I would like some help from you to come up with a good theme. (Christmas ornaments are on my list, but tisn't the season. Maybe this fall.)
>How about pure form. Whatever the object is, it is painted flat black so that the only attribute to evaluate is form. Bowl, Hollow Forms, Platters, Candle Sticks... all evaluated together on one criteria, form.
>Since not everyone has a lathe on which to turn larger pieces, maybe some maximum size should be specified.
Since not everyone has access to, or the money to buy, rare and/or highly figured wood, perhaps readily available, relatively inexpensive more or less monochromatic wood should be specified.
In keeping with the idea of a Level Playing Field, perhaps the price of special tooling should be considered - not everyone has a swan necked hollowing tool, or a captured hollowing system - nor a compressor and a 400,000 rpms "drill" or special threading jig. Chatter tools and texturing tools? Maybe.
I assume most folks in this group have at least one scroll chuck so pieces that require a chuck to make should not be excluded (and for those who haven't got a scroll chuck - yet - this would be a great "justification" for getting one).
Then there's the question of what the contest is testing?
If it's fine tool control and technique - knitting needles are challenging.
If it's the ability to come up with a combination of pleasing curves, blended perfectly, to produce a pleasing to the eye form - maybe plates or bowls - with or without overhanging rims.
If it's crispness of details - spindles and finials come to mind.
Personally, I think lidded boxes - with finials - covers a pretty good range of skills and techniques, involving pleasant shapes, good use of tools both outside and inside, some precision (the fit of the lid), a range of chucking methods and the ability to integrate three components into a single, coherent, piece. They don't take a great deal of wood, don't require a great deal of time to turn - and EVERYTHING can be done On The Lathe.
I like turning little lidded boxes, particularly turning finials for them, so I'll cop to a personal bias.
OR
How about turned pieces - with actual movement - elements that move, or rock, or roll, or bounce, or . . .
OR
Turned pieces, "dis-assembled and re-assembled in a different, unexpected way"?
OR
A set of pieces which relate to each other and, depending on how the parts of the set are oriented to each other, can change the meaning or feeling of the set?
OR
A piece or a group of pieces based on a well known phrase - perhaps a cliche. What Truths does the phrase "We hold these truths to be self evident..." bring to mind, and can any of those thoughts be expressed using a lathe?
AND
In order to encourage everyone to play, how about beginner, intermediate, advanced and maybe a pro category?
Just throwing out some ideas (and adding some more things to my One Of These Days I'm Gonna" list).
>Thank you for the thoughtful suggestions, Charlie. Lidded boxes are an appealing theme, but since these are online contests, we need to rely on good photographs to show us the quality of the work. We can't test the fit of a lid through a photograph, so if we do lidded boxes, we might want to have the winners send their entries to the judges so we can confirm that they are everything they appear to be in the photos. That's a bit cumbersome, but it has been done before, as with our Toolmaking Contest of a year ago.
The level playing field is a good concept to keep in mind. Let's see what others have to suggest....
>Rather than picking a limited topic like bowls or hollowforms, why not pick some kind of an esoteric topic like "turned for use" or "spirit of the southwest" and see what happens?
My nomination for the topic is "Turned in an Hour"- where the entire process can only take one hour start to finish.
>I know every turner is one tool away from greatness and the whole purpose of turning is to buy every one of them until greatness arrives, but what about a turning that requires and uses only one tool?
Or a Skew Contest. Turned right off the skew, without sanding. No, not that, I don't have a chance.
>How about "Flat to Round" with work pieces that start out as flat boards and end up as something off the lathe? Could be segmented, could be layered, could be a bunch of dishes assembled somehow into a final piece.
>I almost mentioned the turned for use category. I probably use my lathe more for useful things (mostly around the farm) as I do otherwise - tool (e.g. shovel) handles, stuff dispensers, repair parts, hydraulic connector plugs for the tractor, etc. Even more if you count household things.
In fact, I should offer my own contest - I turned two pairs of extremely useful things recently that I defy anyone to guess their purpose! They have something to do with baby animals. I have a picture here somewhere...
>What about woodturning jigs? Could be sharpening or lathe related. And if we pulled all the submittals together, it might make a good basis for an article for the web site or even American Woodturner.