I can get either type of steel sharper on the Tormek than I can the conventional grinder. Just look at the edge under a microscope. The Tormek wheel is much finer than my finest 8" wheel (80 grit), and on top of that I usually finish the Tormek edge with a touch of the leather honing wheel.
I don't notice a difference in the initial sharpness of M2 vs either the Crown or Thompson powder metal tools I use (although the Thompson STAYS sharper longer). However, a small difference in relative sharpness is hard for me to judge - perhaps test somehow, say with a piece of paper like we test a knife sharpness?
>I agree with John on the actual cutting test. When I first got the thompson tools I did considerable testing on sharpness and it did seem that my M2 tools would get sharper. So my initial thoughts were that I would use the thompson's to get it down to the final shape and then use the M2 to clean it up. This didn't last long because the Thompson tools just seem to work wonderfully. You can tell a difference when you first make cuts with both tools but I'm guessing the M2 dulls to the same sharpeness as the thompson almost immediately and the Thompson on the other hand just keeps on cutting.
Now I use the Thompson's entirely, rarely changing to another tool. They are sharp enough to give me clean cuts 99 percent of the time. When I have trouble in an area I reach for a tool that has been sharpened to a steeper angle or I lubricate the area with paste wax. If I grab another tool it is either my Henry Taylor M2 sharpened to a 40 degree Stewart Batty grind, or my Thompson detail gouge sharpened to a 40 degrees. Both give the same quality of finished cut.
I sharpen on a 100 grit white wheel dry grinder. I have a Sheppach wet wheel grinder and it does get tools sharper but but I can't see that it has solved any problems with my turning tools so I don't use it for that. I save it for Plane blades and carving tools. I don't have to wait for the water to soak in the wheels or remove the water at the end of the day so it won't freeze overnight, etc. Just too much hassle for turning tools.
>You're right about the hassle of using water. People talk about how slow it is to sharpen with the Tormek and I don't find that true, but I guess it is if you have to prep each time.
I prefer the Tormek edge so I generally wait until I have a number of gouges that need sharpening and sharpen them all at once. This is one advantage I see to having more than one identical or nearly identical gouge of each type. (The bigger advantage is not having to stop for sharpening at all, by any method - just grab another gouge!) Multiple gouges and diamond honing can really stretch out the time between Tormek sessions.
I use the standard grinder for quick sharpening if needed while working, reshaping, most scrapers, and the larger skews (which can be a real pain on the Tormek).
But I forgot you said once that your shop gets below freezing at times. Yikes! Working in an attached garage, that's something I never think about. It gets pretty cold at times, but never freezes.
>... I have concluded that all tool alloys more exotic than M2 requires some honing to achieve the same relative edge sharpness possible with M2. I have tools made of M4,2030,2060, Thompson A11, and I sharpen on a well tuned slow speed grinder(Baldor) with 120 grit wheel. All will have a good working edge from the 120 wheel, but when a precision cut requires a really sharp tool I hand hone with a ceramic rod or diamond flat to get the best edge sharpness possible. The harder alloys will hold a sharp edge longer than the M2, especially with abrasive woods, but the less exotic carbon steel tools can be sharpened to a keener edge with less special effort. But for most of my regular turning I sure like the Oneway Mastercut M4 and Thompson A11 tools straight from the 120 wheel! Sweeeet!!
>My first experience with a 'lasts 4 times longer' gouge was one from Packard. I had been using a M2 Ellsworth gouge at the time. I used the new one for a couple of months exclusively. On a whim one day, I went back to the M2. It had a noticably keener edge. If I switch back and forth on a daily basis, I don't really notice it. I do use a 150 grit wheel for gouges, but do sharpen on an 80 grit wheel some times. I really can't tell the difference. A diamond hone on the edge does seem to make it cut a bit differently, and the difference is more if you hone off the burr on the inside of the flutes, but is minimal. With most steels, the fresh off the grinder edge only lasts a few seconds. The main difference is in how long a useable edge lasts. The Thompson is the best in this category, and it's fresh off the grinder edge does last longer than any other tool I have used.
Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f
Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f
Guest
Re:Over an extended period of turning time .
Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f
>I agree with Jamie. I find that sharpening the Thompson tools on a 180 grit wheel gives me a super sharp edge -- and because of the quality of the steel, this "scary edge" will actually stay in place and not break off.