>I have read posts here (even some from our most experienced turners and finishers) that advocate wet sanding with various mediums, mostly oils, and the practice is an accepted method of filling pores and leveling a surface for finishing. My own experience with making a slurry, even when wiped off with the excess finish, dictates that I do not do that anymore. The reason? Light wood slurry is deposited in dark wood pores, and dark wood slurry is deposited in light wood pores and SOME contrast is invariably lost.
If I would do a good enough job of wiping that there would not be any discoloration, I would be defeating my purpose by removing the wood filler that I have made.
I WILL use oil to wet-sand, but only after many coats of sealer or finish have been applied and dried...NEVER on bare wood. I suppose if sealing pores were the only objective, it would be fine, but if ones cares how the piece will look, one would just say no. No Slurry for me, thanks.
>Right, Barb. I never do it on pieces that have light and dark wood. In fact I only use it on very dark woods like walnut with no sapwood. I don't wet sand light woods like oak.
>I even wet sand anymore. I sued to do it but my lathe was begening to look a tank of burned motor oil had been dumped over it. IT worked OK but sure was a mess. If there is amything I don't need in the shop is another mess.
>To me wet sanding is a final finish procedure. Therefore all wet sanding is done off the lathe. On turned projects I only wet sand after I have applies several layers of finish. Consequently bleed over of colors is not a problem and the project is in my hands instead of the lathe so the mess is not a problem.
When I have done things to the turning that require water or other liquid that will be messy I simply put a towel across the ways and work that way. I guess I'm kind of a clean freak although I fail at that fairly often. I at least shoot for the clean thing as much as possible.
>When I wet sand it is after the second coat and off the lathe. I used to put a empty dog food bag over the ways when doing something messy. Now I use a neat piece of metal Carole gave me.
>I've found (at least with air dried black walnut, and bubinga) that wet sanding muddies the grain. It doesn't happen with kiln dried because the grain is already muddied. By muddied I mean that the deep darks are lightened and the lighter shades are darkened. There IS a fair amount of contrast lost.
>I guess I stand alone on this subject. I do wet sand, on the lathe, with Danish oil. BUT the difference may be that I am making mostly handles which are spindle oriented and are split stock, not cut. Maybe this extremely straight grain orientation helps? The woods I use are Hickory, Walnut, Mahogany, and Maple. I obviously am not going for the glass smooth look. The handle in my Froe is 3 years old. It has been left outside(by accident) on occasion, but still looks and works fine.
>Each time this or a similar topic comes up I wonder if there is a fire hazard when wet sanding with oil. I'm very careful about taking oil soaked rags out of the shop and placing them in a small sealed trash can. This is to prevent the possibility of spontaneous combustion.
My concern about wet sanding with oil is the oil mixing in with shavings. I'm not sure but it seems like this would be the same as leaving an oil soaked rag laying on the lathe. I guess this wouldn't be an issue if everything was cleaned prior to the sanding.
>Yeah, I use the metal side of an old computer. It makes a large shallow tray. I think that's what I gave Barb. You can put a couple of magnets on it but I don't bother. It stays put.
>That's why I use the tray. It catches any drips and keeps finish off the lathe and out of shavings. I use paper towels and they always go outside in a metal can or are opened out and draped across a rail to dry.
>I do a lot of my finishing on the lathe. When I do, I lay newspaper on the bed and some of the headstock. I'm not a neatfreak but I hate the look of crappy looking machines in my shop.
>I think everyone is trying to make much adoo about nothing when it comes to the "slurry". The slurry is not universally good for all wood, and it can be bad for some species. The sanding slurry is good for furniture because it is all flat grain. It can be bad for turned wood where there is mostly end brain, like in a bowl. A slurry is not a good idea for a light wood because there will be discoloration. It can be used to good advantage on a dark wood.
I think that too many expect the sanding slurry to cover up sanding scratchesm torn grain, and bruising from turning tools rubbing on the wood. It won't.
I use wetsanding with a finishing oil because there are many other benefits that are more important than filling the grain with a slurry. I use wet-sanding as a way to get a smoother surface on the wood with finer abrasive grits. I also wet-sand because oil finishes like to be rubbed, and they are the better for it. The rubbing generates some low level heat, and that helps polymerize the oils, it is a more durable finish, and there is a shorter wait until the next coat.
We are always on shaky ground when we use fillers and sealers. Anything that is opaque will muddy the wood grain when it is used to excess and is not removed from the surface. Used to excess the slurry can muddy the wood grain because it is opaque, just as leaving a filler or sanding sealer will muddy the grain when it is left on the surface because it is opaque. We want the slurry IN the wood, not ON the wood. If there are no openings in the wood for the slurry to go into, then it shouldn't be used.
The secret to using a slurry is to wipe it all off from the surface, and always buff with steel wool before applying the next coat. When the directions say "wipe dry" it means WIPE DRY, and then wipe it dry again. There is a universal tendency to think that leaving a wet surface is better. It isn't.
Walnut has been mentioned as a slurry problem, but the truth is that walnut will always be the most difficult species to finish. It is a fact that oil finishes can have a muddy appearance on end-grain Walnut, and that has nothing to do with a slurry. This is easpecially true for our bowls that show mostly end-grain. That is why I always seal the grain with lacquer before applying an oil finish.
>My oil rag clothes is a length of smooth wire strung between two trees and clothes pins dedicated to it. Other wise I chase the darned things after the wind.
>I recently watched Ray Key's DVD on turning lidded boxes. He uses a paste wax as a lubricant when sanding, not so much for creating a slurry to fill grain, but rather to reduce heat generation that can cause surface checking.
Would have other benefits - keep sawdust from getting into the air - without oil splashing all over the place.
Still would have the problem of dark sawdust getting into light areas and light into dark.