>Was stumbling around on YouTube. A guy had a Walnut bowl blank that split. He sawed the blank in half and cut out the split. Glued in a layer of Cherry. Then decided to turn the bowl about ninety degrees and do it again. So, he has a blank that is cut into four quarters with an X of dissimilar wood in it. The bowl appeared to be about 12" in diameter and 5" deep. The finished bowl appeared to be about 3/8 to 7/16" thick. My question. Isn't that glue joint prone to fail over time? It's fairly long and at least some of it must be cross grain.
I would post the URL on You Tube, but they hide it from me when I went back to get it.
>Weakest joint is end grain to end grain. Next is end to flat. Strongest is flat to flat. As long as either the wood coefficients are similar or the wood is not subjected to extremes of humidity & temperature change he will probably be alright.
>It will probably last a long time but I think it would eventually fail. The side grain to side grain will hold up pretty well. The cuts across the grain will probably have problems because he probably used a side grain board for the contrasting wood. Consequently you have side grain to end grain glue joint.
This may not be as bad as if you mitered 4 pieces of wood and put a contrasting piece inbetween. The reason I say that is when you miter 4 pieces the grain usually runs sort of in a circle if you just cut 4 pieces from a flat board. This circle will try to get bigger and smaller with the seasons and cause problems. They way he probably did his bowl the bowl wood probably all has the grain running the same direction so the wood movement here won't be quite as bad.
Then there is the shape. A bowl without a flat bottom will tend to elongate or flatten with the seasons. This puts less stress on the joints than a platter which moves out and in. At least that's been my experience.
If you follow Malcom Tibbets advice the grain should run the same direction in all the pieces if you want a piece to really last.
I did everything wrong when I first started doing segmented pieces and I've only been able to keep track of a half dozen or so. I've only had 2 of those fail. One failed in the bottom of a large goblet. The wood was pie shaped, bad move. Make these out of homemade plywood if you don't want them to open up. The other was a segmented platter with a solid wood rim. The rim would open up during the wet seasons and close up during the winter. Solid wood moves differently than segmented wood. I now make the rim segmented also.