Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Which chuck to get?

Posts

Which chuck to get?

#1

Which chuck to get?

Herb Flower

>Hello all,

Here's a question from a long-time lurker. I have recently acquired a small General International lathe (10" swing with a 1" x 8 tpi spindle).

My good friend has recently refurbished an old Oliver Model #51 (12" swing with 1 1/4" spindle).

Considering the potential of these lathes, what chuck(s) would you folks view as a "good/best" match for the two machines?

We're also a little unclear as to the need for adapters in setting up such chucks?

Looking forward to your thoughts.

Regards,

HJF

Re: Which chuck to get?

#2

Re: Which chuck to get?

Al Neighbors

>Man, you've opened a can of worms. :) Get ready to be bombarded with suggestions. 'Course, that's the nice thing about this forum. :o)

I'll start my suggestions.

For the small lathe, I suggest a Nova Midi Chuck w/ 1X8 adapter. The adapter will screw into the chuck, and then onto the spindle of the lathe.

For the larger lathe, I suggest the SuperNova 2 Chuck w/1 1/4 x (appropriate threads per inch) Adapter.

The SuperNova2 Chuck will accept all of Nova's jaws, except the Titan Powergrip Jaws. The convenience of it, is exceptional.

I have 4 Nova Chucks... all of them are superb.

Re: Which chuck to get?

#3

Re: Which chuck to get?

John K Jordan

>Herb,

Seems to me that "which chuck" is a bit like "which lathe" - there is more than one good choice and recommendations are usually for the chuck that person has. This means to me that nearly any will do the job!

Since the lathes you mention are not monsters, an extremely heavy-duty chuck may not be needed. I get very good use from the Supernova and Supernova II chucks. I think I have 11 or 12 now (I like to have one for each set of jaws and a couple of duplicates for my most used jaws.)

The adapters, at least for the Supernovas, are threaded inserts made to match your lathe spindle. To switch the chuck between the two lathes, you would have to buy two inserts and swap them each time. This is easy to do - just remove a set screw or two and unscrew the insert. It would be a lot easier, however, to have a separate chuck for each lathe.

The cost of a chuck isn't too bad if you catch it on sale. Woodcraft has these sales on occasion. I've also bought some chucks used. If you do this, check for smooth operation - I spent a 1/2 day reworking one that was distorted from overtightening by the incredible hulk.

JKJ

Re: Which chuck to get?

#4

Re: Which chuck to get?

BobP

>Herb,

As John mentioned we all seem to have a favorite chuck and probably think our choice was the best. There are now many good lathe chucks on the market with those from Teknatool (Super Nova etc.) and Oneway (Stronghold and Talon) being some of the most popular. When making your choice consider the various jaws that are provided by the manufacturer of the chuck you choose.

Regarding the two lathes and their differing spindle sizes...I have a similar situation with my Jet mini lathe (1X8) and my Powermatic (1-1/4X8). I use a Teknatool Supernova chuck on both of these lathes (older chuck). It is fitted with the 1X8 insert and mates up with the Jet as-is. When I want to use it on the Powermatic I use a spindle adapter on the Powermatic. The adapter fits on the 1-1/4 spindle and presents a 1X8 thread for the chuck. I find this a lot more convenioent than changing the threaded insert on the chuck. The spindle adapter does not cost that much more than another threaded insert for the chuck. I believe the dapters are available from Penn State Industries for a reasonable price. The Supernova chuck (and the Talon) are light enough to work well with the smaller lathes. I typically use an Axminster chuck on the Poermatic. The Axminster chuck is way too heavy for the Jet mini.

Well, that is how I handled the situation. I like my Supernova chuck and have been pleased with the selection of jaws available for it. The price was pretty good as well.

Hope this helps somewhat.

BobP

Re: Which chuck to get?

#5

Re: Which chuck to get?

John Jordan

>The Oliver may not be 1-1/4 x 8, so check it carefully.

John

Re: Which chuck to get?

#6

Re: Which chuck to get?

Eduardo sarmiento-hall

>Just got my supernova2 chuck and is really a pleasure to work with it,(precision chuck by sorbys for 20 years and served a heavy duty work no failures ,only problem is to disaseble every time to change for compresion duty and the jaws with rubber bands drove me cracy I turn dayly so it was a hassle,the nova did not come cheap to me,$175 chuck $100 extra jaws,$90 shipping(lima peru)import duty$180,fedex $50 extra around $600 hundred bucks counting gas etc,so no matter what you guys paid is really cheap in the usa,and to top that here turning are not apreciated,here you get a set of bowls for 20 bucks tools here are 5 times more than usa and the turnings are 10 times or more cheap than the usa,cracy no?

for me to make something is really expensive and have to charge next to nothing for it, luky I make a living from my shops I rent my 2cents

Re: Which chuck to get?

#7

Re: Which chuck to get?

Ed Pretty

>Hi Herb,

Just read all of the thread in response to your question and all seem to have valid information. The comment I would make will get some flack from the Super Nova fans but I have to pass this on. I was recently convinced to get the Super Nova chucks despite my concern for inconsistent quality of their products - sometimes good but sometimes not so good. I bought a new-in-the-box from a friend and a new one from the dealer so I could have two permanent set-ups. Both chucks ran out laterally and radially by several thousandths of and inch (up to 0.010"). That doesn't sound like much but it was impossible to rechuck and not have serious run out both laterally and radially - even on small bowls. The greater the diameter the worse the problem obviously.

After much measuring with a dial indicator I narrowed the problem down to the jaw slides. The local dealer and Teknatool were very good about helping me deal with the problem, but in the end I had to ship both bodies to the tech support center in either Tennessee or Kentucky (sorry, bad memory)and was sent reconditioned bodies.

I was dismayed to find that Teknatool now outsources to a Chinese factory. I could have bought a Chinese knock off for half the price and I'd put serious money on the fact that they came from the same factory. To Teknatool's credit, I wouldn't have gotten the same service, however.

The chucks run fine now and I had good service, but I wouldn't go that route again. I would get the Oneway that I now have and save the trip. I still stand by my claim that the quality of Teknatool products is inconsistent.

Re: Which chuck to get?

#8

Bill Blasic

Re: Which chuck to get?

Bill Blasic

>Herb,

The other side of the coin is that I have 9 Nova chucks, 2 made in China and the others in New Zealand. The only problem that I ran across was with two New Zealand chucks. I tested the Chinese version of the SN2 against a New Zealand version and found them to be exactly the same as far as anything on them I could compare and that includes runout(as it should be because they moved the machine that does them to China). Another option would be the G3 as it would work well with either lathe by changing the inserts and is well within the swing range of the two. Myself I use the Precision Midi's on the midi lathe and just got an original Nova midi for the smaller lathe. These are tommy bar chucks and they are 1" X 8 direct threaded. Some folks do not care for tommy bars but they work well for me.

Re: Which chuck to get?

#9

Rob Wallace

Which chuck? - My recommendation - Vicmarc

Rob Wallace

>Herb:

Just another opinion from a long time user (of these chucks!).....

I'll put-in a vote of support for Vicmarc chucks - the specific recommendation here being a 3-1/2" capacity Vicmarc VM100 chuck, with two threaded inserts (as someone mentioned, be sure the Oliver spindle threading has been confirmed) for both of your spindle sizes.

I own four Vicmarc chucks (3 of the VM 100, and one VM120) - I have never been disappointed in them and neither will you - highest quality and very well designed. The hex key tightening system, in my opinion, is easier to use than the systems requiring the user to seat a geared wrench into the chuck tightening hole....a bit more time efficient, perhaps. Having used both, I prefer the Vicmarc design. (Full range of jaw styles available, etc. as in other brands.)

Good luck in your decision making process.

Rob Wallace

Re: Which chuck to get?

#10

I agree with Rob!

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>I have several Vicmarc chucks and some Talon chucks. The Vicmarcs are my "Go To" chucks because they are more precise in general. I much prefer using the hex keys rather than a geared key.

Ed

Re: Which chuck to get?

#11

Re: Which chuck to get?

bowlman

>I have a 3 chucks: Nova Chuck (early model), Oneway Stronghold, and a Oneway small (not Talon). If I were to add another chuck and money were no object, I'd opt for the Axminster with a full compliment of jaws. Second to that would be the Oneway Talon, the Vicmarc 5 1/2 inch model and/or SuperNova2. With the Oneway line of chucks, I have never had a problem with fit and finish and zero runout, si I highly recommend them. As to the Axminster: I had the opportunity to try one out at a fellow turner's shop and all I can is WOW! Pretty much the Rolls Royce Silver Shadow of chucks. Of course he had ALL the available jaws, all neatly housed in a custom made custom fitted box. I know its beyong my budget, but if I ever hit the lottery .... well you get the picture ...

With any chuck, if there is a problem, immediately contact the seller/maker and arrange for a replacement. Don't take any guff. They know that an unhappy customer costs more than a replacement. And the Chinese machined stuff is improving dramatically in quality. Also, don't forget to check your own lathe spindles for runout. I have seen a few that were unacceptable. Otherw were just plain loaded with gung and that caused the chuck to not seat properly.

AMy any event, good luck with choice whatever it may be.

Re: Which chuck to get?

#12

JL

Re: Which chuck to get?

JL

>I have a Oneway Stronghold. I also have a smaller Oneway chuck with "tommy bars". They are good chucks. If I were to get a small Oneway, I'd get the Talon and if I were to get a larger Oneway, it would be the Stronghold.

However, if I were to get another chuck, I'd probably get a Vicmarc.

Re: Which chuck to get?

#13

ebd

Re: Which chuck to get?

ebd

>I've got three Axminster chucks and I am more than extremely happy with them. I would like to get one more chuck body so that I can keep all of the jaws that I regularly use mounted. I did get jaw slides for every set of jaws that I have so it's not a problem, I'm just lazy. I will say if you go the Axminster route, plan on ordering from England. As far as I know they are no longer carried by any US supplier. Craft Supplies still has some of their jaw sets available but I think they are phasing Axminster out.

Re: Which chuck to get?

#14

Mike Stafford

Re: Which chuck to get?

Mike Stafford

>I have a Nova chuck, a Super Nova, several Super Nova II's, two Axminsters and two Vicmarcs.

They all work fine for me. The Nova chucks have one advantage over the Vicmarc and Oneway chucks in that all their jaws will fit all the other models by the same company except for the little Nova Compac. I have two different models of the Axminster and all the jaws I have are interchangeable from one chuck to the other.

The only difference I see in any of them is the direction you turn the handle to tighten or loosen the jaws. They all work.

Re: Which chuck to get?

#15

Re: Which chuck to get? *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

>I have several pages on lathe chucks on my Website. It won't tell you which one to buy, but it might help you make the decision.


http://www.woodturner-russ.com/Chucks.html

Re: Which chuck to get?

#16

Re: Which chuck to get?

Roy Girolami------WebKitFormBoundarywFn+9eH9wAEIGq

>One thing to note. I had a Vicmarc chuck and had trouble with it rusting. The oneways I have now have no rusting evident. They are in the same environment.

Roy Girolami

Apex, NC

Re: Which chuck to get?

#17

rechucking

John K Jordan

>> ...it was impossible to rechuck...

I don't know if you do this for rechucking, but if not, it's worth a try: before removing the piece, mark it's position so the same jaws can be put back into the indentations compressed into the wood. I draw lines on the tenon and make an 'X' between jaws #1 and #4. (Of course, if the jaws are removed and replaced, make sure they are on the correct slides.) When rechucking, try to tighten with the same force as the first time. I've seen others use this method as well.

If the jaws fit into the same indentations exactly, you will rechuck as well as possible with any chuck, runout or not. (even chucks with no detectable runout sometimes have jaws cut with slight deviations) Even a chuck with horrible runout will rechuck properly. But if I don't mark the jaw position, I can't rechuck without a lot of trial and error (tighten-check-rotate-retighten-recheck...)

Of course, bets are off with spongy (spalted) wood! Hardening the tenon win CA before the first mounting helps.

JKJ

Re: Which chuck to get?

#18

Re: Which chuck to get?

John Peck

>Another vote for Vicmarc chucks (and I have all 3 major brands: Vicmarc, Nova, and Oneway chuck). Vicmarc chucks are now nickel-plated so there is no longer a rust problem with them.

Re: Which chuck to get?

#19

Mike Stafford

Re: rechucking

Mike Stafford

>On hard wood it is fairly easy to rechuck if you mark a couple of jaw positions as John suggests. I do it fairly frequently and as long as I am careful I don't have any problems with concentricity of the piece.

I don't want to do it but if you're careful it can be done.

Re: Which chuck to get?

#20

Re: Which chuck to get?

Russ Fairfield

>There was an error in the Vicmark information. It has been corrected. Thanks, Ed, for reading it and pointing out my error.

Re: Which chuck to get?

#21

Re: Which chuck to get?

Herb Flower

>Hello Again,

Thanks to all for your informative responses. They have made a first interaction with the forum most enjoyable, and again demonstrate the range of knowledge and experience of this readership.

I did check the Oliver spindle size and did have it wrong. (Thanks for that also.)

Again, thanks to all.

HJF

Re: Which chuck to get?

#22

Re: rechucking

john lucas

>I do the same as John except I mark the X so that all 4 end have roughly the same type of grain. for example if the grain runs perfectly horizontal I will draw the x from corner to corner so the jaws are compressing end grain on one side and side grain on the other. That way all 4 jaws deform the wood about the same amount. doesn't always work, wood is wood and won't always compress equally.

Re: Which chuck to get?

#23

Re: Which chuck to get?

Jim B

>I'm suprised no one mentioned the Barracuda from PSI. I've used it for over a year on bottle stoppers to peppermills on my Jet Mini without an issue. At about $140 with 4 sets of jaws, a MT1 adapter and spare set of attachments screws...it's a great choice.

Re: Which chuck to get?

#24

Re: Which chuck to get? *LINK*

Fred Holder

>I have about a dozen Nova chucks ranging from their smallest one to their largest, they are all good chucks. I also have a couple of the smaller Vicmarc chucks which are also excellent. Recently, I purchased one of the Vermec chucks, which is a good size healthy chuck that supposedly will accept all of the Vicmarc and Nova Chuck jaws. I haven't yet tried any other jaws on it because I like the jaws that came with the chuck. Vermec is also from Australia.

I would say Nova, Vicmarc, Vermec, and OneWay are all chucks that you can't go wrong in purchasing.

I got my first Nova chuck in about 1990 and a second one the next year. Since then I've purchased one or more of each of the new Nova chuck introductions. I guess you could say that I like Nova chucks.


More Woodturning Website

Re: Which chuck to get?

#25

Re: rechucking

Ed Pretty

>Noting some responses to "rechucking with Teknatool chucks".

I was not refering to removing and replacing work in the same numbered jaw marks, but rather changing ends after first mounting on the screw chuck to turn the spigot. The spigot was never concentric nor parallel, therefore any prior shaping had to be redone. That's no real biggy unless the shape was critical at that stage or you were short of material. Changing ends to finish turn the foot caused the same problem - again. The problem was compounded with platters.

The problem is definitely in the chuck and in the jaw slides specifically. The spindle ran out 0.0005 - half a thou'. That's not uncommon. The chuck/spindle seating was checked as well as the adaptor/chuck seating and both were clean and firmly seated. I spoke with a friend last night who had the same chuck and learned that he had accepted that the wobble was "just the way they were". Now that he knows how a real chuck performs he is very upset with all the struggling he has put up with.

My point: if you get a Teknatool chuck, make sure you check the runout of the jaw slides immediately and return if they are out. Better yet, get a Vicmarc or Oneway in the first place.

Ed