Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

Posts

Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

#1

Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

paul waddle

>Now I'm not saying,but I know a person who uses a hacksaw to make cut offs instead of a parting tool. Is she comitting an unpardonable sin in the ranks of turners? She says it makes grain matchups better. Have youall every heard of such??pw

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

#2

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

robo hippy

>What is she using it on? I can't imagine a hack saw doing a narrower job of parting than a thin parting tool. It will be more prone to wandering and binding in the cut, and yes, I have tried it. If the grain allignment is meaning for boxes, the best way to get grain to line up is to use the straightest grained woods possible, as in a piece you split off with an axe. If it angled at all through the piece, your grain won't match, no matter how thin of a kerf/cut you make.

robo hippy

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

#3

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

David Walser

>I've been doing this for years -- so long ago I don't know if it's an idea I came up with myself or stole it from someone else. One of the demonstrators at the DWR used a hacksaw for parting off the top of a box. He explained that it was quicker, left a better surface, and used up less wood than using a parting tool. For safety, he stressed using a quality hacksaw frame.

He also swore us all to secrecy, so I can't mention his name. I will say he sports a beard, is known for his skew work, stresses honing turning tools, lives in the upper Midwest, and his wife has something to do with the AAW...

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

#4

I've seen Alan Lacer do it.

James McClure

>It worked great. He used a nice heavy framed hacksaw and ran the lathe at pretty low RPMs. I think he ran the lathe in reverse too.

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

#5

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

Rick Allen

>I have seen a guy use a butter knife he got at a yard sale for this purpose. He ground the nose to a profile he like for a parting tool and it gave him a very narrow curf cut.

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

#6

Steven Antonucci

Try an Xacto Razor saw

steve antonucci

>Probably good for a 2" parting cut. Run the lathe slowly and clear the blade or it'll smoke like a beast...

S

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

#7

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

bill Crommett

>For thin kerf parting I use a piece of a band saw blade from a band saw saw mill mounted in a good hardwood handle. Anyone need a piece to try ?

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

#8

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

john lucas

>I never use a saw under power on the lathe. If it binds at all it ruins the project. At higher speeds it burns the wood. I did it early on until I learned better.

I find the best thing is a thin parting tool. I have made them from paring knifes, Cheap drywall saws, and commercial bandsaw blade pieces. What I like about these is that you can make the first cut about 3/8" deep and then you can use the same slot but aim the blade left and right each time you pull it out. This gives clearance for the blade on the inside so it doesn't bind but still leaves a very thin kerf for your boxes.

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

#9

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

paul waddle

>Looks like its pretty evenly devided,so I assume its ok. I will tell HER.. he he. pw.

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

#10

Re: Hacksaw works just fine at slow....

Jamie D

>...speeds, as long as you finish the cut with the lathe stopped. Won't cut with the lathe reversed unless you also reverse the saw, so nothing gained but an awkward situation.

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

#11

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

Al Neighbors

>I've used a hacksaw blade for years, off and on. It works. I use it on a pull cut, lathe reversed, starting at the top, cutting down.

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

#12

ebd

Re: Hacksaw instead of a parting tool?

ebd

>I sometimes use a dovetail saw. It probably has less of a tendancy to wander, is easier to get lined up square, and the teeth face the right way to cut (on the push stroke). Unless the hacksaw blade is mounted backwards I would imagine it wouldn't cut very well and would generate a lot of heat (hacksaws cut on the pull stroke).