>How can I overcome,or do differently to fill the pores in walnut and porous woods to prevent the opaqueness caused by wood filler.Trying to upgrade the finish on my ringboxes,I started using a wood filler. I now get an excellent smoothness,but sacrifice the clarity of the wood. Currently I'm using Famowood filler(Wood Craft) walnut color. I hope I won't need to fill up the pores with several coats of top finish. What if I buff the boxes-won't that dull the natural wood look?pw
I have no answers to your problem but sure would like to read replies you get. I have turned some walnut boxes and have yet to be happy with the finished outcome. Two types of sanding sealer but did not try wood fillers. Used wipe on poly, lacquer and oil finishes but none look good. Buffing did nothing for mine.
Only walnut I ever got a good finish on was a coffee table YEARS ago so don't even remember what I did.
>Barb,this is what I'm trying to avoid. Next I'm going to give part a shellac coating,then use pore sealer and see if that clears things up. I may run into a problem getting the sealer to adhere? pw
>Paul I haven't used that wood filler but most fillers should be sanded back to the point that the fillers only full the pores. They shouldn't add color the rest of the piece. I suspect it might be the dye they put in the filler. I have problems when I use contrasting colors to fill the pores. The colors in these fillers will change the color of the wood.
The easiest filler that I have found for Walnut is Birchwood Casey's True Oil. It is just a thick building varnish I believe. You apply a layer let it dry overnight and then steel wool it down until all you see glossy are the pores. Do this each day for about 6 to 10 coats. When you steel wool the piece and there aren't any glossy areas left apply one more coat and your done. Let it dry for several days and then buff it lightly. It's easy to burn through the finish if your aggressive or use high speed. I find this finish very easy to use and gives a beautiful color to walnut. I've finished several turned pieces and quite a few gunstocks. It's just about fool proof but does take patience. I just put a coat on each day the first thing when I walk in the shop. That way it doesn't seem like such a chore.
I've used water based poly finishes to do the same thing. They dry in about an hour or more and can be sanded back. It takes quite a few layers to fill the pores but since they dry so fast you can put on 4 or 5 layers in a day. You will have to wait a week or more to buff or rub it out with pumice because it takes a long time to harden.
I have done the same thing with spray lacquer. It takes multiple coats. My spray gun and my skills and where I spray aren't very good in this area so I spend a lot of time correcting errors like orange peel or runs. I don't do many pieces that need this level of gloss so I just put up with it for now. I'm getting better all time and eventually may be able to do a glass finish in just a few days instead of a week or more.
I have filled pores with shoe polish but the coloring changes the other part of the wood. I put a layer of shellac over it to seal it before I apply other finishes.
I have used Durham's powedered wood putty. I mix analine dyes with it to color it and make it to the consistency of toothpaste. It usually takes 2 or 3 applications to get a really smooth surface. It is water based and will raise the grain so I often raise the grain on the piece and sand back before I fill with this.
I haven't tried the commercial fillers because I don't do enough of this to justify buying them.
Proper finishing takes time and patience. If you want the best you have to get yourself in that frame of mind and just go for it.
>Paul, you have gotten some good advice from turners who are very experienced and they know of which they speak. I don't have much experience with walnut but it seems to me that you are in a hurry. As has been stated, you can't rush nature. Practice and experiment to learn what will work best for you. Many of the people who will offer advice on walnut have been doing this for many, many years and those of us who have tried their methods usually have success. Good Luck and keep turnin' and learnin'!
>Paul that may work if you are having carryover color. That is the color that is not in the pores. Sealing the wood first stops the color from the wax from carrying over so only the color of the wax fills the pores.
You can also mix shellac to a thicker cut so it will fill the pores faster but you still have to sand or steel wool it down to so that it only fills the pores.
I'm open to faster ways of filling the pores because I have a furniture project coming up that may need that. The client and I are still discussing the finish. I may break down and buy commercial wood filler for this project and try it out. I will be testing it on scrap of course.
>Barb's advice is good...wet sanding with an oil for a deep, smooth finish. It has to have time for the slurry that accumulates and fills the pores to dry completely between coats. Patience is a must when finishing walnut.
>I used to finish all my furniture that way. 600 grit and and oil slurry. It gives a very nice natural look and wonderful feel. It does fill the pores to some extent but if you want a glossy glass like finish I think you have to go further.
>Thanks for all the responses,but don't see a magic recipe.
What do the bowl turners do? I know they buff with at least 3 grits. Do they just wax the final coat or rub some oil?
I would like to buy a small amt of violin varnish if some one will sell me some for a trial. The smallest amt adverstised, is 34$qt!
I've used True Oil,its fine but still too slow. Do the gel type polys dry hard enough to really get on it with the buffing wheel without burn through? Should I be looking at the spraying lacquers ? I want smootheness,but desire clarity of grain ober alles. Oh well,guess I will waddle along with oils and sanding for now,but I would have thought with all the chemical advances,would have provided an easier solution.pw
>I think you will find that most of us turn bowls as well as many other things. For a regular bowl that probably will see use, I don't spend a great deal of time trying for that exceptional finish.
One trick I have found since I don't like the mess of wet sanding is to lightly sand the dry oil with 600 grit paper. I do not wipe off the residue and then put another coat of oil on. I repeat until the surface is where I want it to be. Buffing followed by the application of Renaissance Wax gives a wonderful glow which shows off the wood very nicely.
>Way back in the 50's when the NRA was selling Springfield rifles for $15 I got into gunstock making as a sideline. Nearly all of the stocks were walnut. I finished them with a partly linseed oil finish called Linspeed. I oiled and wet sanded until the pores were level full. Some took as many as 14 coats. A long process. One day it occured to me that oil sanding might work on my woodturning....that's when I learned about wet sanding. Been doing it ever since.
Many good responses here, but probably no magic bullet for this question.
Ring boxes expose a lot of end grain, and Walnut is a porous wood, so you have a greater challenge than with a fine grained species.
I've oiled, and wet sanded with oil, and even had some good-looking results with patinating wax -- fills the pores which then look like black dots. Another option is a seal coat of water-thin CA glue, then fine steel wool, then top finish, but that can get cloudy,too.
Keep in mind that violins are made mostly from fine grained species in side grain -- really glossy finishes used in furniture and cabinetry are also usually applied to side grain, with special attention and techniques for end grain.
The best-looking finishes usually take more time than a quick wipe-on poly. A slow-build finish built up from inside the wood will probably look better and have better durability than a shiny coating applied to the wood surface, and that does take more time. If you get a number of pieces started in a production line, and move each one to the next stage with each visit to the shop, you'll always have pieces coming out the other end of the process, much like green-turned bowls that take time to season.
>You mask the wood surface when you put things that are opaque on top of it. All wood fillers and sanding sealers are opaque to some degree. If you can't see the bottom of the can, it is opaque. They have to be sanded back until the filler and whatever solvents and thinners are in it are only IN the wood and there is no longer any of it ON the wood. Woodworkers always miss this important part of using fillers and sealers.
Filling the wood with the slurry made from sanding a wet oil finish is the better way to do it. This insures there is no color difference (like white), and all of the filler is IN the wood where it has to be. The rest of it is wiped away with the excess finish.
You can do this same wet sanding technique with shellac, lacquer, or CA glue. You just have to be faster than with an oil finish.
>Unless I missed it in all the advice, no one mentioned grain filler. It's a different product than wood filler. Wood filler is meant to fill nail holes, grain filler is meant to fill the wood pores. To get some depth to the finish, the filler should be tinted darker than the wood. Traditional woodworkers put on the filler, then take off the excess with burlap. I like to use a squeegee. This should work about as quick as multiple coats of wet sanded oil, maybe quicker. Water based is definitely quicker than solvent based. Here's a link to some product.
I suspect that you want a perfect finish, but expect to find it in a can. You won't. There is nothing fast about finishing wood. You get exactly what you are willing to put into it. Regardless what finishing product you are using, a beautiful finish takes a lot of time, elbow grease, and sandpaper. There is no shortcut. There is no magic bullet. All of the shortcuts and bullets exist only in the minds and advertising claims of the manufacturers who want to sell us stuff. The rest of have to either do what it takes, or accept something less than perfection.
I disagree that wet sanding with an oil finish can't leave a glass smooth finish. You just won't get there with only 3 or 4 coats sanded in. It will take about 10 or 12 more than that, and sanding with grits to 2000 at the end. 15 coats of Waterlox done this way will will leave the surface with a smoothness and gloss that is the equal to the finest spirit varnish (shellac) or lacquer finishes. But, always remember that those finishes weren't a 3 coat quickie either.
Go to the link if you want to enter the world of violin finishes. They are neither cheap nor fast. Violin makers spend weeks and months on their finishes.
>Agree Dave.... the other stuff is just wood "putty" for filling defects, such a loose fitting joints,etc. It won't work for filling pores in the wood. Typically, filler is thinned a bit, then worked into the grain, and wiped with burlap.
>If you use the pore filler and a oil finish will you end up with the filler buffing to a greater shine than the wood giving the piece a speckled look?
>Wally I did a few with Linseed oil. Mine must have been thinner than your because it took many many coats. I don't remember how many but it was too many to be useful. I did this rifle for my Dad so it didn't matter but I tried the True-oil after that and like it.
For turning I prefer the color of lacquer on most woods but then I don't do very many the kind of functional pieces you eat out of.